HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AStrangeMorrow

267 karma · joined June 27, 2016

submissionscomments
AStrangeMorrow··on Oldest Pyramid Found Not in Egypt or Americas, but in Indonesia
Exactly. There might be some traces of human passage dating 10000 years ago. But basically what we have is: surface-ish level construction, then a bunch of stones they interpret as old masonry but that is more likely natural, with deeper possible human traces as organic material, such as even a hunter gatherer that made a fire here one night. They use that to conclude to a paleolithic construction site.

Kinda like going to a European church, finding a bunch of stones and gravel under for 30m. Finding one silex around the same depth ans thus concluding European paleolithic people 10-20000 years ago were building complex edifices.

AStrangeMorrow··on Oldest Pyramid Found Not in Egypt or Americas, but in Indonesia
Yes. Archeologists are often frustrated they can't get funding or enough time at specific locations, not a huge cabal thathas access to the world history abd hides it from everyone. And most discoveries are much more mundane (even though still exciting IMHO) that what people would expect, as you said.
AStrangeMorrow··on Oldest Pyramid Found Not in Egypt or Americas, but in Indonesia
I think where I have seen people take issue is that there seems to be a push for "10000 year old pyramid". In short the measurements are correct the conclusions wrong.

They split things into 4 big layers, unit 1,2, ancient soil fills and unit 3. With unit 1 the most recent, also split into more find layers. Unit 1 goes to 2000 BCE roughly, 2 to 6000 BCE and then ancient soil 7000-8000 BCE and unit 3 13000 BCE+.

Unit 1 has clear megalithic structures and masonry work.

Unit 2 is more debatable, with stones and possible mortar remnants showing possible masonry work. But it is mostly some long stones and gravel, all with shapes that can occur totally naturally.

After that, ancient soil and Unit 3, from what I could read evidence of proper construction work seems more tenuous, if existant at all. Basically stones and soil.

Basically what the paper finds is some surface level masonry work and some deeper level stones they interpret as masonry while it is VERY debatable. Then they take a deep drill, date it to the paleolithic, and frame it as "paleolithic construction". But what most archeologists are reading is "recent construction with possible traces of humans in the area before"

AStrangeMorrow··on Oldest Pyramid Found Not in Egypt or Americas, but in Indonesia
As they briefly mention in the article, the dates provided are, to say the least, debated.

Contrary to what they seem to imply the consensus is that the pyramid is much more recent than 10000 years. As a general better be weary of all those "ancient civilization" articles, as they often either fall under bad science, if not straight up conspiracy.

What happened here in short is that they found some organic material dated roughly 10000 years by drilling under the pyramid. Ex: ashes or similar. Instead of concluding that 10000 years ago some humans did a fire here, and that thousands of years later other humans people decided that was a good spot to built a pyramid, they concluded those had to be the same humans. It is like finding Celtic artifacts under the Eiffel tower and concluding it had to be built 2400 years ago

AStrangeMorrow··on Oldest Pyramid Found Not in Egypt or Americas, but in Indonesia
Miniminuteman goes over "10000 year old Indonesian pyramid" too in his 4h or so debunking of Graham Hancock ancient civilization Netflix series (the usual "big archeology doesn't want you to know about this prediluvian ancient Atlantean civilization").

Link to the relevant section of the video of this debunking series: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-iCIZQX9i1A&list=PLXtMIzD-Y-...

AStrangeMorrow··on Empires of the Steppes: The Nomadic Tribes Who Shaped Civilisation
Not always fond of the use of "tribes" (which in itself is a pretty dated concept) to describe what was a complex empire. While certain early medieval kingdoms or duchies are called such (and not tribes) while being just one family governing over a small area, with a much simpler administrative structure.

Also recommend the work of Simon Berger, who pushes more for the empire of the steppes not being simply "nomadic tribes" but a proper nomadic state: https://www.academia.edu/106272853/Nomadic_State_in_the_Sede...

For those who speak French there is also this very in-depth series of videos on that topic (steppes), which also goes over the work of Simon Berger and some very early historians encounter with the steppes cultures: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLKZgJ2XooL3ARUPRafV2y3972...

AStrangeMorrow··on A chatbot encouraged a man who wanted to kill the Queen
The anti AI and anti open-source pieces are really flowing these days.

"No to AI. And if yes to AI then only for big corporations with strict direct government control".

Sure that might not be the ideal answer from a chatbot. But people can get the same reinforcement from their dreams, random strangers on Internet forums, or a 4 lines python program than answers "yes" to everything they would input.

AStrangeMorrow··on Humane, a startup full of ex-iPhone talent, trying to make phones obsolete
I remember about this being posted about 3 month ago (the product, not the link. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36573437).

Outside of a few marketing and hype terms, the website was so dry it was actually really hard to even get a simple idea of what the product was.

AStrangeMorrow··on Simulating History with ChatGPT
You could argue the same about other types of buildings too. You are going to a restaurant, a McDonald's, a Cafe, a Taco Bell, a bar that also serves food and so on. People make a distinction between those when they are all places to eat food. Sure the food differs, the way you interact with the staff too etc. But they all serve the same core purpose, yet people call them different things. The same way, people go to different places of worship for different faiths, with different expected behaviors and building designs
AStrangeMorrow··on Humane unveils AI Pin – a contextual computer with a mini projector
Exactly. You follow the link you get what is basically an image as landing page. Then you have to click on it to get to a small article/text, which doesn't tell you much either about what the actual product is. Somewhere in the text is a TedTalk video which shows and explains a little more. But when I see a link that is "whoah look at our new product" I expect more than a tagline and a picture
AStrangeMorrow··on Is history written by the winners?
We still have people believing WW1 and WW2 propaganda, or have a very cliché view of the middle ages for example. With tons of fact that have been debunked over and over again being spread.
AStrangeMorrow··on GPT-4
Yes. Language and image models are fairly different, but when you look at dall-e 2 (and dall-e earlier) that blew many people's mind when they came out, they have now been really eclipsed in term of popularity by Midjourney and stablediffusion.
AStrangeMorrow··on How primitive building videos are staged [video]
I'd say most of the time the split between legit or not is fairly obvious:

- legit: focuses on "simple" builds that they usually work on for months. They also cover many topics and techniques relative to primitive life

- fake: build a "primitive" house with pool every few weeks

AStrangeMorrow··on How primitive building videos are staged [video]
I also expect people like Chad Zuber (https://youtube.com/@ChadZuberAdventures) and a few other in that style to be legitimate.

Basically you have the ones doing it for fun / as a lifestyle, where progress is slow and that cover many elements of survival/primitive life. And those who build a new house with pool every week or so

AStrangeMorrow··on Egg whites can be transformed into a material capable of filtering microplastics
Yes, that's also where the french dessert canelé comes from: the egg whites being used for wine filtering, you have a lot of yolks left. So instead of wasting them, they were/are used to make canelés.
AStrangeMorrow··on A legal dispute that will test the limits of fair use
Does it truly contain all these texts? It seems more like it can generate any of these texts, but they are (obviously) not pre-generated and stored anywhere.

If we consider only lowercase non accentuated English characters and a few additional basic chars (space.,? etc), let's say 30 base characters, we are looking at 30^3200 combinations. Which is a number made of 4727 digits. Estimated number of atoms in the universe is 10^80. So basically nothing compared to this 30^3200.

Them claiming copyright over this would be a bit silly as the texts don't truly exist but only have the potential to be generated.

AStrangeMorrow··on DreamFusion: Text-to-3D using 2D Diffusion
This isn't what is usually meant by "technological singularity". It is an inflection point where technology growth becomes incontrollable and unpredictable, usually theorized to be cause by a self improving agent (/AI) that becomes smarter with each of its iterations. This is still standard technological progress, human control, even if very fast
AStrangeMorrow··on Despite faster broadband every year, web pages don't load any faster
Actually curious, what do you mean exactly by "doesn't perform better" in this context? My experience doesn't go as far (10-15 years), but while I agree a whole subset of softwares don't feel much different (text editors, web browsers), in some other domains I can feel the difference (video games, programing IDEs and the tools they offer). Where I imagine I agree is if a computer hardware becomes 10x more performant, there is not a related 10x improvement performance on softwares
AStrangeMorrow··on DALL-E 2 vs. Midjourney vs. StableDiffusion mega thread
For having played for more or less the last two months with Midjourney and Dall-E 2, and some crayon/dall-e mini, I'd say they have different content (what the image is about, ex: a winged firefighter riding a sheep) quality vs style (specific artist, minimalist, daguerreotype...) quality:

- Midjourney: so so at content, great at styles and plenty of settings options: image size and rarions, seeds, early stop, input images with weights, sub prompts with weights and more

- Dall-E 2: great at content, decent at styles, inpainting, but low res images.

Overall, have been having more fun with Midjourney but might be a matter of taste (and available credits. Dall-e 2 gets expensive fast)

AStrangeMorrow··on Microsoft is testing ads in the Windows 11 File Explorer
I wouldn't say really destroyed by the phone market, but yes, I feel like the markets are getting more and more specialized. From what I've seen Windows machine still have two big markets: Companies (for various software compatibility / historical reasons) and Gaming. If I look at all the persons I know using Windows as their main OS, and that's quite a few, reason nb 1 is video games.
AStrangeMorrow··on Show HN: I made a little math game named Summle
That's what I thought of too. Even though Countdown is kind of the UK version of the longer running French game https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Des_chiffres_et_des_lettres#Nu...
AStrangeMorrow··on Ask HN: What caused the Olympics to become so terrible?
I am in a similar situation, except the country where I come from usually makes it to the top 5-10. I have been surprised by how poor the coverage of the Olympics is here in the US: only sports where the US have a change of medals, don't bother to show the finale if the American contestant(s) has been eliminated in the semi, constant ad breaks and ad integrations. Almost unwatchable. And so antithetic to what the idea of the Olympics should be: bringing nations together and competing for the beauty of the sport and of the performances of the athletes. Coubertin, who founded the Olympic Committee said "L'important, c'est de participer" (roughly: "the important thing is to participate")
AStrangeMorrow··on How We Lost the Women in Computing (2018)
Interestingly my country (France) shows the same trend, but with a peak almost reaching 50%. It also shows that after that peak, the number of women in IT kept increasing then stagnated, while men exploded: https://imgur.com/a/gNHHIxm (rehosted, original website is dead)

This might be anecdotal, but I did an engineering school, CS/IT section. It was one of the very first school of my country to have a dedicated CS/IT program and diploma (the section opened over 50 years ago, 40 at the time I was there). A few hundred students each year. One of my teachers was one of the students dating from a few years after the section opened. He told us a few times that when he was studying, each promotion of the section was usually 50% men 50% women, sometimes more women even. When I graduated, it was close to 80% men. The nearby CS focused private school, where one of my friends was going, had 2 women for hundreds of men.

AStrangeMorrow··on Welcome to Waifu Labs v2: How Do AIs Create?
If interested in an other project that offers good tweaking, artbreeder (artbreeder.com) has been around for a while too. You have different models to play with (faces, anime, general, buildings, paintings etc...). Not all of them have the same level of quality and customization, but for example if you go for the face one, you get a really high level of customization: "cross-breeding" of 1 to 8 faces and then tweaking of many attributes (gender, color theme, age, ethnicity, realism, and other various details).
AStrangeMorrow··on Show HN: Cedille, the largest French language model, released in open source
Looks nice! I wanted to try stuff with lots of spelling/grammar mistakes to see how it handles that:

> [typed] La journer et vraiment tro belle et je voudre qu'on aille fere un tour de kart.

> [generated] Posté le: Sam 26 Jan - 19:12 (2009) Sujet du message: Publicité

Posté le: Jeu 31 Jan - 21:51 (2009) Sujet du message: Un jours ils sont venu me demander de les rejoindre

So it is trying to simulate some weird chat app I guess?

AStrangeMorrow··on Making a game to memorize facts about every country
I agree. I was on a big screen an some of the smaller countries were still impossible to see for me. Like some of the smaller islands are probably just a couple pixels. A dot of color or a circle around them would probably work better than a simple yellow fill.
AStrangeMorrow··on Will it rot my students' brains if they use Mathematica? (2002)
I watched it a while ago, but the TLDR is more or less that the learning styles (ex: visual learners, or auditory, reading/writing, by doing etc...) are a myth. People do not learn better when we use their preferred learning style. But overall, people do learn better with multi-modal (mixed support / style).
AStrangeMorrow··on Why pine nuts are expensive [video]
Similar situation here. When I was younger, there was plenty of these specific pine trees close to a local cinema (back in France). We wouldn't go often, but before / after the movie we would pick the shelled nuts off the ground and crack them open. I got surprised to see how expensive these are the first time I found them in a shop given that, as kids, we would just pick these off the ground.
AStrangeMorrow··on Culinary detectives try to recover the formula for garum
Yes! Speaking of that channel, he did a video on garum: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5S7Bb0Qg-oE
AStrangeMorrow··on Python 3.10
The "switch/case" statement is now in too (or match/case here, even though it goes beyond a simple case statement).

It had been rejected by Guido before (see: https://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-3103/#rejection-notice) but it seems it made its way in this time.

Approved: https://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0634/

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →