I upvoted you for your last sentence alone. What high school did you go to, and is it still heavily focused on Latin and Greek?
Picking up latin as an italian seems far simpler (and probably more useful) than as an english, as you can guess large part of the lexicon and you will be exposed to "volgare" (transitional latin-italian) when studying early italian literature.
But would studying Old English be of any use for italians? I am not sure.