HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

0x500x79

459 karma · joined July 1, 2020

submissionscomments
0x500x79··on Two narratives about AI
There is a great article floating around on the economics of AI and how parasitic the current market is between the Fab Five.

We are 27-ish months since the claim that all software engineers would be replaced within six months by some of these CEOs. It is their job to analyze the market and determine what the next big thing is, but they can be wrong - no one has a crystal ball here.

The difficulty for me is how disconnected a lot of the takes are (or even flat out manipulative) that are being pushed out. I am an early adopter of AI tools. I utilize them on a day-to-day basis, but there is no way that I see AI taking SW jobs right now.

You have others claiming that these tools will just get exponentially better now, time will tell, but as of right now there is still too much value in human coders any anyone that is actively pushing for replacing SWE with "Agents" is either betting big on the future (that is unproven) or attempting to entice/manipulate the larger market.

0x500x79··on MCP is eating the world
Agree, but I think we should hold those Apps to a higher bar. Chat interfaces are not a replacement for good UX.
0x500x79··on MCP is eating the world
I don't think that the goal of MCP is for software developers.

MCP is great for: "I would like Claude Desktop/VSCode/Cursor to know about my JIRA tickets". AFAIK Most of the tools that are being used for AI Coding tools are not delivered through MCP.

0x500x79··on MCP is eating the world
It never fails that if you look at their title it's: VP of XYZ at something.ai as well!
0x500x79··on MCP is eating the world
I believe that MCP is a bit over-marketed.

MCP allows you to bring tools to agents you don't control. It's awesome, but it isn't the right match for every problem. If you believe the hype of X/LinkedIn you would think that MCP everywhere is going to be the solution.

Bringing tools to your local Claude client is awesome, but there are still challenges with MCP that need to be solved and like all technology, it isn't applicable universally.

Not to mention it's a recipe for burning tokens!

0x500x79··on Generative AI coding tools and agents do not work for me
Interns usually CARE as well.
0x500x79··on Generative AI coding tools and agents do not work for me
Great tools should be: 1. More efficient 2. Better Quality 3. Allow you to be lazier

AI hits 3, but not the other two. Given the current human condition, this is a dangerous combination! It will win, but at the cost of the other two.

0x500x79··on Generative AI coding tools and agents do not work for me
For one-offs, sure! Go for it. For production/things you will have to manage long-term I would recommend learning some of the space given the output of AI and your capability to surpass that pretty quickly.
0x500x79··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
Yeah, these 100x numbers being thrown out are pretty wild. It dawned on me during the Shopify CEO post awhile back. 100x is unfathomable!

You did a years worth of work in 3 days? That is what 100x means.

0x500x79··on GitHub MCP exploited: Accessing private repositories via MCP
The issue is that anything put into an LLM thread can alter the behavior of the LLM thread in significant ways (prompt injection) leading to RCE or data exfiltration if certain scenarios are met.
0x500x79··on Watching AI drive Microsoft employees insane
Agree, the problem is that investors and companies see developer salaries and want to cut that out. It's all bottom-line at the end of the day.
0x500x79··on Watching AI drive Microsoft employees insane
Theres a 3 point way to say this. Usually technology: * More efficient * Higher Quality * Less effort

Most successful technologies provide multiple of these benefits. What is terrible, and the direction we are going right now, is that these new systems (or offshoring like we are talking about here) seem/are "Less Effort" but do not hit the other two axioms. This is a very dangerous place to be.

People would rather be lazy than roll their sleeves up and focus, especially in our attention diverting world.

0x500x79··on After months of coding with LLMs, I'm going back to using my brain
I have also stepped back from LLM coding a bit. I still utilize LLMs for API discussions, maybe 1-off things I would stackoverflow before but I have stepped back a bit from autocomplete everywhere and even agentic flows.

And I feel more productive. I recommend that everyone gives it a try.

As a tenured SW developer in my company my measurements for success are much more than "how much code can I spit out". There are mentoring, refactoring, code readability/mantainability, and quality that are important to my job. I found that LLM generated code was not hitting the necessary bars for me in these areas (agent or code autocompletion) and so I have stepped back from them. The readability point is extra important to me. Having maintained million lines of code products, I have found that readability is more important than writing a ton of code: and LLMs just don't hit the bar here.

When I am playing with side projects that I don't have the same bar on, sure Ill have bolt or lovable generate me some code in combination with cursor or windsurf, but these are low stakes and in some ways I just want to get something on paper.

0x500x79··on Curl: We still have not seen a valid security report done with AI help
It should be called "Denial of Attention" attack!
0x500x79··on Maker of AI 'vibe coding' app Cursor hits $9B valuation
This is something that I think Copilot is working on fixing actively. I think that they were focused on Agent mode previously, so put less effort into the autocomplete functionality but they are hearing more and more that this is somewhere they need to focus.
0x500x79··on Cursor hits $9B valuation
I'm not sure that Andrej envisioned this when he tweeted out his Vibe Coding take what seems like forever ago now.

I applaud anybody who jumps into Cursor (or other AI Assisted Coding Tools) to build a new product. I think that a way to express ideas is awesome, and allowing for these ideas to materialize is valuable for society and users will determine what is valuable/usable.

However, it's well documented that the expression of these tools is limited. I think that the bet here is that LLMs will continue to get better and better, paving the way for these tools to become more valuable: which I haven't been convinced with yet.

At it's core you can list out the primary functionality of an AI Assisted Coding platform and how these components interact. Their prompts have been dumped, and the tools have been replicated, plus the big LLM providers are in this space as well and understand more nuances around the models and how they interact with the different components.

$9B seems bonkers, but time will tell. There are a few outcomes here: pop, life changes incredibly, or this is the stagnation period that seems to happen with AI/ML. LLMs have changed the way I work already, the question is "what is next". I am hoping that I am ahead of others on the Hype cycle, but only time will tell (from heavy use of AI tools).

0x500x79··on Google to buy Wiz for $32B
Agree with most of your points, the one correction (that I think is important) is that they were the fastest from 1M ARR - 100M ARR. Not a straight fastest to 100M.
0x500x79··on We spent $20 to achieve RCE and accidentally became the admins of .mobi
Can you point me to a blog or feature of them that does this? I used to work at R7 up until last year and there was none of this functionality in their products at the time and nothing on the roadmap related to this. It was all static content.
0x500x79··on Google-Wiz deal fizzles out, company will pursue IPO
There are a lot more factors that they will be subject to in an IPO that I think they could have avoided through this deal. IPOs/Stock market has not been kind to companies that do not have great margins and the current rumor mill has Wiz spending quite a lot in infrastructure costs to power their platform (a lot of it is built on Neptune and snapshot data transfer/processing is costly).

At the end of the day there were a lot of employees up and down the organizational chart that would have been very happy with this deal. So I wish that we could see the inner workings of what went wrong.

The constant rumor mill around Wiz keeps turning, and one starts to ask if there are nefarious actions at play.

0x500x79··on Figure out who's leaving the company: dump, diff, repeat
I worked at a company that had an internal website that showed all people, departments, teams, and had a filter you could use for new employees or employees that left. It was sort of a double edged sword: you had enough information to start asking questions about what it meant if a team member or coworker was on the list. What was more interesting is that it almost became ritual for some people to logon first thing in the morning and check the list, every morning.
0x500x79··on There are too many damn honeypots
At the end of the day the number of instances that are publicly available is just clickbait in an article. What really matters is whether or not this is being actively exploited in the wild. I have my own issues with Clickbait and dramatization of vulnerabilities, but I don't think this is necessarily something that we should be concerned about (as-in I think that this vulnerability is pretty damn bad and should be patched, regardless of if there are 2k or 200k instances).

Sure some metrics around "number of instances out in the wild" will determine if threat actors put resources into developing mass-scale exploitation, but if you are patching for a company it doesn't REALLY matter.

If you are a target and are exploitable it doesn't matter how many honeypots are reporting as Confluence -- you will be breached if your Confluence server is vulnerable and exposed.

The best argument against honeypots would be that if we had some active group that was working with all affected users to patch and verify patches, if that was the case then the honeypots are a detractor. News outlets should do their best to get the best information, but this is the least-worst thing around vulnerability reporting IMO.

0x500x79··on Changes at Riot Games and the road ahead
Breaking records does not mean profitable, having first hand knowledge of the situation esports (for Riot) is still very unprofitable -- the way that they try to measure esports profitability is by player increases/purchases after the events occur and leading up to the events and sponsorships of course.

esports does not bring in new players, it mostly brings back churned players or excites current players. The financial model for existing players versus new players is very different.

When you look at some of the sponsorship conversations over the past couple of years it makes sense why they needed to make some of the bets (https://www.polygon.com/2020/7/29/21347587/riot-games-saudi-...).

0x500x79··on Two pharmacists figured out that oral phenylephrine doesn't work
Another thing -- if you are ever need Sudafed (the real stuff) and they are out ask for one of the allergy medicines, the -d version. Claritin-D, Zertec-D all have the primary active ingredient as Sudafed bundled with the Allergy medicine.
0x500x79··on Xbox will block third-party controllers to "preserve the console experience"
Once you get into certain skill levels in matchmaking it is very common to run into cheaters, depending on the game. If you think about above average lobbies, the number of cheaters will go up until you get to another MMR threshold just due to the fact that the cheats enable people to move up MMR. The average low MMR players will see less, and the top of MMR will see less, but the middle-upper bracket cheating is very, very bad.

Companies are trying to battle this with anti-cheats, heuristics, shadowbanning, etc but it is still noticeable at above-average MMR.

0x500x79··on Xbox will block third-party controllers to "preserve the console experience"
> Again this is just not true - the revenue and profit of casual games dwarfs competitive games.

This is actually very, very true. Most esports departments are not incredibly profitable (I actually worked for one of the biggest esports gaming companies for a long time and it was a constant source of friction how much money was spent on esports versus the return on it).

At the end of the day, cheating is a dopamine hit: killing the whole lobby in 2-seconds by holding down a button makes people feel good and you can't fight against that without some pretty drastic measures.

0x500x79··on Xbox will block third-party controllers to "preserve the console experience"
I think the metric is blocked controllers, which is a small subset of 3rd party controllers. So far the most common people complaining about this change is cronus and xim users not legit players.

Most 3rd party controllers that are being sold online are still compatible afaict.

0x500x79··on Xbox will block third-party controllers to "preserve the console experience"
It is not all 3rd party controllers. It is "unauthorized accessory" controllers which excludes devices that are part of the "designed for Xbox” hardware partner program.
0x500x79··on Xbox will block third-party controllers to "preserve the console experience"
Possibly, I think the math on number of people that currently purchase controllers that will be blocked in the future is a very small amount of money compared to the possibility of losing that revenue to other gaming sources if that is the reason.

"Preserving console experience" really feels like corporatespeak to say "cheaters" without saying the devices in question (because then it raises visibility to those devices).

I think the "doing this for money" is the people who are currently not gaming due to rampant cheating in games like R6S, Apex, COD, etc.

0x500x79··on Xbox will block third-party controllers to "preserve the console experience"
This has always been my thoughts as well, and it seems like they have the data required, but I always think they are worried about some false positive issues. These companies should have the resources to build deployable models for this.
0x500x79··on Xbox will block third-party controllers to "preserve the console experience"
I think that this is a response to the rising usage of the Cronus and/or other controller modification tools that give players advantages (cheats).

For example one of these "Mods" for Cronus state that they are:

a dynamic, fully-automated Anti-Recoil system that transforms your in-game character into a laser-guided juggernaut we've affectionately dubbed as [BEAM]

Battling cheaters in video games is a never-ending chase, but I appreciate that they are attempting something.

I wish that a gaming company could figure out a less invasive way to detect these cheaters.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →