HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

8fingerlouie

1,749 karma · joined May 1, 2017

submissionscomments
8fingerlouie··on I ditched Spotify and set up my own music stack
It may not be theft, but it is stealing :

---

Stealing: the action or offence of taking another person's property without permission or legal right and without intending to return it; theft.

---

Regardless if there is anything physical missing, you're still obtaining something for which you don't have the ownership rights, therefore another persons property.

And somewhere there's a starving artist that would get $0.25 per purchase that now gets nothing, so you could argue that you're stealing from the artist.

8fingerlouie··on I ditched Spotify and set up my own music stack
So i decided that Spotify/Apple Music/Tidal/whatever doesn't pay enough money to the artists, and instead i decided to pay none.

gotcha.

8fingerlouie··on The Synology End Game
I remembered wrong. I’m fairly certain that Synology, at some point, allowed you to store the encryption vault on an external (USB) drive, but apparently not anymore.
8fingerlouie··on The Synology End Game
The filename limit comes from ecryptfs (https://www.ecryptfs.org/) which is what Synology uses for encrypted shared folders.

As for full disk encryption, you can select where to store the key, which may be on the NAS itself (rendering FDE more or less useless) or on a USB key or similar.

8fingerlouie··on The Synology End Game
> Multichannel CIFS/SMB)

My DS918+ has multichannel SMB and possibly also parallel NFS. It only works if you have multiple NICs connected.

Other than that, i completely agree. Their tech stack is horribly outdated, and while i understand their reasoning for not upgrading, there's a limit to how long you can do that. Their reasoning is that they know the software that's currently running, warts and all, and can better guarantee stability across millions of devices with fewer moving parts.

8fingerlouie··on Word documents will be saved to the cloud automatically on Windows going forward
I think the main competitor for Microsoft Office is Google, which indeed defaults to saving documents in the cloud.

Apple, as far as i know, still gives you a choice.

8fingerlouie··on Sequoia backs Zed
> You can continue to use that version of Sublime Text until the end of time.

Or until some change in the underlying OS makes it no longer able to run. Not saying that happens frequently, but it does happen.

> I'll stop there. Those are just the largest, most user facing new features, not any of the new settings, new APIs or improvements that I'd argue are new features.

New font pickers, settings dialogues and other "polish" is hardly what i'd call new features. I listed those as "improvements".

I'm not trying to start a fight, and i respect the work that has been done, but VS Code releases more features in a month that ST has released in the entire ST4 lifecycle, as does Zed. I understand the team is (a lot) smaller. My frustration is that when a new release comes out, it's mostly polish, and not fixing the real problems, such as lack of integration and plugins.

You may choose to brush it off as just an old fart rambling on the internet, but i'm not alone with this opinion, and i have ST licenses dating back to the original version, and i have chosen not to renew my ST4 license. When you start losing the "religious" users, maybe it's time to reevaluate ?

8fingerlouie··on Sequoia backs Zed
ST is also all but dead.

They switched to a subscription model (3 year licenses are still subscriptions), and since the release of ST4 in 2021, there has been exactly one release with new features (May 2025). All other releases have been bug fixes and "improvements".

I get that developers need to make a living, but 4 years of fixing bugs in your products is probably not what I want to be paying for, at least not when that is the only thing I'm getting. Speaking of releases, they're also usually 6-12 months apart.

I have used ST ever since the first version replaced TextMate for my use (TM2 spent something like a decade catching up to ST2), but I've since switched to Code and Zed (mostly Zed as of late, Code on windows until Zed is ready there).

ST was great back when it was still an actively maintained product, but in recent years (ever since ST2) it has felt like it was mostly on the back burner and other editors have passed it in functionality.

As for VC funding, it has done miracles for Code to have Microsoft sponsor it (and others). Code is currently the editor to beat for anything that doesn't involve opening large files.

8fingerlouie··on Electricity prices are climbing more than twice as fast as inflation
My local electricity infrastructure provider is a private company, with the twist that all residents within their area are also automatically shareholders.

They operate "for profit", but profits are distributed amongst shareholders in the form of reduced bills, ie last year we didn't get bills for electricity transport for december, and the year before that there were no bills from august through december.

The "for profit" part pays infrastructure upgrades, so some years we pay the normal prices if there is infrastructure work being done, which in the end benefits all shareholders, meaning me (and other users).

8fingerlouie··on Streaming services are driving viewers back to piracy
>I didn't even mention that it's free or that there are no ads

It's free in the same way shoplifting is free, until you get caught. You are very much in violation of copyright laws if you pirate.

8fingerlouie··on RISC-V single-board computer for less than 40 euros
Just open the link in private browser mode. Any cookie you accept will be cleared when you exit the private window.

If you're using Safari (and possibly others) they also (attempt to) anonymize your browser fingerprint, making it harder to track you.

8fingerlouie··on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers
Sure, run a homelab as a hobby. Everybody has hobbies.

Once your user count goes beyond 1, you suddenly have a SLA as people are dependent on your services. Like it or not, you are now the primary support staff of your local cloud business.

The more users you get, the more time you will need to spend to fix problems.

At which point does it go from a hobby to a 2nd job ?

8fingerlouie··on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers
I'm willing to bet that far more data has been lost to people serving their own data, than Google has lost data.

In any case, you should always make backups regardless of where your data is stored. At home, your biggest threat is loss of data, probably through hardware malfunction, house fires or similar.

In the cloud your biggest threat is not loss of data but loss of access to data. Different scenarios but identical outcomes.

Backup solves both scenarios, RAID doesn't solve any of them, but sadly, many people think "oh but I've got RAID6 so surely I cannot lose data".

8fingerlouie··on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers
I thought they were.

If you need to commute to work daily, and you're concerned about the cost, you don't really care if you're comparing a city car vs a sports car vs the bus, despite on goes at 80km/h, and another can do 230km/h, if all you're interested in is the price.

Obviously as your storage needs increase, so will cloud costs, but unless you're a professional photographer, I'm guessing 2TB will be more than enough for most people.

Again, not talking about people trying to run their own media server on pirated content, and saving money that way. In my book that's comparable to saving money by robbing a bank. You're not saving anything, you're breaking the law, and 9 out of 10 times, it's cheaper to steal someone else's bike than it is taking a taxi home.

I'm talking actual storage for data you actually own, and possibly even data you have created yourself. Anything that came from the internet can be found on the internet again, purchased or naval acquisition.

8fingerlouie··on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers
You can fit A LOT of photos and videos in 2TB.

My wife is a professional photographer, and while we do archive most of her RAW files somewhere else, pretty much everything HEIC, JPEG or any other compressed format lives in our main cloud.

We have 2.2TB in total for “direct storage”, and we’re currently using around 1.5TB, and that’s including myself and our kids.

My personal photo library has just short of 90,000 photos, and about 5,000 videos. My wife’s library is roughly twice that. I have no idea how many photos the kids have, but they each take up around 200GB for photos.

And then we have backups, which actually take up about 1TB per person, mostly because that’s the space I’ve allocated for each, so history just grows until it’s filled. Photos ideally won’t change much. We backup originals along with XMP metadata for edits, so the photos stays the same, and changes are described in easily compressed text files. Backups of course also have deduplication enabled.

8fingerlouie··on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers
do you need more space than 2TB ? (excluding things you've downloaded from the internet)

Very few people i know has use for that much storage. Yes, you can download the entire netflix catalog, and that will of course require more storage, and no, you probably shouldn't put it in the cloud (or even back it up, or use redundant storage for it).

Setting up your own homelab to be your own netflix, but using pirated content, is not really a use case i would consider. I'm aware people are doing it, and i still think it's stupid. They're saving money by "stealing" (or at least breaking laws), which is hardly a lifehack.

8fingerlouie··on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers
Yeah, northern scandinavia has plenty of renewable energy.

As for electric heating, that is true in 1:1 heating scenarios, but i assume you guys are also using heat pumps these days, and while you still get heat "for free", it will not be anywhere as efficient as your heat pump.

Yes, it's probably peanuts in the grand scheme of things, i know our air to water heat pump in Denmark uses around 4500-5500 kWh per year, so adding another 100 kWh probably won't mean much.

8fingerlouie··on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers
How many services do you need ? And how much CPU power do those services need ?

I've also self hosted for decades, but it turns out i don't really need that much, at least not public.

I basically just need mail, calendar, file storage and DNS adblocking. I can get mail/calendar/file storage with pretty much any cloud provider (and no, there is no privacy when it comes to mail, there is always another participant in the conversation), and for €18/year i can get something like NextDNS, Control D, or similar.

For reference, a Raspberry Pi 4 or 5 will use around 50 kWh per year, which (again in europe) will translate to €15/year. For just €3 more per year i get redundancy and support.

I still run a bunch of stuff at home, but nothing is opened to the public internet. Everything runs behind a Wireguard VPN, and i have zero redundant storage. My home storage is used for backing up cloud storage, as well as storing media and client backups. And yes, i also have another cloud where i backup to.

My total cloud bill is around €20-€25/month, with 8TB of storage, ad blocking DNS, mail/calendar/office apps and even a small VPS.

8fingerlouie··on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers
As a bare minimum, you should update your server and docker images daily, or at least whenever there's an update (which you won't know unless you check).

If you only access your homelab over VPN or similar, then by all means, update whenever you feel like it, but if you expose your services to the internet, you want to be damned sure there are no vulnerabilities in them.

The internet of today is not like it was 20 years ago. Today you're constantly being hammerede by bots that scan every single IPv4 address for open ports, and when they find something they record it in a database, along with information on what's running on that port (provided that information is available).

When (not if) a vulnerability for a given service is discovered, an attacker doesn't need to "hunt & peck" for vulnerable hosts, they already have that information in a database, and all they need to do is start shooting at their list of hosts.

You can use something like shodan.io to see what a would be attacker might see (can check your own IP with "ip:xxx.xxx.xxx.xx".

Try entering something like Synology, Proxmox, Truenas, Unraid, Jellyfin, Plex, Emby, or any of the other popular home services.

8fingerlouie··on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers
How much space do you realistically need high availability, redundant storage for ?

For my personal use case, that involves photos and documents, all things i cannot easily recreate (photos less so). Those are what matters to me, and storing them in the cloud means i not only get redundancy in a single data center, but also geographical redundancy as many cloud providers will use erasure coding to make your data available across multiple data centers.

Everything else will be just fine on a single drive, even a USB drive, as everything that originated on the internet can most likely be found there again. This is especially true for media (purchased, or naval aquisition). Media is probably the most replicated data on the planet, possibly only behind the bible and IKEA catalog.

So, back to the important data, i can easily fit an entire family of 4 into a single 2TB data plan. That costs me somewhere around €85 - €100 per year, for 4 people, and it works no matter what i do. I no longer need to drag a laptop with me on vacation, and i can basically just say "fuck it" and go on vacation for 2 weeks.

8fingerlouie··on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers
While i get the whole homelab thing is exiting and a great learning experience, it's simply not worth the time and effort for the majority of people.

You will end up paying much more for your services, along with spending a ton of time maintaining it (and if you don't, you will probably find yourself on the end of a 0-day hack sometime).

In Northern/Western Europe, where power costs around €0.3/kWh on average, just the power consumption of a simple 4 bay NAS will cost you almost as much as buying Google Drive / OneDrive / iCloud / Dropbox / Jottacloud / Whatever.

A simple Synology 4 bay NAS like a DS923+ with 4 x 4TB Seagate Ironwolf drives will use between 150 kWh and 300 kWh per year (100% idle vs 100% active, so somewhere in between), which will cost you between €45 and €90 per year, and that's power alone. Factoring in the cost of the hardware will probably double that (over a 5 year period).

It's cheaper (and easier) to use public cloud, and then use something like Cryptomator (https://cryptomator.org/) to encrypt data before uploading it. That way you get the best of both worlds, privacy without any of the sysadm tasks.

Edit: I'll just add, as you grow older, you come to realize that time is a finite resource, and while money may seem like it is finite, you can always make more money.

Don't spend your time hunched over servers. Spend it doing things you love with people that matter to you. Eventually those people won't be there anymore, and the memories you make with those people will matter far more to you in 20 years, than the €20/month you paid for cloud services.

8fingerlouie··on The future is not self-hosted, but self-sovereign
I fully agree with the points the author makes about self hosting. You’re not liberating anybody and you’re just creating more obstacles for sharing data.

Sure, if your user count equals one, then go ahead, but as someone who has self hosted for 2 decades, trust me, you’re only making it harder. As soon as you want to share data or collaborate on data, you’re forcing another person to download and use a specific app, and you’ll be managing a bunch of users.

Add to that the fact that the internet is not a friendly place, and you’ll really cannot just take a lax stance to security. Everything needs to be top notch and patched.

Personally I’ve long since moved to public cloud. It doesn’t matter where my data is hosted as long as I have a backup of it, and everything stored in the cloud is encrypted (where applicable) before uploading it.

As for the didspaces product, isn’t that just what Resilio Sync and Syncthing did a decade ago ?

8fingerlouie··on 1 in 3 US teens have prediabetes, new CDC data show
Maybe the younger generation has learned the lesson, but many people 30 plus still drinks 1-2 liters of the stuff every day. Many 20 plus year olds I know also drink energy drinks like it’s a miracle drug, when all it really is, is soda in disguise.
8fingerlouie··on 1 in 3 US teens have prediabetes, new CDC data show
Admitted, i'm an old fart, but when i was a kid, cake was something we had on sundays, sodas was something we got at a birthday party, and we had one, maybe two, and meals were rich in protein and fat, with carbohydrates usually being at the bottom. We spent the entire day outside, riding our bikes, playing (as in physical, not computer), riding skateboards, etc.

These days it almost feels like sugar has replaced a lot of the protein and at least some of the fat, and we eat a lot more of it.

Sodas are no longer a "monthly" event, but a daily event, and people will happily drink 2-3-4 sodas per day (or more). In our food, a lot of the protein has been replaced by sugar and fat as well.

And instead of running around, playing on the streets, kids these days sit in front of a computer/tablet/phone/tv/whatever.

8fingerlouie··on 1 in 3 US teens have prediabetes, new CDC data show
It's probably a combination.

30-40 years ago, sugar wasn't in everything, or at least not in the levels it is found today. People also chuck down liquid sugar like there's no tomorrow, which is also something "new" that wasn't around 30-40 years ago.

People today are less active, eat much more calories, many in the form of sugar, and many in the form of fat.

The main problem is, even if you wanted to go back to a "1970s diet", you probably couldn't today. Processed food is everywhere.

8fingerlouie··on Bitchat – A decentralized messaging app that works over Bluetooth mesh networks
The 30% also covers refunds, legal stuff (not stuff IN your app, but regarding the sale of it), taxes, GDPR and much more. The infrastructure running the app store probably also isn't cheap.

I'm not saying Apple doesn't profit from it, but they're not just pocketing every penny.

As for "quality", they mostly check that your app isn't using unauthorized APIs, or doing other scetchy stuff, like leeching all of your data. They couldn't care less if your app is bad, thats' between you and your potential users.

Does it work ? apparently so. Apple catches around 2 million apps every year that are rejected for those reasons. Android has about the same amount of apps, but there they're caught by Kaspersky (and others) after they're published.

That doesn't mean that malware isn't making its way through the App Store review, the damage will be somewhat limited if it can't use private APIs.

I should add that here in the EU, where we’ve had 3rd party app stores for over a year, nobody uses them. The absolutely biggest one, Epic Games, has attracted about 29 million users across both iOS and Android, out of a population of 450 million.

8fingerlouie··on Next month, saved passwords will no longer be in Microsoft’s Authenticator app
Passkey is literally an open standard under the FIDO alliance.

https://www.yubico.com/blog/10-things-youve-been-wondering-a...

8fingerlouie··on Next month, saved passwords will no longer be in Microsoft’s Authenticator app
Absolutely, passkeys couple a trusted device (typically a phone with HSM) with asymmetric encryption.

HSM ensures that the device is actually the device it claims to be, as the key cannot leave the device, and by coupling it with biometrics, which is authentication, you prove to the device you are who you claim to be.

So by the device authenticating you, the device by extension can authenticate you against the remote site using a cryptographic challenge.

There is no vendor lock in however. You can use a password manager like 1Password to store passkeys, or even Apples keychain supports synchronizing the passkey across devices (including windows). KeepassX also supports passkeys, so it’s not limited to official vendors like TPM.

As for HSM, you can also use something like a Yubikey.

8fingerlouie··on Next month, saved passwords will no longer be in Microsoft’s Authenticator app
That kinda leaves (current) biometrics in a gray zone, as fingerprints and faces can be regenerated.

You literally leave your fingerprint on every surface you touch, and faces can be covertly photographed.

8fingerlouie··on Next month, saved passwords will no longer be in Microsoft’s Authenticator app
Well, biometrics usually act as a proxy for PIN codes, so the PIN code is something you know, the private key is something you have, and biometrics is authentication.

And yes, nitpicking :)

← PreviousPage 5 of 27Next →