HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

3grdlurker

331 karma · joined March 8, 2021

submissionscomments
3grdlurker··on 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy
To participate in consumerism and capitalism, correct?
3grdlurker··on YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking all anti-vaccine content
I’m not a believer that vaccine science is a matter of “public” debate. It’s scientific debate, where only experts who have the tools, experience, and knowledge to argue should be allowed to weigh in. If you already have the problem of bad actors misappropriating yet-to-be-verified “scientific” claims for their own political agenda, then I don’t see why it’s right to let those ideas go out there.

I believe that people only have the right to speak their own opinion, but have none to spread disinformation.

3grdlurker··on 200k-year-old hand art found near a Tibetan hot spring
Even if it were true that societies today are more complex, why is that inherently more special than a time in the past when life was simple? How come so many people today long for a much simpler life, like in the past, as if the past was special? The point is, special is highly subjective and you really should be doubting your own notions of it.

In any case, I think that the original commenter really referred to how there’s nothing so drastically different about the experience of being human in the present and in the past.

3grdlurker··on Apple threatened Facebook ban over slavery posts on Instagram
Because right now we only have the capability to regulate content where it is stored and after the fact of its storage, hence Facebook. But your suggestions are all great ideas—all forms of on-device scanning which, last I checked, HN was all up in arms against when it was Apple who was about to do it.
3grdlurker··on Apple threatened Facebook ban over slavery posts on Instagram
Why stop at Apple? We understand that there is a government that is making companies liable for moderating their user-uploaded content, correct?
3grdlurker··on Reasons to Quit Social Media
Technically what you’re doing is ad hominem—invalidating the arguments of the post by attacking what the author does for a living. It’s not even necessary that someone who makes (possibly extra) money publishing insights is out for validation—there really are just people who are willing to pay for insights and he’s simply fulfilling a demand. Anything else beyond seeing what he does as simply business is pure speculation.
3grdlurker··on An appeal for an objective, open, transparent debate re: the origin of Covid-19
.
3grdlurker··on There won’t be a Goddamn creator economy if we don’t invest directly in creators
I think your comment is even more odd (and detached, really) since it’s coming from the assumption that the current system is fair and not curated or incentivised by biased algorithms.
3grdlurker··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
I think that that’s just an excuse, considering how we didn’t stop when we finally knew.
3grdlurker··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
I can only wish that more people realized that we didn’t have to start with something so destructive before we could “get better eventually”.
3grdlurker··on Facebook apology as AI labels black men 'primates'
Well how do you know that the image recognition error is a fault of the ML algorithm (because we can’t capture how organic minds learn, as you are suggesting) and not of the learning sample?
3grdlurker··on Facebook apology as AI labels black men 'primates'
Couldn’t you apply the same way of thinking to finding a cure for AIDS, or doing interstellar travel, or P = NP, or pretty much any problem that we haven’t solved yet? Just because we can’t solve a problem within our lifetime doesn’t mean it’s not solvable at all. This is one of the most basic principles by which knowledge, and therefore, technology, progresses.
3grdlurker··on Pavel Durov: Most studies show humanity is now less free than several years ago
But that’s the point—there will always be people who do want to live in a state where something is being done about CSAM down to their personal devices, while there will always be people who don’t. So which of the two groups are objectively right to have things done their way? It’s neither, and whoever wins on the policy level is a matter of politics, not of objective moral correctness.

So then since you can’t always have it your way when you’re living in a society, isn’t it that the only other option to have things your way is for you to live alone, all consequences entailing? Therefore, isn’t the argument for the full exercise of individual freedom an argument for the dissolution of society and ergo government? Because this topic seems to me about the full realization of individual freedoms and not making any compromises at all.

3grdlurker··on Pavel Durov: Most studies show humanity is now less free than several years ago
I think that there’s a question not being addressed here.

The things you’ve pointed out to be “taking away” your individual freedom are things that you have to put up with when you’re choosing to live in a society or a civilization, i.e. in togetherness with other people who do not have the same preferences as you. This scenario is inherently rooted in conflict, and everyone has to make compromises if everyone wants to live peacefully. If you don’t want to have to put up with other people then your only choice is really to just live alone in a forest where you can exercise your near-total individual freedom.

So since there seems to be a genuine binary between living a life of compromises in a society and living freely but like an hermit, aren’t we actually advocating for the dissolution of society when we’re talking about exercising our individual freedoms? Government and laws are, after all, just manifestations of how people in a (democratic) society want to run their society, but it’s not like we can draw a clear line on where government control and regulation should end, no? Because not even all democratic societies are the same.

3grdlurker··on A Screeching Voice of the Minority
I agree about how the technology can be applied to other instances, but I feel that people who are criticizing Apple are crucially placing all the blame on Apple but not on the government that pressured them into doing this in the first place. This CSAM issue is proof that if even the most valuable company in the world can be pressured into compliance, then any company in the world could be, calling into question whether it is realistic in the first place to expect companies to act ethically while also creating highly profitable products.

For all the things that have been said about the issue, I don’t remember a single comment that has been directed at the US government, or China itself, or any discussions about how nation-states should be run and genuine introspections on what could prevent surveillance states from existing in the first place.

3grdlurker··on Even my bigoted critics deserve free speech
I've seen people deliberately seek to offend marginalized groups with their language, though, and then they cry out about being cancelled and how speech is no longer free when the people they provoked naturally respond to and fight back against their posts.

I don't believe that people have become less tolerant. I think that the reality of disagreement as a fact of life has just been amplified by the constant connectivity afforded to us by social media, and people (especially those who like to provoke debates) have a hard time accepting that not everyone is going to agree with them, and that there are real social costs to deliberately positioning oneself as edgy or unpopular or hateful, as there has always been.

3grdlurker··on What happens to your brain when you give up sugar
> It means you're addicted to cheap carbs.

How do you know this?

3grdlurker··on A few useful Xcode debugging tricks
I love this technique, but it can be very slow for large apps that have a less-than-ideal state of code cleanliness or architecture-and I assume that most apps fall under that category.

For tracking gesture and scrolling events, though, breakpoint debugging is outright impossible to work with, and good ol’ print statements are still the best tools for the job.

3grdlurker··on Apple's child protection features spark concern within its own ranks: sources
> Apple is engaging in this activity of their own free will for sake of their own commercial gain and are not being incentivized or coerced by the government in any way.

Honest question: how do you know this, for sure? Or is your comment supposed to be read as an allegation phrased as fact?

3grdlurker··on There’s a crack in the iPhone foundation and it could get a lot worse
I don’t think that trusting a corporation is any good either. Imagine the alternate scenario where the government is benevolent and has no interest in surveilling its citizens. Companies in this case still have an incentive to gather as much data as they can from their customers because the ability to manipulate people into patronizing their products is a competitive edge.
3grdlurker··on For programmers, remote working is becoming the norm
You see it as OC making excuses or not having discipline, I see it as you wasting valuable time by taking it upon yourself to do things you can ask or pay others to do for you. You might as well reprehend OP for working smart because you work unnecessarily hard.

I mean, the attack is so deeply personal yet you don’t know anything about OC’s circumstances. Maybe OC knows how to cook a little but he really sucks at it? Or he’s just not interested? Or he doesn’t have as much free space at home as you do? There are so many possibilities and you’re very quick to blame it on discipline, lol.

3grdlurker··on Big Tech are supposed to be the plumbers, not patricians of internet discourse
Isn’t this just a consequence of American capitalism? Incentivise companies to optimize for profit, and they’ll do anything to rake in more ad money including violating people’s privacy and curating user-submitted content. We’ll have to fundamentally rethink entire economies before we could see large companies (if they would be, at all, allowed to exist) acting ethically.
3grdlurker··on Life before smartphones (2020)
That last sentence is the most confusing thing I’ve read today, and I still don’t know what you mean by it.
3grdlurker··on The recycling myth: A plastic waste solution littered with failure
The problem isn't just "white people telling brown people what to do", though that's certainly one aspect of it. The more important issue, though, is that there's no way for developed countries to significantly "drive change" in other countries without undermining the sovereignty of the latter through some kind of bribery or debt trap or predatory trade deal.
3grdlurker··on The recycling myth: A plastic waste solution littered with failure
Commenting to save
3grdlurker··on The recycling myth: A plastic waste solution littered with failure
Absolutely, I just made the wording a little bit """moderate""" to avoid debates I'm not in the mood to have, but I agree.
3grdlurker··on The recycling myth: A plastic waste solution littered with failure
OK, we need to be specific that most of the plastic that end up in oceans and landfills are those called "single-use", mostly used in food packaging.

> all of the human advancements in sanitation, food safety, and transportation energy afforded by plastics

The pollution negates the health benefits of sanitation and food safety though, especially in the places where they are dumped, which are in rural communities in developing countries, whose people are somehow expected to make a living out of it for themselves and for their children.

Besides, there are so many uses of plastic in food packaging that aren't even necessary to begin with, and which shouldn't exist. How much of single-use plastics are just bags of unhealthy junk food and candy wrappers and carbonated soda? Is it even necessary to have such a large economy based on unhealthy food sources?

3grdlurker··on The recycling myth: A plastic waste solution littered with failure
Buddy, that wasn't even a comment on his tone.
3grdlurker··on The recycling myth: A plastic waste solution littered with failure
Is it just the cost/benefit ratio that you have to consider? How about the quality of being realistic? Tell me, and in the context of the previous responses--how realistic is it that North America will be able to carry out and enforce its agenda in the Ganges?
3grdlurker··on Where has all the productivity gone?
Science discoveries don't just happen because there are more people "competing" to solve a problem. The more likely outcome of what you're saying is that you'd only have more teams competing, sure, but to redo each other's work.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →