What good is getting eliminated before than later? They eventually did reject them, all that shows is, they are also humans and not perfect in predicting the future by few questions in the applications.
Eliminating them earlier would have allowed a better qualified candidate to go through, a benefit to YC and to the other company.
There won't be many unicorns. They'll be one or maybe two, and it won't be obvious for a few years which companies they are.