Why did Willie Sutton rob banks?
Why did Willie Sutton rob banks?
This is a good case in point. According to the article families who make less than $125,000 pay nothing and those who make $225,000 or more pay the full amount, listed as $65,000. Now let's take the hypothetical family where one parent makes $125,000 and the other makes $100,000 and look at what happens. If the second parent keeps his or her job, this is where the $100,000 salary goes:
28% federal income tax ($28,000)
9.3% California state income tax ($9,300)
Stanford annual cost ($65,000)
Total: ($102,300)
In other words, that parent is working a full time job in order to lose $2300. And that's assuming there are no other taxes or loss of benefits that come from the higher income, which there are, and that there is only one child in college.It seems like this can't possibly have been the intended outcome.
It's exactly the intended outcome. Progressive taxes and regressive subsidies are designed specifically to disincentivize earning income. To think these policies are implemented without actually thinking about both sides of the coin would take Hanlon's razor to the extreme.
As more people stop to actually do the math, and realized the mind-boggling treadmill that is the middle-class, not surprisingly the middle class shrinks.
The only reason keeping many in the game while they have school-aged children is some professions don't lend themselves to just taking 5 years off. But some lend themselves surprisingly well to that, and frankly I don't see an ethical dilemma in not working if the work has negative expected benefit.
Nope. Those families pay no tuition, but still may pay living expenses. The 'pay nothing' tier starts at $65,000
That doesn't actually make anything better. You're attempting to address the perverse incentive for one of the parents in the family making $225,000 to quit their job by pointing to a higher burden on the families making between $65,000 and $125,000, implying that it's less desirable to become one of those families. But the incentive is still there whether it preposterously exceeds 100% or only approaches it, and reducing it by making the burden on even less affluent middle class families worse can't possibly be the right solution.
Your calculation assumes a family could deliberately reduce their income by $100,000 in order to save $65,000 on their Stanford term bill, resulting in a (net gain of $2,300) but this is not correct. The savings are more like $45,000 (the cost of tuition).
But there are many, many things I didn't account for. The point was not to make a full accounting, the point was to present a back of the envelope calculation demonstrating what can hypothetically happen when programs are structured this way. If you want better researched numbers I encourage you to read this:
http://johnhcochrane.blogspot.com/2012/11/taxes-and-cliffs.h...
Those numbers also point out something else somewhat misleading about my example -- although it is possible (particularly with regard to education programs) for the upper middle class to be ravaged by excessive marginal tax rates, those most hard hit by means tested programs are really the working poor. Have a look in the first graph at the marginal rate on someone making minimum wage.
I'm not making any other claims about the merits of progressive taxation, price discrimination by universities, or economic policies affecting the working class. I'm just pointing out your error so that other readers don't rely on your calculations.
From the fine article:
"Stanford will expect no parental contribution toward tuition [~$45K for 2015-6] from parents with annual incomes below $125,000.... And there will be zero parental contribution toward tuition, room or board [~$65K for 2015-6] for parents with annual incomes below $65,000"
So your table should read: 28% federal income tax ($28,000)
9.3% California state income tax ($9,300)
Reduced Stanford FinAid ($45,000)
Total: ($82,300)
This is admittedly a very high marginal rate, but it is not negative.There is a realistic hypothetical family that loses more than they make in total regardless of whether the loss of Stanford financial aid is $65,000 or $45,000.
"In either case, students will still be expected to contribute toward their own educational expenses from summer income, savings and part-time work during the school year. Students are expected to contribute at least $5,000 per year from these sources but are not expected to borrow to make the contribution."
So its really $5K/yr even at $60K/yr and below, despite the glorious headlines. Its quite a downer to start with a fantastic headline and realize its all BS, although the truth of the matter is a pretty good deal. The article should have been more honest. Under promise and over deliver, as opposed to the opposite provided.
Was comparing this to my own state school numbers from 20+ years ago. One year was < $5k. Min wage at $3. One could work a summer job (or two) and pay for a year of school. That just doesn't seem possible any more, or at least not without a lot of assistance programs.
The other part of this is the inherent infairness of someone paying $65000 per year for Stanford. That's just insane. The price of something should not change based on someone's income. Why should someone making $225k per forced to subsidize everyone else? If the lower income kids want a BMW, should higher income families be required to pay for it? Going to Stanford isn't a right; it's a luxury.
Tuition, like tax rates should be the same for everyone. As it is now, the market responsiveness of higher education costs is distorted because of this cross subsidization scheme. If we eliminated all financial aid, Stanford would cost $8000 per. As it is now, universities have zero incentives to cut costs because many of them face no exposure to actual market forces. Whatever extra they want, they know students will just go deeper into debt.
It's a scam. How many Vice Provosts and Assistant Deans or "coordinators for diversity" does a university actually need? They could likely cut half of university administrators and it would make no appreciable difference to the quality of education.
Now turn your perspective around. How fair is the distribution of educational opportunity and, especially, networking opportunity with powerful people?
Progressive taxes don't do my income any good. But I wouldn't be in the position I am today without them; I grew up poor, too poor to own a family computer, never mind a family car. I still resent the lack of information I had about educational opportunities. And more than anything, I wonder what we could achieve if the impoverished of the world didn't need to scratch out subsistence living, and could instead apply themselves to the limits of their ability.
The right way to fund things like this is to give the same dollar amount to everyone but collect the same percentage from everyone. The rich still pay their share because a percentage of $20K/year is naturally much less money than the same percentage of $20M/year, but you discontinue the wanton destruction of the middle class, and as a happy consequence you also eliminate a lot of waste and frustration because if you give everyone the same benefits unconditionally then you don't need an invasive means testing bureaucracy.
The basic income + flat tax system is ethically superior but politically impossible. What's worse is we're still actively going in the other direction, to more progressive taxes and more regressive subsidies.