208 karma · joined August 8, 2013
hnchat:FdoERjfXiD6SKtSlGuck
This still wasn't a good idea, but for a different reason - it's relying on the demo at https://igorescobar.github.io/jQuery-Mask-Plugin/ continuing to exist, and continuing to host the plugin at that same path.
That's how it works for any open source project you use, regardless of where it's been hosted. Unless you review the entire codebase (as well as all changes made in new releases), you're trusting the maintainers' judgement.
Without an explicit warning, it's not going to be at all obvious to the average user - or anyone who forgets to check the address bar/isn't enforcing HTTPS - that the connection lacks those properties.
I would add that it's also because the government can censor people when it otherwise wouldn't be involved - a person hosting a blog with a third party, for example. Ordinarily, only that third party gets to decide whether or not to provide a platform for your data.
"Would the author have written this piece if all distros ticked all the three HTTPS boxes?"
Most likely, as three of the criteria listed have nothing to do with HTTPS ("Checksum available", "GPG signature available", and "Verification instructions clear and easy to find").
The author was referring specifically to the download page itself. As they correctly point out, the checksums and keys themselves can be modified if the page isn't served securely.
As for 'trusted keys', that doesn't help someone downloading the ISO for the first time, who hasn't previously verified a download from that site (how do they know if the key fingerprint is the correct one?)
Were the certificate to contain an IP address (or IP addresses), it would need to be updated every time the site started or stopped using a public-facing IP address.
If you're talking about officially, when the device is shipped, then this is true. However, one of the first steps after installing a custom rom is to flash a Google Apps package for your device (which includes Google Play). People still install Google's applications without the device passing any test.