HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AimHere

1,124 karma · joined April 26, 2012

submissionscomments
AimHere··on How recursion got into programming: a comedy of errors
Be warned that, despite the name, the Reasoned Schemer is only tangentially about scheme; it focuses on miniKanren, a somewhere-in-the-Prolog-ballpark logic programming language created by one of Friedman's students, that is implemented as an extension to the Scheme language proper (among other languages, most notably as the clojure core.logic library).

Also Friedman and Byrd did show up to a few clojure talks and seemed, from the online videos, to be highly entertaining - I remember their using miniKanren to automatically generate scheme programs that evaluated to 6 being particularly fun.

AimHere··on Dutch court: selling e-books second hand is legal
Your argument could apply to a book too; why should an author NOT be able to veto whenever a copy of his work changes hands, or gets lent to a library or ends up in a second-hand bookshop?

But the law of copyright is clear when it comes to physical goods. The consumer has rights too, and one of those rights is to treat physical copies of copyrighted works the same way as normal everyday physical items. It's one of the limitations that society has seen fit to impose on the rights of copyright holders; in exchange for their monopoly on the right to make copies of their works, the customers get the right to borrow, lend, resell or otherwise alienate themselves of the product. You'll find the doctrine called 'exhaustion of rights' or 'first sale', and in US Law, it's to be found in 17 USC 109.

What's happening here is that with the internet switched on and the mass trade in digital goods, the copyright holders have been spending years making the analogies with physical goods that require capital and cost money to reproduce ('You wouldn't download a car') and now the physical items analogy is being applied to the rights that everyone else has too.

AimHere··on Qualcomm issues DMCA takedowns for 116 GitHub repositories, including their own
A normal DMCA takedown request is taken under penalty of perjury (sadly, a lot of the big common carriers, like Youtube, have gentleman's agreements with Big Media, so they don't rely on formal DMCA takedowns), and knowingly and falsely claiming to be the copyright holder is likely an infringement of the author's moral rights, which is at the criminal end of copyright law, so that's two flavours of illegal right there.
AimHere··on The Problem of Induction (1967)
Aren't those about the philosophy of mathematics, rather than that of science?

At this level, mathematics is a discipline that's entirely unlike science, in that (at least if you believe it's philosophers) science doesn't prove anything true, it just has a bunch of competing theories some of which get disproved by experiments.

AimHere··on Inside the Building That's Calling Itself the People's Republic of Donetsk
The bureaucratic misadventures at the start of the article sound like this is a bunch of people playing a LARP version of Papers, Please. Which, come to think of it, should be a thing.
AimHere··on How extreme isolation warps the mind
See, this is why you should have been using emacs all along. Theological and ergonomic considerations aside, for your sanity's sake, GNU emacs comes with two IRC clients, a web browser, an email reader and a usenet reader to stave off isolation-induced hacker-madness. And in extremis, with no network connection, there's always M-x doctor.

Truly, RMS thought of everything, and then put it in emacs twice, just in case.

AimHere··on Are you paid to look busy?
When I was stuck in a meaningless office job with too much time, I took to learning myself a perl (that was used for some login scripting so there was an interpreter lying about) using notepad to edit, and the windows cmd.exe to execute the scripts. One other (more senior) employee did get curious and asked me what I was up to, but I did have a script that was actually useful to get part of my job done, so I just showed that off. Then I went back to teaching Perl to play scrabble!
AimHere··on We are throttling the FCC to dialup modem speeds until they pay us for bandwidth
Well maybe there's room for mass action along these lines.

If, some ISP, say, "Bombcast", decides to throttle some website, say "Slacker News" as part of an extortion plan, can't we have every other content-providing internet service - be it Wikipedia, reddit, AirBnB, Facebook, maybe even google, if they're on this side of the fight - throttle all of Bombcast's customers right back.

Suddenly half of Bombcast's customers find their favourite sites moving at unacceptable speeds, with a black border around the edges and an annoying black popup window telling them exactly why their website access is being throttled, and recommending they switch to some less heinous ISP instead. Naturally, hit the FCC, any part of the US legislature that voted against Net Neutrality and so forth into the bargain. Force customers to choose between the faceless drones who laid the cable to their door ten years ago and send them a bill every month, or the guys who provide all the shiny internet stuffs that they enjoy for more or less free.

Might some sort of content provider's union be quite powerful? Because of who they are, they have a head start at winning hearts and minds so they'd have leeway when it comes to taking action that might alienate their public.

AimHere··on Steam Gauge: Steam’s most popular games
Lost Coast is a standalone freebie tech demo; it probably was issued freely to owners of various other Source Engine games (or maybe even just to absolutely everybody). Apparently it was also given out to people who bought certain graphics cards too.
AimHere··on Steam Gauge: Steam’s most popular games
And risk alienating an entrenched and fanatical fanbase?

Note the '2014' in the title; this is one of those regular sports games franchises, and it has been around since 1992 (For the first 10 years or so, it had the name 'Championship Manager', but that was changed due to legal hassle). Every year, these guys upgrade their engine, upgrade the player database, pile on some improvements and tweak stuff, and put out a new game. Some fans buy the game every year, some every two, or every three years.

It might be a niche product, but Football Manager owns that niche; it has a recognisable brand name and product (one that is well-recognised in the real-life sport itself to the extent that one Premiership Football Team - Everton - even bought early access to the player database), a large and fanatical fanbase (the company has fans in almost every football team in the world scouting players for it), and constant (if not growing) revenue stream.

Gamers aren't stupid; trying to nickel-and-dime them with those hated microtransactions is the sort of thing that would easily lead Sports Interactive down the road to an EA Dungeon Keeper-style PR nightmare. SI are already onto a very good thing; the sort of quick-buck Zynga/King style cynical disruption you're suggesting would be a total disaster.

AimHere··on GCHQ Used Fake LinkedIn Pages to Target Engineers (2013)
>Terrorists don't use mobile phones anyway.

There you go! Track all the phone users, and anyone who doesn't have one, and is therefore untracked, is probably a terrorist!

Actually that's not far-fetched. I do recall, vaguely, some old indymedia article about a European political activist being arrested, with the fact they left their phone at home before turning up at a meeting being part of the grounds for suspicion. Indymedia stories tend to be rather ephemeral and hard to search so providing actual details is somewhat troublesome...

AimHere··on Direct3D to OpenGL abstraction layer
Well there are possibly smaller studios and devs who perhaps don't have the resources to roll their own translation layers, for whom this might be a tipping point towards supporting SteamOS and/or Linux.

Since Valve has already written this for their own purposes, it'll cost next to nothing for this to be published if they can stop people expecting support, and they might get a few bug reports into the bargain.

AimHere··on Mathematicians are chronically lost and confused
>we have a system of mathematics built on a few basic principles (that you would not disagree with) and deductive reasoning

I think it's even better than that; mathematicians don't necessarily care whether the reader 'agrees' with the axioms, or whether they're in any sense 'true' or 'false'. Mathematics is always of the form 'if these axioms are true, this theorem follows from it'.

The real world and the notions which people consider to be self-evidently true is just some messy slimy gooey gunk best left to psychoanalysts and theoretical physicists and sewer workers and the like.

AimHere··on Portal 2 Beta for Linux officially released
It's not yet ported to Linux.
AimHere··on Portal 2 Beta for Linux officially released
Likely technical; the last three major source games to be ported were Dota2, this and Counterstrike: Global Offensive (as yet not running on Linux), which were their three newest games, and presumably used their shiniest, glossiest versions of the Source Engine.

I'd imagine that CS:GO would have been prioritized much higher if it was purely a business decision, given it's still high up in their top-played games; Dota2, likewise, is their top played, flagship title, so if it was a pure business decision, that would surely be #1 instead of third-last.

AimHere··on IMDB Top 100K Movies – Analysis in Depth, Part 2
I don't think it would make much odds for IMDB. Sure you'll maybe negate the overly high proportion of extreme votes, but I don't think that effect is large. I did once take the top films on IMDB and remove the extreme votes, and the effect was marginal - a few films shuffled a place or so. In exchange, if you use the median, you could have polarising films - like Twilight, having their ratings change markedly over time, as people decide to start warring over it and the numbers swamp the small number of ambivalents.

For your other point, there will be voting patterns for various demographics and certain groups of people prefer certain movies. But I think the phenomenon I'm describing is a bit too extreme to be merely a bunch of old women disproportionately taking a dislike to Ikiru and then rushing onto the internet to tell the world they hate it. It is the smallest demographic IMDB has, so it's not hurting the ratings of the films in general, it's just an oddity.

AimHere··on IMDB Top 100K Movies – Analysis in Depth, Part 2
IMDB provides that by itself:

http://www.imdb.com/search/title?groups=top_1000&sort=user_r...

AimHere··on IMDB Top 100K Movies – Analysis in Depth, Part 2
One thing I was hoping this series would shed light on was an oddity in demographic voting patterns with the ratings system.

From my own (anecdotal) observation, there's a class of films where the 'Females 45+' rating is a big outlier in the voting, with a large proportion of '1' votes. it's as if there's a gang of a few hundred users consistently downvoting films who are classed by IMDB as being part of that demographic - I don't know if it's a default setting that some bots or trolls have used or if there really are a bunch of cinephobic old women out there just watching and hating on films, but it did spark my curiosity as to what the pattern was. It doesn't happen in every film, and it's rare that you see any other demographic sticking out like this.

The best examples are critically acclaimed films with low voter counts. More popular, or less well-received films tend to have a lot of negative noise to begin with, so the effect is less noticeable, if it's there at all.

Here's some examples:

Army of Shadows : http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0064040/ratings?ref_=tt_ov_rt

Spartacus : http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0054331/ratings?ref_=tt_ov_rt

Ikiru : http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0044741/ratings?ref_=tt_ov_rt

Passion of Joan of Arc : http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0019254/ratings?ref_=tt_ov_rt

Breathless : http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0053472/ratings?ref_=tt_ov_rt

Z : http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0065234/?ref_=fn_al_tt_2

Barry Lyndon : http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0072684/ratings?ref_=tt_ov_rt

AimHere··on Irrational Games (Bioshock Infinite) is shutting down
Well LGS made about three games after Terra Nova, so maybe not. Their last full game was Thief 2 which I think made money but not enough to warrant them being kept alive in the wake of the Daikatana fiasco.
AimHere··on Valve DNS privacy flap exposes the murky world of cheat prevention
Right. Gabe isn't admitting to wrongdoing here, since Valve feels that the particular check was limited enough to be a reasonable countermeasure.

According to Gabe, this module was not aimed at scraping anyone's web usage or browsing history (not even for game cheat sites), but just to detect whether a machine was likely to be automatically dialing a hack's DRM server, and then sending hashed copies of those, and only those, entries to Valve to flag as a potential cheat. I can imagine that a lot of the gaming community would consider that reasonable behaviour, if it was effective at cutting down on cheats.

Whether Valve is telling the truth, I don't know. I suspect so (Gabe seems smart enough not to try lying to the internet, though, so any deception is likely to be that of omission). Whether this is right or wrong is a matter between you and your shaman/vicar/rabbi/mullah/conscience/etc.

AimHere··on Steam's VAC reads all the domains you visited
>I've poked around a few of the DLLs since I saw this and am unable to find anything even remotely close to what this does.

This is part of the Valve anticheat system. I believe that the idea is that this sort of code is downloaded on the fly by the game client to make it harder to reverse engineer by game cheaters. What you have to do is to find some way of dumping the code that VAC pulls from the steam servers, and of course Valve tries to make that difficult for legit reasons (regardless of whether this particular snippet of code is legit).

AimHere··on Silicon Valley billionaires believe in the free market, as long as they benefit
I think that the original use of the term was as a synonym for anarchist, because anarchism had been outlawed.

Libertarians have to call themselves something - I figure they can keep the word 'libertarian' and old-school libertarians can keep calling themselves anarchists or, if they believe in some sort of government, 'libertarian socialists' (which is also a fun phrase to drop in front of the more ill-educated right-libertarians). The nearest alternative to libertarian in current use is 'anarcho-capitalist' which is problematic for right-libertarians in that most of them believe in some sort of government ('Anarchists who want the police to protect them from their slaves') and problematic for anarchists who think that the capitalist employer/worker relationship is entirely incompatible with any conception of anarchism.

Neo-liberal is already in use for more conventional political outlooks, as other posters have pointed out.

AimHere··on Julia, the One Programming Language to Rule Them All
The argument is more along the lines of 'the users for these systems use 1-based subscripts in their technical literature so we'll make conversion from formula-in-physics-paper to running code easier by having the corresponding data structure match the user's expectation.'

0-based arrays are easier for computer folks who occasionally have to implement the code that translates 'a[i]' into a memory access. 1-based is easier for physicists and mathematicians who were subscripting variables before there were computer implementations to worry about and had a pile of literature already written using that idiom. It's just a clash of conventions.

AimHere··on Peter Higgs: I wouldn't be productive enough for today's academic system
He was a professor of physics at Edinburgh University, and he certainly showed up on the campus there. I saw him around, but I don't recall witnessing him doing any work since I didn't study much physics.

I'm guessing what he did was teach classes and supervise graduate students, put out the occasional paper now and again, just like any other professor. Also, his name would allow Edinburgh University to say 'We have that famous Professor Higgs working for OUR Physics department' to any passing Science Funding Authority or Corporate R&D department thinking of handing out a research grant in physics, or to any rich foreign parents looking for somewhere to send their physics-inclined offspring.

I'm sure he was pretty good value for money just for his name alone...

AimHere··on DMCA takedown on GPL-copyrighted code
That's a possibility; or perhaps the OP is recruiting Hacker News as a vigilante mob to scare off the person whose code he ripped off; or perhaps this is an experiment or a prank to see what sort of internet vigilanteism can be whipped up on Hacker News.

So far, I'm leaning slightly in favour of the guy sending out the DMCA takedowns, in that someone claiming to be him put his code on the internet first by about 6 months, if the internet's timestamps are to be believed, and OP hasn't provided a convincing rebuttal even to that.

Whether these guys are talking about the same code or whether there's some other evidence that clears the OP remains to be seen.

AimHere··on Bertrand Russell: In Praise of Idleness (1932)
>The number one economic fallacy is this: he claims that doing a job, all other things being equal, removes bread from someone elses mouth. This is 100% false.

Russell agrees with you, through the medium of sarcasm and reductio ad absurdum:

>If this argument were valid, it would only be necessary for us all to be idle in order that we should all have our mouths full of bread.

He prefixes citing the argument with:

>Before advancing my own arguments for laziness, I must dispose of one which I cannot accept.

in case you don't get the sarcasm.

AimHere··on Bertrand Russell: In Praise of Idleness (1932)
>The theme was also propagated in the novel 1984,concept of equality among humans was/is going to be a big disaster.

Not at all. If you want to mention an anti-egalitarian novel, Harrison Bergeron is probably the one to pick.

Orwell was very definitely big on equality and socialism - In one of his essays, circa World War 2, he even proposed a maximum wage!

1984 was largely a critique of Stalinist totalitarianism (and post-war British austerity) rather than a criticism of socialism itself. In fact, one of his problems with Stalin (as well as the previously-mentioned totalitarianism) was that Stalin was a counterrevolutionary who crushed the egalitarian revolution going on in Spain during the Civil war - Orwell was fighting alongside a Trotskyite militia at the time and recounted his ideas in Homage to Catalonia. Orwell was to the left of Stalin, if anything.

Orwell's socialism is certainitely the main thread throughout all of his work, but unfortunately his two most famous works - Animal Farm and 1984 - because they happen to be attacks on the Soviet Communist Party, are often erroneously read as attacks on socialism.

AimHere··on SteamMachines
Heh, there's still time, you never know! Perhaps Friday's announcement is a cold HL3 product launch.
AimHere··on SteamMachines
And right there you're going to need a sizeable chunk of X windows, and a C library, and network configuration utilities, hardware management tools (looks like this is aimed at commodity hardware + reference machines from Valve) and the guts of a web browser and Steam itself. I wouldn't be totally surprised to find coreutils or at least busybox in the default install too, for aiding and abetting system initialising (and to please the intrepid few who somehow make their way to a command line).
AimHere··on Artillery is building a hardcore RTS with HTML5 and WebGL
I think the reasoning behind using an RTS is likely that the company wants people to write inherently online games on their platform as part of whatever monetization strategy they have - and the other big alternatives are the MMO and MOBA genres, which would need a lot of content to be made. Having a couple of bright programmers on call - the designer is both a Starcraft celebrity and a mathematics nerd, so he likely can chip in too- would no doubt be cheaper than hiring enough artists/character designers or voice/motion capture actors to make a respectable game in some known hardcore online game genre...
← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →