Dave stated during the keynote that they were slimming down the number of permission categories.
So ... they're taking a terrible problem and making it even worse ?
Forcing them to ask every time will either show my concern is wrong (a good thing) or stop them doing it (even better).
M ready app, you get no permissions display up front but asked to approve on API use.
Older app, you get a permissions display up front and can disable API access in Android settings.
On older devices both M ready apps and older apps would behave like today, giving you a list of permissions up front and no way to control them (unless you are running a custom Android or the OEM added the possibility).