If anything, you should accuse them of foolhardy recklessness. They are not the sticks in the mud.
4,563 karma · joined November 18, 2016
If anything, you should accuse them of foolhardy recklessness. They are not the sticks in the mud.
There are some interesting ways in which AI remains inferior to human intelligence but it is also obviously already superior in many ways already.
It remains remarkable to me how common denial is when it comes to what AI can or cannot actually do.
Meanwhile, the technology continues to progress. The level of psychological self-defense is unironically more interesting than what he has to say.
Quite a wide variety of people find AI deeply ego threatening to the point of being brainwormed into spouting absolute nonsense, but why?
Based on the rate of progress alone I would expect functional vision-only self-driving to be very close. I expect people will continue to say LIDAR is required right up until the moment that Tesla is shipping level 4/5 self-driving.
The conclusion that everything around LLMs is magical thinking seems to be fairly hubristic to me given that in the last 5 years a set of previously borderline intractable problems have become completely or near completely solved, translation, transcription, and code generation (up to some scale), for instance.
There are many things that are simply uncertain and “untrue until proven otherwise” isn’t an exclusively optimal policy.
The power laws actually cut both ways. I think the optimal path is not entirely obvious without some particular understanding of whether or not you are a stronger player as a leader or a follower.
That the implications of this idea have the “wrong” winners and losers is a separate matter.
- In China you can say anything you want! (of course you can’t criticize Xi or though, that would be ridiculous)
- in the UK you can say anything you want! (of course you can’t say anything untoward about anyone, that would be ridiculous)
- in Denmark you can say anything you want! (of course you can’t say anything that would offend religious sensibilities — this is real by the way, Denmark has reinstated blasphemy laws as of 2023)
The solution to this problem is either moral flexibility (which I do not suggest) OR a moral stance which is not dependent on the material facts.
We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal.