There will have to be a number of cut-backs in retirement benefits for future retirees, including means-testing, removing the maximum wage for Social Security contributions, and higher Medicare premiums.
There will have to be a number of cut-backs in retirement benefits for future retirees, including means-testing, removing the maximum wage for Social Security contributions, and higher Medicare premiums.
If you remove the cap on contribution and/or means test the receipt then that pretense is gone. Politically, it becomes explicitly a welfare system for people that did not save for retirement and penalizes those that do save. Once Social Security is perceived as "unearned" it becomes an acceptable target for reduction or elimination to the population at large.
Social Security is in fact a welfare tax and no one is entitled to receive it (see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flemming_v._Nestor) but its political viability is dependent on the popular perception to the contrary.
Well, its a monotonically increasing function of your contributions, but its not proportional to them, because of the bend points.
> If you remove the cap on contribution and/or means test the receipt then that pretense is gone.
Means testing might arguably do that in theory (except that it empirically doesn't in practice, as SS is, in fact, already means-tested via the rules for taxability), but how does removing the contribution cap so long as further contributions above the old cap still contribute to the benefit calculation?
Ahh! So the question is, at what point will Millenials (myself included, at the older end of the spectrum at 32) say "f* it" when we're paying Europe-level taxes with third world country benefits
* Single-payer Medicare for retires, expensive private insurance for everyone else
* Social security essentially becomes a basic income for retirees, as its not an account that can be depleted but an entitlement until death, supported by younger workers with terrible job prospects and long hours at low pay
Maybe the problem is that no one saves enough anymore, but that's because no one makes enough to save because most new income/wealth is kept by the very top wealth bracket.
Subtract all of this from your income and look at most of Western Europe and you'll see we pay roughly the same overall.
I agree most people don't save enough. Part of it is people buy a lot of things they don't really need but "deserve" and the other is as you said.
Note that this graph doesn't include VAT which can be 15%+ in the EU.
[1]http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2012/10/focus-4
It also sounds like it doesn't count state and local income taxes, nor property taxes or any of the many other taxes we have the privilege of paying.
The conclusion may well be correct, but the data presented doesn't seem to be nearly complete enough to support it.
Employer contributions don't come out of your paycheck though; for the business, its a cost of doing business.
Other benefits (company car, apartment, fuel etc.) are subject to employee's income tax beyond a certain threshold.
Edit: Taking a step back, there is simply a fundamental difference between taxes and payments to social security / different insurances.
I think the "fundamental difference" is key. I don't ultimately see any real difference between taking 12.4% of my pay (under $118,500) for Social Security, and taking a variable percentage of my pay for government operations in general. It's money, based on a percentage of what I earn, that goes to the government, i.e. an income tax.
This sounds like a great idea to me. It's absurd that only the first $118,500 of earnings are subject to to social security tax, and it means that our tax structure is much less progressive than it appears at first glance (which is one reason certain people strenuously avoid talking about any taxes except Federal Income Taxes).