I've noticed a lot of sites exhibiting these faulty semantics recently. For instance, twitter.com seems to have different content almost any time I refresh. Me and a colleague did a quick test, submitting a GET to Twitter at the same exact time. Her screen showed a completely different set of content. Strange and troubling.
Fortunately there are no HTTP requests going on that cause this behavior. It is done by JS, using Local Storage.
your expectation is fundamentally flawed for many reasons, but I'll stick with the most general: the Internet has no HTTP police.