What biological advantage does a large family have over a small family in an affluent society?
What biological advantage does a large family have over a small family in an affluent society?
The definition of biological advantage is having a large number of offspring rather than a small one! (Simplifying a bit; said offspring should also reproduce, recursively, but it's a decent approximation to just consider offspring.) What kind of weird question is that?
Also, to bundle a reply to another of your concerns, of course you don't observe changes yet. If you have one population averaging 3 children per couple and another of equal size averaging 1, in the first generation it may not look like that big a deal, but by the fourth or fifth generation the 1-child-per-couple group has been effectively eliminated as a significant part of the population. Surprisingly small differences magnify surprisingly rapidly across generations; evolutionists have observed species going extinct because of far smaller differences than that. I just used large numbers to make the point more understandable, it applies equally to 2.1 children vs 2.15, it just takes a few more generations in that case... and not even all that many.
It also depends on whether there are malthusian limits applicable specifically to the population that is growing. It's unclear if this is the case in the modern world, but it certainly was the case in the past (availability of food in one place didn't prevent famine in another).
In this case, a higher birthrate could technically continue for centuries (or even millennia) before a reckoning, so you might have to go well beyond a single iteration of offspring to know.
There's plenty of debate about whether science can save humanity from malthusian limits, so the scenario I described might never come to pass. There are also other ways (wars, territorial conquest, mass immigration) for a high growth population to find a release valve.
All in all, though, I'm hopeful that the economist has this right - a non-coercive reduction in birth rates brought on as a natural response to increasing levels of global wealth, peace, and prosperity. Man, that would be an awfully nice way to avoid malthusian catastrophe. And while there's plenty to debate and disagree about, it's encouraging that the data does at least to some extent support this hope.
In animals, yes. Humans, especially in affluent societies have more sophisticated goals. Obviously, reproduction is important, but we will also pursue irrational goals, such as self-realization, quality of life, love, ethics and so on. The idea that we consider it a virtue to raise a child with Asbergers syndrome or other genetic defects is evidence to that, and in an evolutionary context decidedly self-destructive. In fact, I feel queasy even writing this, so strong is our opposition to applying our intelligence to raising the quality of our gene pool = eugenics.
My point is, although ill-articulated in a biological context, how does having a large family further any of the goals that a affluent individual in a wealthy society has? I'm not talking material wealth, even though that applies as well, but also the "soft" goals of contributing great ideas, science, arts, all the jazz, to the greater good of humanity. My point is; is a family with 10 kids more likely to foster a Miles Davis, Ernest Hemingway, Obama, Reagan, whatever floats your boat, than a family with one or two?
You seem to be trying to prevent this from being true by sheer volume of analysis. Evolution doesn't care about your analysis, either. It doesn't matter why some people have more children than others in an affluent society. It doesn't even have to be an integer number of children like "3" vs. "2", it only has to be a trend.
If you want to have a separate debate about how children impact your quality of life, than say so and have at it. It is from my reading of your other messages that I get the sense that you are almost willfully denying what other people are saying. Perhaps that is not true. But step one is to agree that in the end, it simply doesn't matter what the reasons are, only the actions and their results.
What I was trying to argue, clouded by my lack of understanding of the exact biological meaning of the word trait (i.e. something hereditary rather than a preference a person might have), was that there seems to be little evidence, which is backed by the statistics in the article, that a preference towards many children is hereditary.
Unless the ten kids are near starvation or are very restricted in how they are allowed to spend their time, the answer is that the family with ten kids is more likely to foster a notable person. Each child in the ten-kid family may have a somewhat reduced chance of being notable, but that family gets ten rolls of the dice instead of only one or two.
Like compound interest, it gets big surprisingly fast. Another example is that story of placing one grain of rice on the first square of a chess board, and doubling it for each square, so 2 grains on the second, 4 on the third, 8 on the fourth and so on. You end up with 2 64 (2 to the power of 16), or about 16 million million million grains of rice.
The engine of evolution is the ability of your decedents to continue to have children. If at any point all your decedents fail to have children then you fail. But, if your decedents have more children than the replacement rate over time, your DNA gets mixed with everyone else in that species. Once you become an ancestor 5,000 times removed from of 90+% of the population, most living people will have a random slice of the useful bits of your DNA and the harmful stuff should be less common.
Edit: DNA can also evolve odd stratagies. EX: Say each person has say a 23% chance of wanting a large number of children, which let's family's build resurces over time, and then have lot's of children and then repeat. With longer streaks of accumulators, and breaders possible even with the same DNA.
(The fate of such a gene is quite different if food is scarce and there's a danger of starvation, which has been the case for most of human history.)
In past agrarian cultures, a large family wasn't just an advantage, it was required due to high mortality. My girlfriends mother is one of eight, all girls. None of her aunts, and none of their children have an above-average number of children, and between them I think they're below average.
On the other hand, my sister and I are out of a ridiculously small family, and she just had her third baby. Plans for more are uncertain, but not ruled out.
It's a sample of two, but if nothing else, it shows that if it's a biological trait, it's pretty weak.