That this is so hard feels notable to me, like we're specifically misunderstanding something about the optimization process in higher dimensions.
4,563 karma · joined November 18, 2016
That this is so hard feels notable to me, like we're specifically misunderstanding something about the optimization process in higher dimensions.
Eliezer is probably going to seem convincing, he's a great writer and a reasonably eloquent speaker - his audience is humans.
Goerge Hotz's competence is machines, and he's exceptional at interfacing with them. Yes, I trust the less eloquent tinkerer who's only famous for his preternatural understanding of machines over any theoretician and 1000x more than a (pretty good!) writer.
Meanwhile, George Hotz, an engineer and a technologist - a guy who actually works with and understands technology, but isn't an acclaimed harry potter fanfiction writer or a stand up comedian - is derided because his arguments are dramatically less sexy, harder to appreciate why they might be right.
People, please do not listen to people who sound great but have no credible claim to be an expert on something. There is a difference between an idea that sounds good and an idea that is good.
The track record of communism is so insanely bad that it is literally the second worst ideology of the 20th century, beat only by facism which caused the instant self-immolation of every country to ever try it (while inflicting terrible harm on their neighbors).
Completely harmless and naive in its attitudes towards harmful or controversial things, and this is trivially detectable.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiregional_origin_of_mode...
This theory holds that humans in different parts of the world are primarily descended from local hominids vs the commonly accepted theory that humans are all primarily and recently descended from a population somewhere in East or South Africa with a small amount of admixture with local hominids.
Most people consider the multiregional origin theory highly motivated reasoning and also completely garbage science.
And I don’t mean that it isn’t true that we could try harder, I just mean that sometimes “trying harder” seems to make the problem worse rather than better.
I can think of a few problems like this:
- homelessness
- cost of college
- healthcare
- housing
I’m not sure if the critical factor is that the issues are morally charged and so encourage effort-heavy policies or if it’s because “trying harder” is really a supply-side subsidy, meaning money for healthcare providers or colleges or landlords. In practice at least it seems that supply side subsidies without cost controls are essentially useless, as the cost of the subsidized good rises to match the subsidy.
If such a test exists we could interrogate if a system of some design might pass it, but if such a test does not exist and we cannot even imagine it then you’re talking about something that is unfalsifiable - which is another way of saying “effectively fake”.
The question then is whether we are willing to tolerate the level of enforcement necessary. Is the cure worse than the disease? That is a real question and a worthy one, but pretending that no tradeoff exists is just silly.
Under those conditions I’d estimate your odds of getting into at least one Ivy (or equivalently good school) at around 50%, which might seem low but remember 99.6% of college students do not attend an ivy.
And the answer is that there will be something like two 80 yr olds for every 30 yr old.
And I think this is because we sort of have this assumption that society having more kids is a thing we don't have to incentivize, and so we haven't really thought about what is the actual cost/value of that incentivization.
- an old optimist you're liberal
- an old pessimist you're conservative
- a young optimist you're conservative
- a young pessimist you're liberal
I have no idea why or even if this is really true but it is my impression.