HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

99052882514569

657 karma · joined August 23, 2018

submissionscomments
99052882514569··on Stress That Doesn't Pay: The Commuting Paradox (2004) [pdf]
The problem with that logic is opportunity cost. What improvements to public transit could have been done with that thick wad of cash? Often (usually?) ones that would open up options and mobility to far more people.
99052882514569··on The programmer behind the THERAC-25 Fiasco was never found
Where did someone assume that the programmer was to blame? How do you find out if the High On Totem Pole Man is to blame if you can't depose the Low On Totem Pole Man? You can't. You are forced to take the High On Totem Pole Man's word for it.
99052882514569··on Free Online Courses from Top Universities
>Geoff Hinton on Neural Networks.

Brilliant as a researcher, not so brilliant as a teacher.

99052882514569··on Programmers can’t write algorithms without help
This is infuriatingly stupid. Not only does that waste your time (which we can be uncharitable and say they don't care about), but it wastes their time! i.e. costs lots and lots of money.
99052882514569··on Who does that server really serve? (2010)
In addition to paid SaaS(S), to which your comment applies, there are also 'free' SaaS(S), where you're not taking the role of customer at all. Instead, you're taking the role of product, or your data is. You are the product to be sold to the platform's actual customers or used to benefit the larger company in some other way (e.g. Google Photos). I don't think it's an existential problem by any means, but one has to be cognizant of this fact.
99052882514569··on The American Dream Is Alive in China
Are you trying to say all states use coercion, or actually trying to draw parallels between Chinese and US government's methodology for suppressing dissent? Because if it's the latter, they are not comparable. You wouldn't even hear of a Chinese soldier who did what Manning did, regardless of motivations and how wrong the military's exposed actions were. Neither would his family hear about him, ever again. People have been executed in China for far less, sometimes simply for losing a high-stakes political game.

The larger point I was trying to make is that having the rule of law usually moderates the severity of repression, sure, but it's not just a difference in degree. It's a difference in kind - it prevents arbitrary oppression. You can fault the US for suppressing whistle-blowers/leakers, but you cannot tell me those whistle-blowers/leakers simply stumbled into their actions without knowing they'll get in trouble. They knew the game, and knowingly broke its rules. Are there rules in China? Maybe, until there aren't. Ask the two Canadians being held in isolation without even the right to a book, just because their files turned up at the wrong bureaucrats desk and became needed to send a message to the Canadian government.

This is also why I won't set foot in the PRC if I can help it. I don't want to be used as a message to my government, no matter how unlikely it is for an insignificant pawn like me to get caught up in something like that. I'll limit my travel to places where I can read up on rules beforehand, and those rules are actually followed.

99052882514569··on The American Dream Is Alive in China
Sorry, not sure what it is we're comparing? 1950s segregation to the oppression of Uygurs, in which case no, in the 1950s the US was not running an all-encompassing dystopian surveillance state, mass reeducation camps and oppressive forced assimilation of African Americans? Or 1950s segregation to imprisonment and torture of political dissidents in general, in which case no, in the 1950s the US was not rounding up every Black activist and executing him or throwing him in jail for decades?
99052882514569··on The American Dream Is Alive in China
Not to mention that, once in a while, even people who don't dare speak against the authority get caught up and obliterated by the system. It's the nature of oppressive authoritarian systems where the rule of law is absent. You don't necessarily need to do anything for it to single you out.

On the topic of the 'American Dream': the more successful you are, the more likely it is in such a system that you don't pay off the right guy in time, or don't surrender enough of your wealth to a well-connected guy who wants a piece of it. And off to the Gulags you go, sharing a cell with the 'political prisoner' who pointed to as a cautionary tale of why you must not speak out and criticize the government. Wait, does that mean you're also a 'political prisoner' now too?

99052882514569··on The American Dream Is Alive in China
The scale, intensity and length are just not comparable. It's like comparing the Gulag to modern American prison labour.
99052882514569··on New Hampshire Lawmaker Kills Repair Bill Because 'Cellphones Are Throwaways'
This point is often overstated, so as to almost make it seem like shameless propaganda outlets like RT are equivalent to an actual journalism outfit with standards. Though I'm sure that's not how you meant it.
99052882514569··on Congressman's phone password is 111111
There are lots of obvious smudges on my screen, and the ones I made first thing after picking up my phone never stand out.
99052882514569··on We are leaving the Apple App Store and all its problems
As a standalone word, yes. The expression is, nevertheless, "bury the lede", and always* has been.

* since the 1970s when it first surfaced.

99052882514569··on We Need to Dream Bigger Than Bike Lanes
Biking isn't completely safe. Do helmets really help all that much? Very questionable[0]. Wearing a helmet, for example, promotes less safe behaviour by both cyclists and by drivers around them.

The sense of safety a helmet gives you when you cycle is mostly a false one. Lack of cycling infrastructure is a far greater danger anyway. In countries with the best cyclist safety records, no one wears or owns bike helmets, like not figuratively 'no one', but literally, no one. Can't be a very significant standalone determinant of bike safety then, can it?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_helmet#Effectiveness

99052882514569··on We are leaving the Apple App Store and all its problems
If you insist on using journalism jargon, why not use it in its intended, original form? I for one am not a language purist, you can change expressions any way you see fit but... I mean... The expression is still bury the lede.
99052882514569··on “We have no reason to believe 5G is safe”
"The present review - of results published by my group from 2006 until 2016"

Self-evaluation of quality is not quite a systemic review of literature. Neither is research on drosophila melanogaster quite in the same ballpark as research on homo sapiens.

99052882514569··on Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey
This is the sad reality. An international world order in which borders are somehow sacrosanct was a nice feel-good fiction, but ultimately if it cannot be enforced, it's not real. Not to mention that, like you said, long before Crimea there was Golan, Kashmir, etc.
99052882514569··on Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey
I disagree. Keeping your opponent in the 'fog of war' is a legitimate, reasonable military aim. In the olden days, radio/TV transmissions and newspaper publication was severely restricted during military operations. Today, those are largely irrelevant as news is spread on social media, so this block is the modern-era equivalent.

Note how my argument does not depend on whether we're talking about a good war, bad war, just war, evil war, etc.

99052882514569··on Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey
I'm not commenting on the war, the sides taking part in it, etc. I'm merely saying that muting social media in the vicinity of troop movement is a logical move by any government engaged in a war.
99052882514569··on Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey
I mean, it's next to a war zone, with tons of military hardware moving about, preparing to enter fighting. It sounds like pretty reasonable counter-intelligence (not to mention counter-propaganda) move.
99052882514569··on Bulgaria is the world’s fastest-shrinking country
Being in an EU country is a definite advantage over Panama.
99052882514569··on Show HN: Ieddit – A minimalist, Reddit-like site with anonymous posts/comments
People change these logins like gloves despite what the "spirit" of HN is supposed to be. In fact, an anonymous community that is strictly moderated for quality is better for being anonymous (or at least pseudonymous). If the average quality of contributions is reasonably high, you judge comments on their merit and aren't excessively reverent toward some and excessively skeptical toward others purely based on the contributor's history (and therefore set of beliefs). And people self-censor a lot less.
99052882514569··on Have Online Reviews Lost All Value?
> It's the same reason Rotten Tomatoes differentiates between a score and a top critics score. You can have a consumer reports score, and an amazon verified buyer score.

With sites like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic, I almost always completely ignore the "top critics" reviews and go with user reviews. In almost 100% of cases where the scores for TV shows significantly diverge, I find the user score to be spot on.

I think the user scores on these sites aren't horribly out of whack with reality because there's not much to be gained by gaming them. I'm sure only a small minority of consumers go on such sites to pick what to watch next.

99052882514569··on Banks, Arbitrary Password Restrictions and Why They Don't Matter
"Why am I supposed to believe that?"

Because if someone gets in, they're going to refund you.

99052882514569··on Equifax doesn't want consumers to get their $125
I agree. Until someone's ass is on the line, and I mean in terms of prison time and not merely their job, the rational thing to do for a shitty company that never cared for its customers is to continue with that approach.
99052882514569··on Edward Snowden: Permanent Record
>Bill Binney[1] consistently drives his message home that the NSA's surveillance apparatus is very inefficient at foiling plots, and I agree with him.

Oh, were you also with the NSA? For how long, and what did you do there? Or is that (let's put it charitably) an "Internet agree"?

99052882514569··on WeWork Isn’t a Tech Company
Their business is structured in such a way that the leases they signed on their locations aren't really enforceable against WeWork itself, but rather against "special purpose vehicles", I'm guessing one per lease?[1] It costs a bit in insurance but substantially limits their liability. So, in a downturn, even if "short termers are done", they can shed properties too, basically with impunity.

[1] https://stratechery.com/2019/the-wework-ipo/

99052882514569··on Netflix’s biggest bingers get hit with higher internet costs
Okay, make it 4 TB. My point is, ISPs imposing a cap is reasonable and a way to get the outliers to pay for more of the hardware/personnel required to service their extreme bandwidth requirements.
99052882514569··on Netflix’s biggest bingers get hit with higher internet costs
Not sure what you mean by "It’s equivalent to 3 mbps". Are you, like, streaming a video of an eagle nest 24/7?

You are paying for residential Internet service. The number of people who would legitimately need to transfer more than 1 TB per month over a residential Internet connection is vanishingly small. Bandwidth, particularly during high-demand hours, costs money. It is not fair for other users to subsidize your extreme usage scenario (since it is an axiom that all costs borne by the ISP are passed on to customers). It is far more fair that you, the extreme outlier, pays more.

99052882514569··on Netflix’s biggest bingers get hit with higher internet costs
A cap of 1 TB seems completely reasonable to me.

edit: After reading some replies, let me modify it and put it this way: the concept of a cap of n TB, where n is such that 99% of users don't ever reach it, seems completely reasonable to me.

99052882514569··on Luxembourg to be first European country to legalise cannabis
Consistency of laws across jurisdictions is not exactly what comes to mind when one thinks of the US legal system.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →