Hacker News Reader

Comment by seniorsassycat | Hacker News Reader

I'd like to see the justifications for some of these, particularly 3.5 which I see as only obscuring that the current context is a function.

Major advantage: fewer characters to type and parse (parse with your eyes, that is).

Major disadvantage: in the short term it might be difficult to parse.

Possible additional major disadvantage: programmers may never adapt and find it difficult to parse for ever more.

Yeah, I'm not sold on "fewer characters" as a win. 'cause then we can have the code golf arguments that inevitably get into the nutty realm.

For visual parsing, consistency matters. In an object literal dec I expect:

  name : value

That's easy to parse visually. Not good is when suddenly we get:

  nameandvalue(){

in the space that our brain expects the former.

Agreed. That's pretty obscure.