I have no idea if the same conclusions would be drawn by doctors today today, but I thought it is an interesting anecdote to share nonetheless.
They aren't the cause of brutality, but they probably are the cause, in a way, of concussions and lots of the cumulative damage -- but still an improvement over not having them. Specifically, the modern "complex helmets" are a direct result of a past crisis in fatal brain injuries in football, peaking in the 1960s, and directly reduced them, you probably wouldn't have so many people surviving with brain injuries during football when instead they were dying from much more serious brain injuries.
I wonder what the brain damage rates of players of a game like rugby are?
I don't. In all eras of football -- including the eras before pads and helmets -- the close-in part has been the most damaging and seen the most fatalities (especially before elaborate protective gear.) Rule changes designed to spread the game out specifically for the purposes of safety have reduced that overall, but the linemen are still in the worst of what remains.
> And yes I do think the damage done to linemen can be attributed to helmets
No doubt they would -- and did -- but "as much as possible" is unlikely to be enough to offset the increased consequences when it is not possible.
Its not like we haven't had football without, or with less effective, helmets.
The existence of special teams and having separate players for offense and defense also contributes to the problem. If the players were forced to play the whole game they simply couldn't be the wrecking balls they are now.
I suspect that helmets and padding are the reason we don't see more deaths at all levels of play.
Honestly I think facemasks are the biggest problem with the equipment and contributing to problems with it.
Still rugby is a great game and he loves it and I love watching him play.
[Scrums are the really scary bit of rugby as of the risks to players necks - fortunately he is a No 8. not a prop!].
I don't think reducing the impact of concussions by returning to the age of deaths by brain injuries from broken skulls is a way forward.
Given the fact that we have a history of both no helmets/padding and less or less effective effective helmets and padding with much higher death rates, I think that's fairly clear.
http://www.unh.edu/unhtoday/2014/11/keeping-their-heads-out-...