Why science instructors are so focussed on the inwards force (in the case of a tilt-a-whirl, it's the outer frame, in the case of orbiting a planet/spinning neutron star, it's gravity) to the exclusion of everything else never made any sense to me, and caused me know end of distress.
It probably came from the same place that suggested a charged item can attract a neutral object, but that a neutral object cannot attract a charged item. That made even less sense to me, but was right out of the book.
Needless to say, my high school physics instructor and I never really got along very well.
The goal is to help students break through assumptions and understand that our everyday experience results from interactions of forces, not just singular forces themselves.
A similar concept is the normal force. Everyone knows about gravity because they know what happens if they fall or drop something. But few people on their own will think of a force to explain why they are usually not falling.
It's like the joke that "it's not the fall that kills you, it's hitting the ground." Analyzed with Newtonion physics, that is literally true! My physics teacher used to say "gravity never killed anyone," which is the sort of counter-intuitive thing that drives teenagers crazy. But it's true--it's that nasty normal force you have to watch out for.
It makes an enormous amount of sense.
Telling someone there's no such thing as the centrifugal force in physics is a good starting point but you shouldn't stop there.
No, it's a terrible starting point. Maybe the worst possible starting point. "Here is something you know to be true that I am going to tell yo is false, creating confusion and a tendency to reject anything else I say as obvious nonsense."
End with the notion of fictitious forces (which do exist, so the name is terrible), don't start with them, unless you want to be like one of those dreadful people who talks about negative generalized temperature or negative generalized resistance to neophytes without first explaining the generalization, so you deliberately mislead people into thinking you are talking about the familiar, ungeneralized concept.
There is no evidence whatsoever that such introductions make anyone more motivated or able to understand, and a good deal of reason to expect they don't.
I've probably learned more about the topic from this HN thread than I ever did in grade 11 physics.
Forces push. Inertia is not a force. Inertia doesn't push.
What was completely left out of the entire conversation in High School physics was the concept of frame of reference. By leaving out even a 5 minute briefing on that, my physics instructor lost all credibility (from me, and probably half the class), claiming that something that actually existed, did not exist.
I disagree. It's not a real thing. If I pretend an acceleration that does exist doesn't exist, and then I realise that the only way I can make the mechanics work is by inventing a force to offset the force that's causing the acceleration I want to pretend doesn't exist, insisting that that invented force is "real" is just plain crazy.
It's a way to make the equations a bit easier. It's not real. There is nothing pushing anyone outwards. No atoms, no electromagnetic forces, nothing. There is no force pushing anyone away from the centre. To say that a force that simply does not exist, is "real", is just plain crazy or renders the word "real" meaningless.
Curious - which of the four forces are the source of the centripetal acceleration in a tilt-a-whirl?
There is a wall behind the person, right? We don't use the phrase "tilt-a-whirl" here in the UK (or at least, in my part of the UK), but I think I know the device you mean. This sort of thing: https://debrasanborn.files.wordpress.com/2013/07/flat550x550...
That wall exerts a force on the person, inwards. That's the force causing the person to accelerate (i.e. change velocity).
What we conventionally label that force depends on where you are in the world, I expect, but it's the interaction of the person's atoms with the wall's atoms. Electromagnetic, or electroweak if you want to go more fundamental.
The person's atoms, of course, are exerting a force on the wall's atoms, outwards. That outward force is not exerted on the person. The person gets an inward force.
The force exists because the person's velocity is tangential to the circle. Sideways, if you will. But there is something in the way. The curving wall. The wall gets ever so slightly compressed (much as when you put a book on a table).
(I've simplified a bit - the person's velocity is pointing tangentially, and if the wall vanished they would zip off in that direction; the bit of the wall in the way is what they push on, and obviously there's not a single point of contact, so the forces aren't quite so simple as "a force" that way, and "a force" this way, but when they've all been summed, you get what we see - a force towards the centre. Also, weight still exists, and I've ignored that completely)
PS: Apparently they aren't called tilt-a-whirls, but RoundUps. And they are a lot of fun.
https://www.google.com.sg/search?q=round+up+amusement+ride&s...
So, the definition of "force" he was trying to get across was different from the one created by Newton and used by every physicist and engineer? Why did he ignore Newtonian fictitious forces? Because he didn't want to explain them? If so, what was he doing there?
This is what happens when you have someone with no passion for a field teach out of a book/curriculum.