That's why they kept bringing up the situations with mod tools, lack of communication, and so on.
Reddit (the company, not the community) is NOT your friend and has no obligation to the community. Just like every other social media company out there, their fundamental goal is to make money, and serving the community isn't always aligned with that interest.
Which is why Digg is considered a such a success today right? Sure, the community is the product, but there is a breaking point where you end up losing the community.
Yay, this meme again. What a silly oversimplification. Of course reddit users are customers of reddit. Reddit does not exist without their continuing visits. Their ability to create meaningful content is part of the product, along with how reddit the site actually functions. But they are in no means not customers nor the only part of the product.
I'm surprised how often people on reddit say this, given what happened to Digg.
The only significant claim I'm making is that social media users are not customers/clients unless they are giving money to the websites. Mostly it's advertisers giving the money.
Also, I know that the content of social media websites is both created and consumed by users, but nevertheless the social media companies operate those websites, store and process the content, and provide the content created by everyone to everyone. This doesn't make the users into customers however, because they still aren't giving money to website. An analogy would be a TV show where the creators just gave the show to the network for free, and then watched it at home. Or maybe, a news station that films people's real lives and then uses that to sell ads.
As for Hacker News, we are also not the customers. Maybe you could argue that investors are customers, since HN is a promotional vehicle for YC. But, that's kind of murky.
The community around /r/askscience or /r/askhistorians perhaps. The community around /r/fatpeoplehate, /r/coontown, and /r/creepshots probably not so much.
If so, I really don't understand why there hasn't been an official justification yet. So much of the rage could have been defused by a prompt and earnest explanation of why she was fired. The fact that that hasn't happened seems to imply that the real reason would only make people angrier.
It is also, literally, none of our business. Did Taylor ask people to dig into her personnel story? In a situation involving something as private and sensitive and reputational as a termination, you would want more than tea leaf reading: you'd want an overt affirmative consent from Taylor that she wanted the world talking about what happened to her at Reddit.
Apologies if that's what's happened, but I haven't seen it.
It's not uncommon for a corporation to state why they are terminating an employee. GM terminates known engineers as scapegoats for negligence resulting in multiple deaths; many firms pre-announce mass terminations; some shut-down with no notice, save a publicly posted letter on the front door of their building telling the employees who show up for work that day that they no longer have a job ("sorry! but we tried").
Anyway, reddit left AMA out to dry by not arranging some kind of transition plan for the community, and instead created the perception of operating in secret to unknown ends.
It is very uncommon for companies to reveal reasons for employee termination. It may seem like that's not the case because the only termination stories you pay attention to are the newsworthy ones where the cause was stated, but that's an artifact of selection bias. Tens of thousands of people are let go every year from tech companies and their stories are never told.
Because I assume that Reddit management would prefer not to have a lot of their user base furious with them, and because a placatory answer (if one was available) would at least ease that a little bit.
But I do have a bad habit of expecting human beings to act like human beings even if they also happen to be corporate leaders.
Victoria signed a very comprehensive non-disclosure agreement, and would have to give up a decent severance;
and Victoria is uninterested in picking a huge fight in public because she'd like to be employed again.
If she was terminated for cause, Reddit has no obligation to reveal what that cause was, and neither does she. Leave them be, it's not really any of our business anyways.
That is a non sequitur.
> On September 6, 2011, Reddit became operationally independent of Condé Nast, now operating as a separate subsidiary of its parent company, Advance Publications.