HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

1_player

8,196 karma · joined March 30, 2011

Jack of all trades, master of none.

hn@combo.cc

submissionscomments
1_player··on Origin of the Bluetooth Name
A huge amount of people have him as their 30th-something great grandfather.

Somewhere in the ballpark of (average # children that grow to adult age per family) ^ 31

1_player··on High carbohydrate intake, not fat, was associated with higher risk of mortality (2017)
It certainly did for me + IBS goes away after just a week on it. Gas is passed once a week, if at all. It's hard to argue that my gut is extremely happy when eating an extremely restricted diet. Digestion is a non event.

And no, you don't _need_ fibre. I'm right in the middle of the Bristol stool scale with zero fibre. Another thing that scientists are uncovering right now but "you need fibre, fibre is good" keeps being parroted by everybody because someone said so 5 decades ago. Such is dogma.

1_player··on High carbohydrate intake, not fat, was associated with higher risk of mortality (2017)
Healthier than what? "Healthy" doesn't exist in a vacuum.

Fat is healthy in a vacuum, fat with a carb heavy diet causes metabolic syndrome.

Fruit is healthy in a vacuum, but anything containing fructose, fibre or not, isn't great when you have metabolic syndrome, insulin issues or non-alcoholic fatty liver disease.

Plenty of nutritional studies are completely worthless for this reason. There is no double-blind, randomised and controlled dietary studies.

1_player··on High carbohydrate intake, not fat, was associated with higher risk of mortality (2017)
The issue with talking nutrition with people is that they think one size fits all and that the body and its digestion is a simple machine we have fully understood.

Like you are preaching that meat gives too much iron and is bad, while in my experience decades of eating gluten have caused nutritional imbalances, one of which is called iron-deficiency anemia, and causes brain fog, tiredness, pallor and shortness of breathing. More meat and iron supplements (rarely) gives me an amount of energy I haven't felt in a decade. I've found this out for myself because even medical doctors keep repeating advice ("you should eat less red meat and more whole foods" is the MD's mantra) which doesn't respect one's own physiology and weren't able to track this down.

Yes, people can thrive on a diet of Mars bars, but it's not that simple and doesn't work for everybody. And I'd be more worried about heavy metals on a pescatarian diet than any other diet, vegan or otherwise.

1_player··on High carbohydrate intake, not fat, was associated with higher risk of mortality (2017)
Potassium deficiency is very rare, and causes arrythmias and other electrical problems just like ingesting too much of it.

I think you mean magnesium, whose deficiency is widespread and it is though to be caused by depletion of it in the soil due to intensive agricultural practices.

1_player··on High carbohydrate intake, not fat, was associated with higher risk of mortality (2017)
The vast majority of nutritional studies are based on epidemiology and pretty much useless. Since diet is so hard to control for, it looks at aspects of the diet of a group of people and tries to determine which variable are correlated with specific outcomes.

Most nutritional science is a whole load of crap. Which is why I invite anyone to learn and experiment with their body. The stakes are low, the benefits potentially great and it's easy to tell what feels good and what doesn't. It's not science, but again, most of nutrition isn't either.

1_player··on High carbohydrate intake, not fat, was associated with higher risk of mortality (2017)
I've updated my comment with reddit resources. Read on the science as well, learn about it.

It would be hard for me not to be in a caloric deficit. Meat and fat are incredibly filling, and once your body switches to ketone bodies and then fatty acid oxidation for fuel, it learns that, if you're overweight, you're carrying a ton of fuel ready for use. It's hard to explain if you haven't experienced it, but it actually feels _good_, as opposed to the regular carb and insulin dance.

1_player··on High carbohydrate intake, not fat, was associated with higher risk of mortality (2017)
3/4 of what I eat is organic, pasture-raised beef, pork and lamb from family owned farms, the rest is meat from supermarkets just because it's cheaper and sustainable meat is hard on the wallet. I hate cooking, I hate having to do it twice a day, so for me it's mostly grill/oven/pressure cook and eat 500g of meat twice a day with a little salt and spices. If I feel the need for more energy, butter or high quality organic ghee is added. Hunger is non existent, and I figure I'm naturally eating at a 20% deficit, because I have fat around me and my body knows it. Blood sugar perfectly stable at 5.5mmol/L, which feels incredible.

But vegs works great as a treat. Today I had a simple salad with my steak and it was lovely, though I'm a little gassier now.

If you use Reddit, look into /r/carnivore or /r/zerocarb.

1_player··on High carbohydrate intake, not fat, was associated with higher risk of mortality (2017)
I eat some, but very little. 99% of my calories comes from animal foods.

I do not think they are _unhealthy_, but there are some benefits in restricting them in some cases. In mine, cures _my_ digestive and mood issues. One is caused by whacked intestinal flora, and once your gut is completely destroyed, nutrient malabsorption caused by phytates and other phytochemicals worsen into systemic issues, including mood disturbances and inflammation. In my case, the experiment has been an absolute success, but I often succumb to the temptation of a pizza and I'm 5 steps back.

Long term, I will reintroduce some as they are benign, but grains are actually bad for me. Gluten is even worse, again, for me.

There is more, but this is good enough for an internet comment. The science is a google search away.

1_player··on High carbohydrate intake, not fat, was associated with higher risk of mortality (2017)
Now we need two decades before all the studies of the past 10 years are common knowledge and I can buy full fat yogurt in my corner store, but right now it's only stocking reduced fat ones with added sugar, because some pillock in the 50s construed the idea that saturated fat is going to kill us. Sorry, but the obesity epidemic isn't because everybody is eating butter.

/r/ketoscience has plenty interesting studies about high fat low carb if you're interested in doing your own research. And I'm a big fan of the "Low Carb Down Under" Youtube Channel for latest research talks.

https://youtube.com/c/lowcarbdownunder

1_player··on High carbohydrate intake, not fat, was associated with higher risk of mortality (2017)
I'm on carnivore, and although fruits are no-no (for me at least), in my own research they're better than grains and other vegetables. Unlike leafy vegetables, most fruits are evolved to be eaten by animals, and have the seeds pooped out or discarded in the ground. That's why they taste so fricking good. Though evolution didn't make them this big and full of sugar, we did. And then we juice them so you can consume 20 apples in one sip, and call that healthy.

In my eyes and personal opinion, the diet we are most genetically optimal for is high fat, mostly carnivore, with seasonal fruits and berries, and remembering that modern fruits are nothing like what we have been eating for hundreds of thousands of years. And ideally insects, though they weren't a huge part of our diet. We after all are big herbivore hunters and scavengers.

1_player··on Crows may soon be Sweden’s newest litter pickers
Then the crows will learn to distribute free cigarettes hoping people will pick up smoking and throw empty butts on the street.

See the Cobra effect: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive

1_player··on Alder Lake Core i9 processor is faster than the M1 Max
I've used Windows 10 on a 4K monitor at 200% for a couple years and I didn't have any issue. macOS' scaling works best, but Windows has been HiDPI ready for a while, and only a small handful of old apps need you to enable the application-scaling option manually. Especially since Windows still runs 15 years old applications that use crappy old APIs, while macOS doesn't.

It's not fantastic by any means, but it's a disservice to call it _horrible_.

1_player··on Ask HN: Why the obsession with note taking?
I have ADHD and for me note taking has always been a novelty; like todo lists. I get excited about it, I forget about it the next day. Most days I kept thinking "I should write this down", and then didn't. But now that I am _diagnosed_ with the thing, I will try and make more use of note taking, since I'm made aware my memory isn't great.
1_player··on An ad plugin was stealing revenue for a year and I didn't even notice
AdMob indeed. It does what it says on the tin.
1_player··on Ketogenic Diets and Chronic Disease: Benefits vs. Risks
> hard to follow because of the high fat

It really isn't, it's just a matter of adapting your taste buds. If you're used to fries and muffins daily, yeah it can be hard, but as someone from Southern Europe used to snacking on salami and cheese and butter, reaching 80% calories from fat isn't hard at all, especially considering that fat is more than 2x more calorie dense per gram than protein and carbs, so you don't need that much of it. A steak with a little butter gets you there easily.

1_player··on Ketogenic Diets and Chronic Disease: Benefits vs. Risks
Plenty of studies on ketogenic diets on rats are based on adding an incredible amount of fat on top of carbohydrate heavy and call it ketogenic. /r/ketoscience has these crappy studies posted and debunked daily. Serious research on low carb is sorely lacking and plenty of interested parties really do not want for good science to be done around high fat/meat: the money's on plant based these days. I am still salty about that sorry excuse for a study the Lancet posted a few years ago and is still making headlines.
1_player··on Ketogenic Diets and Chronic Disease: Benefits vs. Risks
> Very-low-carbohydrate diets may lack vitamins, minerals, fiber, and phytochemicals found in fruits, vegetables, and whole grains

What a load of bollocks. What vitamins and minerals are lacking in meat? Only one, vitamin C, and there is evidence the RDA for it is much lower if you don't ingest many carbs. The Inuit didn't get scurvy. And in any case vit C heavy plants and fruit are definitely OK on a low carb diet.

And no fibre and phytochemicals (literally "plant chemicals")? It's by design. None of these things are essential, and some find improvement in their autoimmune diseases and digestion when these are reduced or removed altogether. My digestion gets better and better as I approach literally 0g of fibre, provided my carb consumption is low of course. High carb low fibre isn't fun.

1_player··on Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
> Also, are you eating much insect protein yourself or are you more hoping other people will do it one day?

The latter. The only insect protein I can find for human consumption is far more expensive than the pasture-raised organic meat I primarily eat. Sadly, I'm too used to modern Western cuisine to stomach eating an insect that hasn't been ground down to fine powder, but I will definitely buy some if/when prices are more reasonable.

1_player··on How the gut differentiates artificial sweeteners from sugars in mice
And the taste of Coke Zero over both, in my case.
1_player··on Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
If the goal is reduction, the target is total reduction, no? Going vegetarian and consuming eggs and cheese still makes use of these darned animals that keep polluting our atmosphere. The suggestion of vegan diet is implied in this context.

Personally I hope insect protein becomes more widespread, makes more sense to me nutritionally than completely avoiding animal nutrients for chemical vegetable pastes people want to promote as meat substitute these days.

1_player··on Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
> Moreover, the food we "evolved to thrive on," was likely primarily nuts, seeds, fruits, insects, rodents, and occasionally larger animals like antelope (which would have been eaten nose-to-tail), not fatty steaks from domesticated animals.

Citation needed. My sources mention the fact that we've evolved bigger brains when we've moved from low-density foods such as vegetables to high-density fatty foods, which is what distinguishes our diet from what primates eat. Meat is fatty, vegetables are not. In fact, vegetables are "fatty" for ruminants, as they have specialised bacteria that convert plant matter to fatty acids. We do not.

https://www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/evidence-f...

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fat-not-meat-may-...

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK53561/

Just a couple articles from a 30 second Google search. The fat == bad, or worse, meat == bad is a modern argument that has nothing to do with our evolution or our physiology.

Here's the thing no one wants to admit: modern meat is bad for the planet, and we humans thrive on meat. We don't know how to reconcile the two, so we keep promoting and pushing towards worse and worse diets. Sorry, a vegan diet for everybody isn't the answer. There is no simple answer.

1_player··on Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
And considerably smaller carbon footprint than industrial emission and cars. The vegetables and grains grown 5000 miles away are being brought via land and sea thanks to petrol right to the vegan store one goes to shop at with their SUV.

But yes, let's demonise the food we've evolved to thrive on. It's mental that this has become a controversial idea worth censoring.

1_player··on ImageGlass added malware with this commit
Sorry for being unable to sympathise with these developers but: if you want to make money out of it, make your users pay for it. How is this rocket science? It's not even incompatible with the principle of open source.

One thing is adding a paid plan after you decide you want to monetise your software, it's unpopular but understandable, another is bundling malware or adding malicious logic to get some money or "protest" because companies aren't paying you. They knew this is how open source worked, and being a twat because they don't like those terms anymore just ruins their reputation and all the goodwill they've built.

1_player··on Rnote – A note-taking application for drawing tablets, written in Rust and GTK4
Do not try and initiate a flame war on a totally innocent thread. It is not appreciated and against the site guidelines. Move along.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

1_player··on Iosevka – Versatile typeface for code, from code
Yes, far too many monospace fonts are too wide on the x dimension, while Iosevka is one of the few that has a slightly condensed look to it. Pragmata Pro is another one.
1_player··on Show HN: AskPaulGraham
It's hard to convey sarcasm with text.
1_player··on Using marijuana may affect your ability to think and plan, study says
Yes, one necessary requirement for the diagnosis of ADHD is for it to be present since young age. There is no adult-onset ADHD, but there are plenty of factors that can cause ADHD-like symptoms in adults. Perhaps heavy marijuana consumption is one of them, and that same substance is used by people with actual ADHD to self-medicate (getting high -> dopamine increase)
1_player··on Using marijuana may affect your ability to think and plan, study says
Executive function disorder, which is what this article says marijuana causes, is also thought to be a much better name for ADHD. It is not much about hyperactivity or attention, but more a chronic lack of dopamine which affects the executive function system of the brain.

I find this interesting and wonder whether many stoners are self-medicating. I know I've smoked so much I've come to hate it and it's caused what I thought were long term memory and executive issues, yet I've recently been diagnosed with ADHD, to my surprise. Were I self-medicating, or did weed made a part of my brain worse? Honestly, I have no idea. I don't think there's an easy answer yet.

1_player··on Ask HN: What are options to replace “G Suite legacy” when it's retired in May?
The iOS app is meh, the webmail is much better but otherwise I'm a happy Fastmail customer and they're 100% worth the money.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →