HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AbrahamParangi

4,563 karma · joined November 18, 2016

submissionscomments
AbrahamParangi··on A forthcoming collapse of the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation
While strictly true, that doesn't mean 5C cooling wouldn't eventually result in NYC under ice.
AbrahamParangi··on Signal walks the line between anarchism and pragmatism
I was more talking about this kind of reaction.
AbrahamParangi··on Attention Is Off By One
One caveat is that the average of many normally distributed vectors in many dimensions is normally distributed with 0 mean but is not typically close to 0. In fact the average norm is quite large. Try it yourself and see!
AbrahamParangi··on Signal walks the line between anarchism and pragmatism
The rising intolerance of wrongthink on the left has been written about extensively but I’d love to read a sympathetic, anthropological investigation into it.

I say sympathetic because I don’t believe you can understand anything without really seeing how a reasonable person could come to those same conclusions.

AbrahamParangi··on Life on Earth didn’t arise as described in textbooks
If you’ve already come to the conclusion you want, why bother asking questions about it?
AbrahamParangi··on I am dying of squamous cell carcinoma, and potential treatments are out of reach
On the contrary, I personally believe it's deeply immoral to tell a dying person to "just wait, it's for your own good".
AbrahamParangi··on Botulinum toxin: Bioweapon and magic drug (2010)
I think people see the pictures and it looks like it might be an improvement but it's the motion of expressions that really makes it look weird/uncanny. A human face is always moving and it reads very wrong to see it move wrong.
AbrahamParangi··on Children of alumni no longer have admissions edge at Carnegie Mellon, Pitt
I think this may have been true in like, the 1920s, when it was very difficult to connect merit and capital but today it’s fairly easy and the justification doesn’t really make sense.
AbrahamParangi··on A stationary jet stream is fueling intense heat worldwide
90% of humans live in the northern hemisphere.
AbrahamParangi··on GPT-4 is getting worse over time, not better
I assume you run your own servers and operating system too?
AbrahamParangi··on The global fight for critical minerals is costly and damaging
I’m interested in how this editorial got written. It’s not attributed to anyone and the language and perspective seem to me to be CCP talking points.

“Sustainability, equity and security are all at risk in the rush to break China’s dominance over their production.”

- I can think of one entity which wouldn’t want China’s dominance of rare earth production broken and it’s not the DRC.

“China’s ascendancy is the result of forward thinking by the country’s leadership”

- Seems strangely flattering since it doesn’t seem like it adds anything to the arguments or the context.

“it is not in the interests of any nation to partner with just one other country or group of countries”

- I believe this is explicitly a CCP talking point (link below for reference). Obviously, other people might say it but it seems sort of… suspect? Like the article purports to make a moralistic claim about exploitation and then goes into pure realpolitik. In my opinion that’s the sort of thing you’d only say if you were wearing social justice as a mask and didn’t actually believe in it yourself.

https://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/wjbxw/202302/t20230220_1102...

AbrahamParangi··on How is ChatGPT's behavior changing over time?
The main thing that ChatGPT has gotten better at is rejecting jailbreaks and refusing to go off the reservation. It has been demonstrated that "safety" trades off against "capability". I'm sure OpenAI has evaluations that demonstrate the improvements they've been making to "safety" have not come at the cost of capability, but I'd bet those evaluations are wrong (by being insufficient). It also wouldn't surprise me if the tradeoff between "safety" and capability is just intrinsic.

You can have your model talk like HR or think like a mad scientist, but not both equally well.

AbrahamParangi··on How is ChatGPT's behavior changing over time?
In my opinion the more likely thing is that OpenAI is gaslighting people that the finetuning is improving the model when it likely mostly improves safety at some cost to capability. I'd bet this is measured against a set of evals and it looks like it performs well BUT I'd also bet the evals are asymmetrically good at detecting "unsafe" or jailbreak behavior and bad at detecting reduced general cognitive flexibility.

The obvious avenue to degradation is that the "HR personality" is much more strictly applied and the resistance to being jailbroken is also in some sense an inability to think.

AbrahamParangi··on The World Bakes Under Extreme Heat
My meta point is that the moral urgency of the discussion has reached such a fever pitch that if, hypothetically, you were wrong about something -

perhaps that the effects will be different than your expectations, perhaps that human ingenuity will overcome the challenges, perhaps that some other, bigger problem will rear it’s head

- you have no mechanism left to tell. If that sounds like the narcissists prayer to you then so be it.

AbrahamParangi··on The World Bakes Under Extreme Heat
You could just as easily argue that "things will be more or less fine" is highly evidence based (things have been fine in the past) and in contrast millenarianism has an awfully bad evidentiary track record.

A mass extinction event is underway, but it's not just starting. We are not at the beginning. There is this idea that the premodern world was "basically natural", but the reality is that 70% of animals larger than 45kg that were present in North America when humans arrived are already extinct.

There is no Eden to go back to or preserve. The world hasn't been in equilibrium since hominid intelligence started taking off and our only constant is change.

AbrahamParangi··on The World Bakes Under Extreme Heat
I would like to register a contrary prediction: I think things will be basically okay even under fairly extreme climate change.

I understand that many people may disagree with this prediction and some of those people will disagree with even communicating this prediction, as they will see it as boosterism for our decadent industrial society. However, I think if we are interested in what is true, we need to allow ourselves to conceive of such things as human civilization continuing on without much fuss.

AbrahamParangi··on The World Bakes Under Extreme Heat
The bitter lesson is that, actually, quantity usually beats efficiency.

Increasing efficiency has a brutal difficulty that is constrained by thermodynamics whereas the universe is almost limitlessly full of energy, space, and mass.

AbrahamParangi··on A Theory on Adam Instability in Large-Scale Machine Learning
The structure of that 3yr old’s visual cortex is itself the result of a ~500 million year optimization process.
AbrahamParangi··on Refusing to teach kids math will not improve equity
There's been a trend in secondary and higher education for the past ~5 years or so in favor of removing more rigorous classes (advanced math) and more objective evaluation* (standardized testing) in the name of equity.

Proponents argue that it advances equity and removes stigma. Opponents argue that equity is a bad goal and even if you thought it was a good goal, this perversely accomplishes the opposite.

You're starting to see articles like this one or this one https://www.bostonglobe.com/2023/07/14/metro/cambridge-schoo... because well, the worm turns.

*While standardized testing is not truly objective it is dramatically more so than grades.

AbrahamParangi··on Bad numbers in the “gzip beats BERT” paper?
Well, biology is probably a lot closer to ML in this way. My experience in chemistry or material science is that 99% of the time if you do anything wrong it totally doesn't work at all.

This is fairly typical in software as well.

AbrahamParangi··on The US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the US is now nearly 2X
These stats drive me up the wall because the US is more diverse than every single European country. The life expectancy in California is 81 and in Alabama it’s 74. That’s the difference between the UK and like, Latvia.

This matters because when you look at these crude aggregate stats, people naively assume that it means that everything is a bit worse but the actual American story is usually more like broad prosperity with some truly awful outcomes for anyone who falls through the (very wide) cracks.

AbrahamParangi··on Bad numbers in the “gzip beats BERT” paper?
Probably disappointing to the authors but an excellent rebuttal.

This is the sort of mistake that's awfully easy to make in ML. The unfortunate thing about the field is that subtle methodological errors often cause subtle failures rather than catastrophic failures as we're used to in many other branches of engineering or science. You can easily make a system slightly worse or slightly better by contaminating your training set with bad data or accidentally leaking some information about your target and the ML system will take it in stride (but with slightly contaminated results).

This result makes sense to me because as much as I would like it to be true, applying existing compression algorithms to ML feels like too much of a "free lunch". If there was any special magic happening in compression algorithms we'd use compression algorithms as encoders instead of using transformers as compressors.

AbrahamParangi··on The deadly “dancing plague” of 1518
It's uncertain that these people were in-fact drugged up and the guards themselves killed themselves as well. Moreover, it doesn't really excuse the point. It was insane. Insane for the people to be there. Insane for the guards to keep them there. Insane for their leaders to tell them to die.
AbrahamParangi··on The deadly “dancing plague” of 1518
Highschool does typically reward bullshit (especially in the humanities where the bar for "verifiably bullshit" is much higher) over "idk lol"
AbrahamParangi··on The deadly “dancing plague” of 1518
In 1978, 918 people committed suicide at Jonestown. I think we should all understand that an average human being surrounded by people acting insane will act insane themselves. Some won't, some have contrary convictions or just don't like to go with the flow, but this isn't typical.

Better to understand that this is innate human nature and guard against it than to just say "couldn't be me".

AbrahamParangi··on Negative Mass
Because this simulation is nonsense. I don’t mean that pejoratively, just that you can’t get consistent answers from an inconsistent or in this case, under-defined, premise.
AbrahamParangi··on Megachurches are getting even bigger as churches close across the country
My pet theory is that the decline of churches has less to do with the secularization of culture and more to do with the fact that they're not very entertaining or engaging relative to whatever else you could be doing on your weekend.

The "engagingness" of entertainment has been increasing in absolute terms for a while now, and it really picked up in the 20th century. Meanwhile, the "engagingness" of mainstream religion has not kept pace. It is perhaps indicative that those groups of people best able to keep devout religious practices also typically shun all the rest of consumer entertainment.

In that frame, megachurches represent an evolution to survive this higher-engagement ecosystem. To compete, church must be more fun, which in this case means turning into a giant pep-rally/rock concert.

AbrahamParangi··on Actors say Hollywood studios want their AI replicas – for free, forever
By and large the boomers won't vote for someone younger than them (notice our politicians are the oldest they've ever been and have been getting older since the boomers started voting).

I bet their other preferences have a lot to do with the decrease in new 80s-type movie stars, because the other thing that we've seen is the retention of stars well past their prime. I mean, they brought back Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher for the new Star Wars.

AbrahamParangi··on 3M reaches $10.3B settlement over PFAS contamination of water systems
There are regulations on quite a number of things but the evidentiary standards are not equal because a treatment has to demonstrate a health benefit whereas a packaging additive just has to "demonstrate an absence of harm" which is actually a lax criteria because proving a negative is inherently "impossible".

The practical implication is that your bloodstream is filled with relatively few small-molecule drugs and relatively many synthetic chemicals.

AbrahamParangi··on 3M reaches $10.3B settlement over PFAS contamination of water systems
To be honest it’s very unclear to me why we hold medicine to the standard of “demonstrably more helpful than harmful” but we hold the material your pill bottle is made out of to the standards of “innocent until proven guilty”.

I can’t help but think that’s an oversight from lack of imagination and lack of intuitive understanding of how much leaching and abrading goes on.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →