Is this a new development? This contradicts both a lot of things I read over the Internet (granted, those were not official SpaceX statements) and the apparently still ongoing plans to build a second barge.
Is this a new development? This contradicts both a lot of things I read over the Internet (granted, those were not official SpaceX statements) and the apparently still ongoing plans to build a second barge.
There might be a reason that people don't let me design large mechanical systems...
Naah, I can totally see this working in Kerbal Space Program...
The hard part is landing it softly enough and vertically enough that it won't break or fall over due to residual velocity. Once it's down, in low seas, the few degrees wobble of the barge won't have an effect.
Or in other words: I can't imagine SpaceX engineers haven't worked all this out in detail, and I can't imagine SpaceX would be trying this if they didn't have good reason to think it would work, and I can't imagine that SpaceX engineers aren't professionally competent, so, based on the standard "what I can't imagine can't be true", Shotwell is spouting irrelevancies.
This is the problem with imaginary arguments: if anyone thinks that what they can or can't imagine is relevant to what is true, they have to yield the argument to me, who can't imagine there is anyone in this day and age who still beleives that.
> the natural instability that occurs when a landing pad floating in the ocean has a very heavy rocket land on top of it has led to a series of near-misses for the technology.
But the two landing failures were due to running out of hydraulic fluid, and to a flight control instability; the landing pad had nothing to do with it.
From the Elon Musk AMA:
Q: How will you secure the first stage of the Falcon 9 to the barge when it lands? Gravity or some mechanism?
A: Mostly gravity. The center of gravity is pretty low for the booster, as all the engines and residual propellant is at the bottom. We are going to weld steel shoes over the landing feet as a precautionary measure
http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/2rgsan/i_am_elon_musk_...