The real reason you see many PhDs fail to get private sector jobs is that they're expecting to be compensated for that PhD. But from the perspective of a hiring manager they're really just a recent grad with a superiority complex.
If you are willing to accept that your PhD does not catapult you into being a senior developer (particularly for startups), then you shouldn't have any trouble finding a job, assuming you are in fact a good developer (unlike many PhDs).
Also, if you're in dire straits, I recommend picking up a contracting gig. It's a great way to tide you over without rushing into the first job offered.
If you'd like to work in NYC, or want to try your hand at contracting, just write to me: morgante@cafe.com.