HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Ajedi32

13,439 karma · joined January 5, 2015

submissionscomments
Ajedi32··on FCC wants to kill burner phones by forcing telecoms to get all customers' IDs
What I find most concerning is that this isn't a bill or law. Unelected government officials at the FCC can apparently just decide to do this.
Ajedi32··on Surveillance is not safety: A statement on the UK's latest threat to privacy [pdf]
I'm slowly coming around to the idea that closed source software was the original sin of the modern digital surveillance state.

Due to the fact that it can't easily be modified without the source, software is uniquely able to act against the interests of its owner in a way almost no other product can. Client side scanning wouldn't be viable if people could just install a mod that disables it, and remote attestation would be a much harder sell if the availability of such mods were expected.

Maybe software copyright should require releasing the source and build tools just like patents require releasing the design...

Ajedi32··on Surveillance is not safety: A statement on the UK's latest threat to privacy [pdf]
There are so many laws on the books that reviewing all of them every year is completely impossible. Doing what you propose would require the government to be greatly shrunk and simplified (which, to be fair, I'm not necessarily against).

Personally I would put myself somewhere between your two "kinds of people". Many individual laws are bad and should be changed, but the rule of law itself is a good, stabilizing force that should generally be respected. If people only followed laws they 100% agree with then that would be chaos, therefore even bad laws deserve at least a modicum of respect.

Ajedi32··on Anti-social: It's fads, not friends, which now dominate social media feeds
Yes the social aspect does definitely still exist, it's just half buried by all the other nonsense.
Ajedi32··on Anti-social: It's fads, not friends, which now dominate social media feeds
Interesting, I thought Revanced was just for YouTube, I didn't realize it worked with other social media sites too.
Ajedi32··on Meta confirms 1000s of Instagram accounts were hacked by abusing its AI chatbot
Yes, when you're selling a product you can price the risk of lawsuits into whatever you're charging customers. You can't do that with free software without making it no longer free.

"No problem: just don't get sued" only works if legal battles are free and/or the law makes it so blatently obvious that you're not liable that nobody would bother to try.

Ajedi32··on Meta confirms 1000s of Instagram accounts were hacked by abusing its AI chatbot
Software can be copied infinitely, so even $1 of liability is effectively infinite since an unlimited number of people can potentially use it and sue you when it blows up.

Nobody's going to be distributing software on the internet for free if the cost of insurance alone precludes that.

Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
I literally just said it's not imminent. I'm focusing my attention on it in this thread because that's what this thread is about. Not like I walk the streets proclaiming our doom on my days off. :P

Also, as I just said, there are less severe short and medium-term problems caused by low birth rates as well so it's not just the looming threat of human extinction I'm concerned about; that's just the biggest and most obvious consequence so it's a convenient counterpoint to people asserting that low birth rates are not a problem at all.

Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
Well, like I said, if the trend is caused by something that's not easily reversible, and there's no negative feedback loop which would naturally cause birth rates to come back up in the future, then unless something happens to reverse the trend then mathematically speaking the end result of global birth rates below replacement rate is human extinction.

Granted that's not an imminent threat, it would take quite a few generations at current first-world birth rates. But I still find it a concerning long-term trend, and there are a lot of less severe negative consequences that could occur between now and then. If you care to dig into it more, this podcast episode has a good discussion of the short-term problems, which go beyond just elderly care: https://www.thepoliticalorphanage.com/p/the-great-baby-short...

Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
The problem is that's not a likely hypothesis. There's no evidence lack of capacity is the cause of declining birth rates. In fact there's strong evidence for the opposite: countries with more resources to go around tend to have lower birth rates than countries with less resources. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?most_rec... There's no equilibrium here, if anything the feedback loop is positive rather than negative. That's the concerning part.

I thought this was common knowledge, but given the reaction I'm getting in this thread I guess it's not as common as I thought and I should have explained myself better in my original comment.

Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
Correct, but my point is unless we find a way to intentionally fix the problem we're going to unintentionally walk into a disaster.

I don't fault your logic, but I don't want to accept that disaster is inevitable.

Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
Because all plausible theorized causes (birth control, global reduction in poverty enabled by technology, women's rights) are not temporary conditions. (Or at least we better hope they aren't.)
Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
Lack of personal space is certainly not the cause of our declining birth rates. People in wealthy countries with lots of personal space actually tend to have lower birth rates than poorer countries with less. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?most_rec...
Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
All plausible theories I've heard for the cause of humanity's unprecedented, historically low birth rates are things that could not occur in less intelligent species. (Birth control, women's rights, hedonism enabled by modern technology, etc.)

> isn’t that catastrophising

Yes, I'm only putting that forward as the worst case scenario to make the point that this can't just be ignored. As I said in other comments, this almost certainly won't actually result in extinction because there are other corrective factors which would occur long before that, but none of those scenarios are particularly desirable either. (E.g. Civilizational collapse returning humanity to pre-industrical birth rates, global takeover by theocratic governments that ban birth control, etc.)

The only non-catastrophic corrective factors that sound plausible to me involve some kind of intentional collective action on our part that reverses the trend, which won't happen if everyone's attitude is the same as the root commenter's. (Granted, maybe there are other possible corrective factors I haven't thought of, but if so I'd like to discuss what those are rather than just have the problem dismissed with a hand wave.)

Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
> They tend to overgrow their environment, outstrip resources, and then collapse.

That's not what's happening here. Birth rates are below 2.1 in many countries who are no where close to "outstripping their resources". There are other factors causing the contraction which have nothing to do with resource limitations.

In fact it seems like it's the opposite: richer nations with more resources tend to have lower birth rates. That's the scary part because it means there's no equilibrium to be reached. Birth rates could, in theory, remain low until humanity ceases to exist.

Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
The population is not "reaching equilibrium", it's shrinking. If it was reaching equilibrium you'd expect the births per women to be slowly reducing until it approaches 2.1 and then staying there. It's dropping substantially below that. And there doesn't seem to be any evidence that the contraction is temporary, the causal factors seem largely unrelated to the existing population size.
Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
If the "cogs of the machine" freeze up and economy tanks the top 1% will be fine. You might not be.
Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
If the trend doesn't reverse, it's mathematically guaranteed.

But realistically, I agree. Civilizational collapse would happen long before extinction, which seems like it would almost certainly return the birth rate back to pre-industrial levels. I just don't think that's a desirable outcome either.

Or, even more realistically, nations with state religions that effectively outlaw birth control and/or women's rights will take over the world, and nations which don't do those things will collapse. That also seems like a bad outcome to me.

Point is, I don't think it's wise to treat this like it's not a problem.

Ajedi32··on India's surprise baby bust
Well, in the extreme case, human extinction seems like a pretty bad thing.
Ajedi32··on They’re made out of weights
Like this? https://xkcd.com/505/
Ajedi32··on Bitcoin Has Longest Losing Streak Since August in Bruising Week
Are there other cryptocurrencies that use quantum safe cryptography that aren't being affected by the downswing?
Ajedi32··on The advertising cartel coming to your web browser
Correct. The whole point of this proposal (and other related ones like FloC/the topics API) is to get rid of the former while preserving the effectiveness of the latter.
Ajedi32··on Pwnd Blaster: Hacking your PC using your speaker without ever touching it
The ability to "type words" is worse than all of that. Just type Win+R, "cmd", Enter and you've got arbitrary code execution on the connected PC. I think that was GP's point. Any competent security team would be aware of such risks.
Ajedi32··on The advertising cartel coming to your web browser
Maybe? Depends on what the ads are for. Obviously I'm not going to buy something I don't actually want just to support the site I'm on, but I have no particular objection to buying something I discovered through an ad if it's something I would buy anyway if I discovered it organically.
Ajedi32··on The advertising cartel coming to your web browser
Because as GP alluded to, the thing it's replacing (cookies) already does exactly the same thing but isn't anonymized.
Ajedi32··on The advertising cartel coming to your web browser
This is a debate I've seen many times now on HN. I sympathize with what you're saying, but the flip side is that many users seem to prefer a free ad-supported funding model over a paid, ad-free model. If a site is going to be serving me ads anyway, then all else being equal I'd rather them make as much money off each impression as possible to incentivize them to keep providing me with free services. The privacy and resource cost of a user's browser sending anonymized attribution statistics is very minimal.
Ajedi32··on The advertising cartel coming to your web browser
Agreed, this can't be worse than what it's replacing. Still, the author has some interesting points I hadn't considered before.

I guess from the advertiser's perspective this standard could be a concern, because the loss of cookie-based tracking might make it harder for them to develop alternative attribution tracking methods that don't have the same data quality problems.

Ajedi32··on The advertising cartel coming to your web browser
Sort of. Cookies track you as an individual with a unique identifier. The conversion report only tracks anonymized aggregate statistics that can't be used to identify you as an individual.
Ajedi32··on YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
> You either want it to be unedited or you don't.

You want it visually identical but not necessarily bit-for-bit identical. Compression and transcoding should not cause validation to fail unless the compression artifacts are particularly severe, but even a tiny, one-pixel change that substantially alters the appearance of the photo should cause validation to fail.

And yes I agree this is hard to quantify and impossible with existing algorithms, that was my point.

Ajedi32··on Can the stockmarket swallow Anthropic, SpaceX and OpenAI?
Isn't it illegal for publicly traded companies to hide such information from their shareholders? What do you mean by "obfuscated"? The numbers are disclosed, but you think they're unclear somehow?
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →