Using Bayes' rule consistently will make you aware of how uncertain the inputs are, and that is a feature, not a bug.
Using Bayes' rule consistently will make you aware of how uncertain the inputs are, and that is a feature, not a bug.
Not that you should actually do mental calculations on made up probability estimates. I mean you can do that, and if your estimates are at all decent, the result might be better. But I don't think anyone actually recommends that.
http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/05/02/if-its-worth-doing-its-...
But in general, no one has enough computing power in their heads to go and do explicit bayesian updates on everything all day long. You have to pick your battles, and use the right tools for the task at hand.
Quite a lot of LessWrong posts are of the theme "my model gives this counterintuitive result" - the trouble is they go on to "AND THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT AND SIGNIFICANT!!" rather than "hmm, maybe my model needs work."