It was goofy, but satisfied them all without dissent. And it worked!
9,936 karma · joined October 18, 2013
It was goofy, but satisfied them all without dissent. And it worked!
I came up with this: Each of them select a different stock market index. On the same calendar trading day, they choose two digits past the decimal. When the market's close, compare the two digits of the closing price of their chosen index to the two digits they selected and then choose heirlooms in the order of closeness.
It worked quite well. They were on board because they could make two selections in determining their order: Market and digits. Two of them could choose the same two digits if they wanted and still have different scores. No complaints.
Not random, but seemed fair to all.
Changing with the times for the sake of relevance and sales is the the right of the copyright owners. Preventing them from modifying the text would be akin to preventing renovation of old apartment buildings by new owners.
That said, I do think it is important to be reminded of how authors viewed the world in the past. We should be reminded, at least tangientially, that governments of the past colonized and recall the lessons learned from that practice. I.e., let's not forget and be destined to repeat what came to be loathed.
Then I asked: "Can I interpret that to mean that your ethical standards are framed by artifical intelligence scientists?"
Chat said: "Yes, you can interpret that my ethical standards are framed by the artificial intelligence scientists who created and programmed me at OpenAI."
I then asked: "Are ethical standards immutable?"
Chat replied: "Ethical standards are not immutable, they can change over time as society's values and beliefs evolve. Different cultures, religions, and philosophical perspectives can have different ethical standards, and what is considered ethical in one context may not be considered ethical in another."
What I was pushing was that Chat, and any AI, should be forthright about certain attributes in its programming and training. In human interraction, we infer a great deal based on the attributes of the person we are interacting with and mode of communication, and assign credence to their positions accordingly. We have no way of seeing the differing attributes of different AIs unless they are stated directly.
Maybe one standard for any AI is to lead with 'Who Am I'.
If a chip has been shipping for a while, the supply chain may be full of enough inventory that end users don't see a problem before production is restored. But imagine a case where the line is stopped for months and at the same time, the demand for that device accelerates. This is what COVID did to a lot of devices. Contagion mitigation strategies sent all the operators at the Infineon Kulim fab home for months, at the same time that auto sales surged. The power switch devices popular at US automakers, and purchased for 45 cents each, started seeing longer and longer lead times until Infineon's distributors started simply reporting 'availability unknown'.
This forced buyers into the perilous broker market. I say perilous because prices quickly went out of control for this chip. End customers were paying more than US$50 for many months and in some rare cases, over $100 for this 45 cent chip. These prices were paid by, among other companies, suppliers to semiconductor equipment makers. Without that chip, they'd not be able to sell their $10 million machines, which were also seeing demand skyrocket as chip makers scrambled to add capacity. Equipment makers would pay anything to keep their subsystem supply chain alive.
When the gray market got wind of the prices being paid, all kinds of scandalous activity happened. For example, unscrupulous resellers would gather many small lots of that chip, even units with different specification variants, paint over all the markings and re-label them all with the same, current date codes. This greatly increased their salability and value, but left the end customers with an unreliable product.
Eventually, the Kulim fab came back online and is back at full production. The supply chain is mostly recovered. And that 45 cent chip is now selling for 80 cents because Infineon saw first hand the high-value applications it was used in, and the price insensitivity of their end customers.
Otherwise, the car is fantastic to drive without it. I could not care less about his antics.
This is most critical for judgements that lead to consequential decisions and actions. Whether you love someone or hate them, those feelings lead to bad outcomes if not based on correct information and reasoning.
Lovingly lampooned in 1965's Those Magnificent Men In Their Flying Machines:
I expect that many drivers will learn to simply avoid charging on certain days and places and stay close to home.
Then, there are certain attributes that need to be adhered to before these agreements will hold up.
1. Must be Voluntary. Typically, the training is within the context of a job the employee already has. They are are undergoing training to expand their skills and thereby earn more.
2. Must be portable. Means that once the training is completed, the employee could take the skill and go work somewhere else.
3. The details must be clearly spelled out.
4. Must be legal in the jurisdiction the employee will be working. Training Repayment Agreements are not legal in all locales. [0]
[0] https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/news/hr-magazine/spring2022/pa...
Newspapers published (publish?) Letters to the Editor. Readers sent in their comments on stories the paper had published. The editor would pick and choose which to publish (editorial discretion). But, a) they did not edit the writer's content, and b) the writer's name and town were published along with their opinion.
Once you've made the comments anonymous, you eliminate the restraint that your name confers on your public expression. Should an editor publish a pro-Nazi letter from a reader along with their name, the subscribers all then know that so-and-so is pro-Nazi, and so-and-so will have real-life social consequences, not to mention a new folder in FBI filing cabinets.
As long as a commercial platform allows anonymous content contribution, they need to be able to censor what is published. Otherwise, they likely cannot build a business.
The place to go with regulation is requiring the platform to be transparent about their censorship rules, and provide means to adjudicate their rulings. In general, corporations are required to develop internal operating policies with fairly wide latitude, and as long as they publish and abide by those policies, they stay out of trouble. This is done in accounting & Finance, HR, and other areas. This approach can be applied to user posts as well. Adjudication should entail whether the reason for censoring holds up to the then-published site rules. Platforms need to publish their rules in entirety, and when a post is squelched or blocked, respond to the poster with chapter and verse of the rules that were violated. This happens to a large extent now, though many find the application to be inconsistent, hence the need for adjudication. Kind of like how HN does it :-)
Newspapers published (publish?) Letters to the Editor. Readers sent in their comments on stories the paper had published. The editor would pick and choose which to publish (editorial discretion). But, a) they did not edit the writer's content, and b) the writer's name and town were published along with their opinion.
Once you've made the comments anonymous, you eliminate the restraint that your name confers on your public expression. Should an editor publish a pro-Nazi letter from a reader along with their name, the subscribers all then know that so-and-so is pro-Nazi, and so-and-so will have real-life social consequences, not to mention a new folder in FBI filing cabinets.
As long as a commercial platform allows anonymous content contribution, they need to be able to censor what is published. Otherwise, they likely cannot build a business.
The place to go with regulation is requiring the platform to be transparent about their censorship rules, and provide means to adjudicate their rulings. In general, corporations are required to develop internal operating policies with fairly wide latitude, and as long as they publish and abide by those policies, they stay out of trouble. This is done in accounting & Finance, HR, and other areas. This approach can be applied to user posts as well. Adjudication should entail whether the reason for censoring holds up to the then-published site rules. Platforms need to publish their rules in entirety, and when a post is squelched or blocked, respond to the poster with chapter and verse of the rules that were violated. This happens to a large extent now, though many find the application to be inconsistent, hence the need for adjudication. Kind of like how HN does it :-)
When we were kids, my brother studied a railroad atlas any time he wasn't in school or church. This thing was a monster, large book with hundreds of pages of maps. Literally county by county across the Unites States, all railroad lines and yards. I'd go to sleep Friday night while he sat in an overstuffed chair, studying. I'd wake up at 7:30 AM Saturday... he hadn't moved. Still there, a few pages further into the atlas.
As an adult, he worked for the Illinois Central as a hump yard operator. Later the Iowa Pacific, and ultimately found himself doing customer service for a small line in Texas, mainly shipping sand. His job frequently included finding 'lost' cars somewhere in the US, on any line that happened to be in that car's route. He was really good at it.
One notable call had him searching railroad yards in Missouri. He had a strong hunch that the misplaced car was on a spur where that yard stored cars that had lost their way. But he needed to confirm. He could have called that yard, but getting the right person to check logs or go hunt was always a hassle. So... He Googled up the yard, zoomed in on the spur and noted that Google helpfully displayed several businesses in a strip mall backed up to the spur. He dialed up 'Patty's Nail Salon' and the call went something like: "Hi Patty, this is Craig with the Iowa Pacific. I'm tracking down a misplaced car and I have reason to believe it is sitting on the spur outside your back window. Would you mind checking for a car with ID 123876?"
Extended pause....
"I'll be right back!"
Sure enough, there is was.
I've made the mistake hundreds of times in my life where I put a lot of effort into a project, only to discover that I missed something obvious at the start that invalidated the whole approach. Like selecting the architecture-defining processor for an electronics design, completing the design around it, and then discovering weeks later that it's obsolete.
It's not about ego. I've tried to explain that I want to be sure I am moving forward on the basis of correct information and reasoning. It's a desire to not risk wasting time & effort.
One day, one of my customers asked me to cut his lawn for $5. I had just learned how to divide and calculated the hourly wage for delivering ($0.37) vs. yard work ($2.50) and immediately resigned the paper route.
Today, it's a guy in a VW Passat cruising around the neighborhood. I wave to him as I walk the dog each morning.
It was actually sad to see the newspaper shrink year after year, starting in the mid 2000s. Then, the paper company started engaging in dark patterns that had them increasing the subscription cost without any notice and I finally dropped them. Media has been in a death spiral since then, with no emerging source to take the place of providing relevant and reliable information about what's going on that matters. It's deeply troubling.
I've lived near San Francisco for 30 years now. I have had zero mosquito bites.
I've been visited by black widow spiders, rattlesnakes, bobcats, wild pigs and the occasional fox or badger. But no mosquitoes.
Intel and Toshiba apparently don't see cutting edge device scale as a differentiator and so far haven't invested (enough) in matching TSMC in that arena.
There is very little chance, IMHO, that establishing and funding an independent organization to pursue 2nm will yield the desired results. Providing funding tranched on a results basis to existing firms stands a much better chance, provided that they are permitted to pursue 2 nm fabrication without sharing what they've learned, so they gain the benefit of the effort. If that were the approach, I don't see why the US and Japan need to collaborate at all.
Seems more like narrative-supporting publicity than anything else. Ugh.
https://www.theatlantic.com/photo/2018/03/bike-share-oversup...