HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AdamH12113

2,758 karma · joined July 18, 2018

submissionscomments
AdamH12113··on I should have loved electrical engineering
As an EE who changed majors from CS in college and who has also done a lot of programming, I can see where the author is coming from. But electrical engineering, by its nature, is a low-level field. If CS students spent their first couple years doing algorithms and data structures in assembly, they would also find it difficult!

A key purpose of the repeated exercises in circuit analysis is to build up the student's intuition for how electricity works. Mathematically, it's "simple" -- just systems of (possibly complex) equations and basic diff eq. But for sophomores, all that is still new, and most students don't enjoy going deep into derivations.

Building kits and plugging pre-made modules into microcontroller development boards is fun, but it's not really engineering. You don't hire an EE to plug off-the-shelf components together, you hire an EE to do design work, to make sure everything is going to work under all operating conditions, and to diagnose problems when something goes wrong.

Finally, software is just easier[1] than hardware. Modern software is a mathematical idealization that runs of top of decades of high-level tools and abstractions. That's why it's so cheap and popular!

[1] This does not mean that everything in software development is easy, just that you don't need to deal with physics or chemistry or manufacturing or the procurement of physical goods in order to create new software.

AdamH12113··on The Enterprise Experience
> Does "career development" just mean "more money"?

No. Career development includes paid training sessions, title promotions (junior -> senior, etc.) opportunities to work on larger projects in more significant roles (resume building), and opportunities to transfer into management, as well as (in some cases) opportunities to publish conference papers and the like. As you get older, this kind of career development becomes more important because it is recognized by people who will hire you.

AdamH12113··on Toothpaste made with keratin may protect and repair damaged teeth: study
“Made from hair” is clickbait — the research is about keratin, a common structural protein.
AdamH12113··on Hyrum's Law
From an API designer's standpoint (especially if that API has paying customers), Hyrum's Law is something that has to be taken into account. But from a user's standpoint, it is engineering malpractice, plain and simple. At the very least, relying on quirks of someone else's implementation is a risk that should be understood and accounted for, and no one has any reasonable grounds for complaint if those quirks suddenly change in a new version.
AdamH12113··on The Tabs vs. Spaces war is over, and spaces have emerged victorious
I use tabs for indentation and spacing for alignment. Tables should be aligned with spaces. A wrapped line can be tabbed up to the start of the previous line and then spaced for alignment.
AdamH12113··on I've Had It with Microsoft
This is not even remotely correct. Historically, Microsoft's biggest problem with Office was having to convince people to buy the new versions since the basic feature set was fairly complete. The file format upgrade in 2007 was the only real forced upgrade since you had to have it in order to read other people's files. I have a copy of Office 2010 that still works just fine and can read files produced by up-to-date Microsoft 365 subscriptions.

The same goes for many other pieces of software. People (especially home users) would buy software once and then keep using it until something justified an upgrade. Software subscriptions were historically a B2B thing and IIRC usually came with support packages to help justify the ongoing cost -- especially important in the pre-internet and early internet eras.

AdamH12113··on I've Had It with Microsoft
The real money-grab was turning Microsoft Office into a subscription service in the first place. SaaS is a cancer on personal computing.
AdamH12113··on Atopile – Design circuit boards with code
That example puts silkscreen reference designators on component pads, which is... not great.
AdamH12113··on Vibe-Coding a PCB – surprisingly good
That’s probably not going to happen. RF simulations are done using extremely expensive special-purpose software, and many components (including basically all digital and mixed-signal components) don’t have simulation models available at all. If they were available, the computing power required to simulate even a medium-size board over any reasonable time scale would be impossible. Simulation is a small-scale thing; you don’t do it for a whole board.
AdamH12113··on Ask HN: Is anyone else just done with the industry?
I wish I had something more specific for you, but my experience is more on the demand-adjacent side (as an EE) rather than directly on the software side. The companies I've worked at have posted on the regular job sites but mainly worked through recruiters. Companies do often post announcements on their LinkedIn, if they have one.

I share your frustration with the fad-driven, cramming-AI-into-everything, rent-seeking model of modern software, and I wish you luck in your search.

AdamH12113··on Ask HN: Is anyone else just done with the industry?
If you're willing to leave Silicon Valley, there are a lot of small companies out there that need one or two or a handful of decent software developers to do useful but non-cutting-edge work. They can't pay Silicon Valley money, obviously, but you get to be a lot closer to other kinds of work, which you might find satisfying in its own way.
AdamH12113··on Cracovians: The Twisted Twins of Matrices
The example is simply wrong, according to other sources. This along with the inconsistent formatting makes me wonder if it was written by an LLM. It's a shame; this seems like an interesting topic.
AdamH12113··on Open-sourcing circuit tracing tools
Yeah, I actually have a decades-old two-layer board that I need to reproduce and I would love to be able to feed images of it into some sort of tool and have it generate a schematic (or at least a netlist) automatically.
AdamH12113··on Sleep apnea pill shows striking success in large clinical trial
Unless there’s a leak (and there shouldn’t be) CPAPs are much quieter than you think they are. The only time I even notice mine (Resmed with P10 nasal pillows) is when using it from a battery during a power outage when everything is dead quiet. If you have any kind of background noise (fan hum, AC, air purifier, living near a freeway) you probably won’t even notice it.
AdamH12113··on Why top posting has won (2018)
I went looking for the date of this post because I honestly thought it was from the 1990s, when top-posting actually won.

The date is more important than you're giving it credit for. Every creative work has a context and an implicit perspective that comes from that context. This is especially true for nonfiction articles, where the date tells you things like:

* Whether the author is reacting to something that just happened or whether they have the benefit of historical hindsight.

* Where the article fits in the author's overall body of work (including works they haven't written yet!).

* What, if any, recent events may have prompted the author to write the article.

* The prevailing intellectual climate, which carries focuses and blind spots that may be very different from what we have now.

* Whether the article is about something immediately useful or whether it's more likely to be of historical interest.

You can already tell, for instance, that "Thoughts on Software Development (1998)" is going to be talking about very different things than "Thoughts on Software Development (2012)" or "Thoughts on Software Development (2025)". An article like "Better C Programming (2020)" probably contains some useful advice; whereas "Better C Programming (1991)" should be taken with a large grain of salt.

Instead of making readers ask questions like "Why is the person talking about operating system monopolies while saying nothing about LLM model ownership?", it's easier and more helpful to just put the date at the top.

AdamH12113··on Why top posting has won (2018)
Needs a (2018) added to the title -- the list of recent posts[1] gives the publication date as 2018-06-13.

Incidentally: Bloggers, please put dates in your actual blog post templates. The date is an important part of the context of any article.

[EDIT: The author of the article has already added the date to their template. Thanks!]

[1] https://www.solipsys.co.uk/new/ColinsBlog.html

AdamH12113··on Have I Been Pwned 2.0
Amazing that even within the last decade a site as large as LinkedIn could be storing unsalted passwords. How does anyone fail at this in the modern era?
AdamH12113··on Stack Overflow is almost dead
Are there any similar articles on the state of the rest of the Stack Exchange network? There are many, many other SE sites that have nothing to do programming and are often less amenable to being answered via LLM.
AdamH12113··on An Alabama landline that keeps ringing
I think the GP is referring to manually operated elevators, in which a human inside the elevator pulls a lever to tell the elevator when to move. When I was a kid, my dad worked in a building with a semi-automated elevator that had floor buttons and an automatic return to the ground floor, but still had the lever. There was an operator inside on weekdays, but if you came in on the weekend you had to operate the elevator yourself.
AdamH12113··on How Silica Gel Took Over the World
The packets look like the little salt packets that come with fast food, and the stuff inside looks kind of like salt.
AdamH12113··on The Ren'Py Visual Novel Engine
If you're wondering what's up with the name, "Ren'Py" is a pun on the Japanese word "ren'ai" (恋愛), which means "romantic love".
AdamH12113··on Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji
An octet is a group of 8 bits. Today we normally use the word "byte" instead. The term is often used in older internet protocols and comes from an era where bytes were not necessarily 8 bits.
AdamH12113··on It's not 'emotional labour', it's kin work
> What's the alternative? A customer service job where you can be rude?

A customer service job where you can be merely polite and professional without also having to be artificially cheerful and enthusiastic. Or, if you must put on a show, at least be paid appropriately for the extra work you're doing.

AdamH12113··on Optical Frequency Combs
Microwave communication goes comfortably into the tens of gigahertz range, and visible light is in the hundreds of terahertz. So it is about a factor of 10,000.
AdamH12113··on How to Debounce a Contact (2014)
Ah, that is better. Thanks!
AdamH12113··on How to Debounce a Contact (2014)
What's wrong with the SR latch debouncer?
AdamH12113··on Advanced Civilizations Could Be Indistinguishable from Nature
One thing that immediately came to mind upon seeing the title is the way that efficient (digital) radio communications look much more similar to noise (due to information density) than old analog communication methods.

The article seems to be looking at things from an energy-usage perspective. Why don't we detect Dyson spheres and other large-scale technological projects? Maybe the most efficient ways of harnessing the energy of a planet blend in with the natural processes of the planet itself.

Or, as a sibling comment suggested, maybe the civilization that makes (alien) people happiest is one that outwardly resembles the world they evolved in.

AdamH12113··on The IPv6 Transition
I’ve often wondered if going with 64-bit addresses with a dotted quad hex notation would have eased the roll-out. I remember a lot of resistance when IPv6 was first announced along the lines of “I can’t memorize/type in giant addresses and I don’t want to have to use DHCP and DNS everywhere.” It felt like IPv6 never recovered from a bad first impression.
AdamH12113··on Fundamental physics is dying? [video]
He was also a long-time maintainer of the Usenet Physics FAQ and has been writing about physics and mathematics on the internet for decades. So not only is he the real deal in terms of knowledge, he also has a long history of communicating that knowledge to the public, albeit typically for a more advanced audience.
AdamH12113··on Calling All Hackers
Estradiol valerate (which is what the article actually names) seems to be used for a wide variety of female reproductive health issues, especially when (as the article suggests) it's compounded with other drugs. It's also used by transgender people as a hormone therapy. A hacker might live in a place where gender-affirming healthcare is illegal or unavailable, or where female reproductive healthcare in general is difficult or expensive to obtain.

Reproductive healthcare is much more broadly useful than Molotov cocktails.

← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →