Lawyer here. Thisis correct but it highlights an important aspect if the thing that I am actively trying to pursue.
Garbage in, garbage out. Right, everyone knows this.
So, my question is, if I redline a document, I don't just see what's there but also what is missing.
Ai generally only work with what's avoailavle and unless you specifcally ask for it, it wont question it.
Take a rental agreement for example. I have tested this before, gave a redlining task whatever, and the draft did not have either a start date clause or a period Claude and none flagged it.
A lawyer would find this easily.
What I am trying to say is, among other things, you get a DMCA notice for example and you use Claude to file a reply, it will find all the proper citations, statutes, etc but if the other side didnt invoke a point, Claude will have no way to object to that because it isn't in the notice.
That is my only issue.
The problem compounds, if a person later reviews it, they skim over because they expect other people to have done their job first....