HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

086421357909764

294 karma · joined January 29, 2016

submissionscomments
086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
So does taking a vigilante approach to addressing these devices. It's no different than saying, there is crime in the inner city and It's my duty to handle it.
086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
Ok, lets switch this around. You just rented your new apartment, they didn't change the locks from previous tenant. Now, by default everyone knows you should change locks to include the owner, manager of property, and renter. I, the previous tenant decided to stroll by the house one day, I realize that the doors are still easily unlocked by my key, so I walk in and poke around. Realizing that this is a security risk, so following your logic, it's completely sane for me to destroy the house and prove that it's a risk. Before you say, that's different, MFG will replace a device, i'm going to argue ok sure, they'll replace it, by that same virtue isn't that what insurance is for? They'll replace the property.

Bottom line, vigilantism has a cost and picking and choosing morality of ideals based on your sole opinion is neither appropriate or legal. laws exist for a reason.

086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
So what's gained by bricking, disabling, or modifying devices, that couldn't be proven with a simple these devices are vulnerable announcement?
086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
What they get is irrelevant, it's someone using their skill set to make others aware of a flaw. I would argue it's the exact same premise. I'm going to phish people & cause them a financial cost to teach them to be safe.
086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
The point is how do you know the vigilante's fix won't have adverse side effects?

EDIT* I agree with the bulldozer analogy.

086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
I would argue, security needs to be a part of planning day 1 rather than looked at as a bolt on prior to involving upper management. It needs to be treated as a core functionality rather than an external concept. The biggest issue I see is we are patching and finding fixes for something that could easily be remedied if address before engineering takes place. Most firms i've worked with put it on the back burner or are stuck with the notion of i'm an engineer i'm smart so deal with it.
086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
How does your opinion change with Phishing attacks? I'm going to steal funds from businesses by phishing vulnerable people, because If I don't capitalize on it, then people won't understand the costs / risks.
086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
What would your perspective be if I took a stance to secure your vehicle, or the power company, or any myriad of others simply because I chose to?

What do you do when I change my logic to, well this is a ZERO DAY exploit, but you need to be patched, without understanding the complexities of your device or network. Which we all know QA takes a while because of variables. Look at any microsoft patch for evidence of that. Your argument makes it seem like if I decide to weaponize the Shadow Brokers toolkit to lockdown and secure networks around the globe, i'm ok because my intentions are good and manufacturers should have secure code without 0 days. What happens when a proprietary driver or component fails because of a change made to the kernel or the way it handles driver functionality? Now I've broken / disabled something because I didn't know the intricacies and instead chose to do what I thought was right.

"No good deed goes unpunished"

086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
I've brought this up to others, how would you feel if someone decided to brick / modify your car without you knowing? What would you do if that fix backfired and caused damage, hard locked the controls on your car, or worse, simply shut it off at the wrong time? We absolutely need to fix these issues, the governments of the world need to enforce standards on products, but vigilantism no matter how much you may agree with, has to be treated the same across the line.
086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
Sadly, they don't. What about a car that has vulnerable software? It's not a medical device but could have a real world effect if the same actions were taken.
086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
Where do you draw the line, I could argue because we know that certain vehicles are remotely hackable we should just disable all the cars without regard to their status of use. Literally 0 difference in argument, yet the results would somehow dictate a different response.
086421357909764··on Mylan’s EpiPen price hike was a scheme to stifle competition, rival claims
I think the argument here is that they were forced to sell the competing product to a new vendor (due to stifled competition) whom are now pricing at $4500, which they weren't.
086421357909764··on A vigilante trying to improve IoT security
It's all fine and well until one of those improperly configured devices are a medical device or something critical. Yes I understand that's part of the problem, but proving a point with risk isn't the right answer either. Every Dialysis machine i've seen runs windows xp, which any security professional will tell you is game over, but given the market hasn't provided an alternative, it's becomes a necessity to figure out how to protect these improperly updated / configured / designed devices.

Fandom of actions that impact others in a negative way is bad, and one day someone will do something they feel is right that impacts you and you'll say.. well that's not fair.

086421357909764··on In Bay Area, six-figure salaries are “low income”
It's also a very small subset of people that get those style offers. Every CS student I talk to thinks they're going to make the google prime salary, when the reality is they're not likely to make the cut as an average developer let alone the "silicon valley rock star". It's really a dis-service to the reality for most entry level and young developers. Additionally these crazy bootcamps aren't helping with their take a 12 week class get a job at google stories.
086421357909764··on Behind Carder Kingpin Roman Seleznev’s Record 27 Year Sentence
It's also been attributed that businesses had to close due to his actions. I believe one group of restaurants in Seattle in particular attributed his attack as the reason they had to close. It's not a crime that only affects banks. The impact hits everyone with further stresses and issues regardless of whom pays back in the long term.
086421357909764··on Leak Suggests NSA Was Deep in Middle East Banking System
Australia Is a five eyes country, Lookup Alice Springs, definitely looking at things.
086421357909764··on Switch Is Nintendo's 'Fastest Selling' System in History
Sadly I gave up and went back to RetroPie.. I'm not paying those crazy scalper prices either.
086421357909764··on Leaked NSA Malware Threatens Windows Users Around the World
Isn't that the Intercepts whole M.O. though?
086421357909764··on Russian FOSS activist arrested in Russia for his Tor exit-node
The Russians have had taps at every domestic and foreign (Rus-biz related) telco site for years through the SORM platform. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SORM

I would imagine that there is a level of capability that already exists beyond 2 years out.

086421357909764··on United removes first-class passenger to make room for 'higher-priority' traveler
It's sad to see that you've had this experience, but the Prime Minister specifically, that was a policy enforcement for a policy that was put in place with the previous administration. So sadly, it's not as new an issue as people think, it's been an issue for over 6 years.
086421357909764··on Russian FOSS activist arrested in Russia for his Tor exit-node
It's Russia, They don't likely believe him to be the culprit, instead they're trying to break down the spirit of the masses for using or the facilitation of TOR which they cannot control.
086421357909764··on Big Tech Company Salaries Are Hurting Startups
This is the right approach. Build a business you want to work at and your employees want to work at. Focus on maintaining operating costs and expenses, everything else is gravy. The buy in and work output isn't necessarily greater or worse than others, but I would argue the quality of life is through the roof. Kudos on what you're doing.
086421357909764··on Big Tech Company Salaries Are Hurting Startups
I think the distinction isn't making money as that's necessary to keep the doors open, it's more about corporate motivations. Some firms want to be a unicorn and some like where I work are more focused on building a business we all want to work at. While both are motivated, there are different buy in strategies with the employees. We have great growth, but we regularly turn down clients because they're not a fit for our team. I realize this isn't as feasible in all areas of expertise.

There definitely is a bit of marketing though and too much talk of culture is usually a good red flag.

086421357909764··on MakerBot says its new print process reduces times and costs by around 30%
After 4 Recent gen MakerBots and the whole Print head issue, MakerBot is on my list of products I simply won't buy regardless of their innovations.
086421357909764··on Broadband left out of infrastructure goals, and how the FCC wants to fix it
My thoughts are only in capacities that support the large incumbent ISP behemoths. I would imagine establishing standards and removing city / county ordinances restricting companies (outside of the big players) from installing services would be a bigger step. It's ridiculous to think that some cities want to provide better services but the lobbying arms of the big guys simply shut it down. We have plenty of people pushing to improve broadband, it's this incentive the rich, restrict the poor (relative to operating budgets) scenario that's only going to be exasperated by these types of counter productive rules.
086421357909764··on Google Fiber Was Doomed from the Start
What's the latency like with the service? We had a microwave transit link until our fiber was installed and we noticed that we had great speed but horrible latency on the whole.
086421357909764··on The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights
They're notorious for spiking demand by creating limited availability. They do it with their amiibo launches all the time. It's kinda sad really. They claim more classics are on the way though after the switch is stocked regularly.
086421357909764··on Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon deal executive team
It's very strange and I would argue it decreases your incentive for making more, which in turn generates growth in the economy based on spend.
086421357909764··on Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon deal executive team
I would argue requiring people to pay a disproportionate share of their income is absurd too.
086421357909764··on US spies still haven't told Congress the number of Americans caught in dragnet
Congress zeroing out their funding wouldn't necessarily kill them, it's a little more nuanced than that. For example, the CIA and Intelligence agencies by and larger are contributors to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-Q-Tel. Not to mention the funding they produce to generate funds within their black operations.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →