HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AnonCoward42

298 karma · joined June 19, 2022

submissionscomments
AnonCoward42··on Why do cats knead?
> Why do cats knead?

> So why do cats knead? Although the reason is uncertain, the most likely explanation is that it is a leftover behavior from kittenhood, Susan Hazel, an associate professor of animal behavior, welfare and ethics at the University of Adelaide in Australia, told Live Science. During nursing, a kitten rhythmically treads its paws on the mother's body to stimulate the flow of milk.

The answer is speculation. Yeah, that would be my guess too, but do we really need "science" for that? (and by science I mean some authority figure that apparently has a title)

This looks much more like what TV sells us as "the science".

AnonCoward42··on How's the Stack Overflow strike going?
Isn't ChatGPT also using SO? If SO would stop and there would be no replacement, then the answers might get worse. My take is that these two currently complement. In my opinion the issue with SO and with most social media is the obsession with metrics. It would be nice if they took more of an HN approach to metrics (votes particularly).
AnonCoward42··on iOS 17 automatically removes tracking parameters from links you click on
Of all of them isn't Google the only one that is actually incentivized to keep the data they get on you to themselves, because of their business model? It sounds bad for Google when they sell their data to others, so they'd feed a competitor for personalized ads. I might be wrong tho.

It's obvious, but I want to make clear, that this doesn't make Google less scary or more trustworty. Avoiding Google is still advised imo.

edit: replace "private" with "to themselves"

AnonCoward42··on Will the Internet Forget Russophobia?
> There was no genocide by Ukrainians in Donbass, this Russian propaganda has been a persistent narrative that has any had a single word of truth to it.

I used double-quotes, mostly because both sides claim a genocide. It's clear that both are at war. A dirty fact of war is that civilians are going to die in the war and both sides are going to lie about every aspect of the war. That is not different this time and we ("the west") are not a neutral observer.

This war feels forced especially with the western interference in the coup-d'état that led to the banishment of Yanukovych. The western narratives surrounding it make no sense at all, but we can probably agree that an elected government was replaced by a movement funded by EU and helped by the US.

We ("the west") forgot the value of peace I think or respectively what war entails.

AnonCoward42··on Will the Internet Forget Russophobia?
> The mentioned Baikal company is a supplier for russian army. The guy behind the patch every morning go to the work, knowing his job will help to launch the missiles to the Ukrainian cities killing children.

Given that the bombardment of east Ukraine preceded the 24.02.22 (by a few years), I hope you have the same standard for Ukrainians then.

> What is happening here is whitewashing a genocide machine many of russians are part of

"genocide" by Ukrainians is okay tho? Because you're very specific here that it only applies to Russians here while ignoring (and therefore whitewashing) Ukrainian acts of war that precede 24.02.22 against their own population.

AnonCoward42··on Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great
> Having every transaction recorded in a public append only but otherwise immutable ledger does not afford the privacy choice you have with fiat.

This would be good or bad for scams? For me this sounds worse for scams. Regarding choice: You could use Monero/XMR if you want to use it like (fungible,mostly anonymous) cash.

> People using fiat are not losing their life savings when they forget their bank passwords, [...]

This is not a like for like comparison. If you forget your wallet somewhere, your money is potentially gone as well. On the other hand if you have your crypto in a bank (custodial), it is the exact same as fiat (with the same caveats).

> [...] nor are they sending money to the wrong address and losing money irrecoverably.

This is maybe the only part that is really different here. Fiat doesn't have the capability to "send" at all, but banks have. The non-custodial part about crypto has the property of higher responsibility. If you have it somewhere custodial you could have the same properties as with fiat (properties not inherent to the currency).

AnonCoward42··on Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great
> What difference you mean, aside from the lack of a regulatory framework, pseudonymity (and paradoxically, lack of privacy), lack of recourse in the face of user error, and custodial issues?

Is anonymity the issue? Cash is anonymous, but you also say that crypto is not private, which makes it now good or bad in your eyes? The opportunity for recourse has nothing to do with a currency. A currency cannot give you recourse in the face of user error (or basically any). Neither fiat can do that nor crypto can.

> The "not your keys not your coins" take is hilariously dumb in light of how much "value" has evaporated in personal custodial failure.

Do you want to tell me this cannot happen with fiat? The (partly rhetorical) question also aims at both sides custodial and non-custodial fiat.

> The currency and its supporting infrastructure has everything to do with it, and crypto fails basic litmus tests to even attempt to go mainstream.

What exactly does it fail?

edit: replace one "it" with "crypto" to remove ambiguity.

AnonCoward42··on Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great
What difference does the currency make in terms of scams? I do not see the point here. For me it makes no difference if I am being scammed in BTC, LTC, or USD or Rouble. Then there are the obvious scam coins, but these are not the primary argument here (would've made more sense when attacking crypto). FTX is the primary argument and FTX is not crypto. You could basically make the same thing with fiat money. Crypto is not necessarily the problem here.

I am not much into crypto, but I know the saying: Not your keys, not your coins/money.

What is this article even? There is the very short vita. The common theme being crypto. Apparently she is also a victim (which is a sole identity by now, not sure if hers). And most importantly she hates crypto.

What does she actually do? I have no clue. She has a blog apparently, but that doesn't really warrant an article and the article should tell me why they write an article about that person.

AnonCoward42··on More than 600k students and teachers use Z-Library
> Something is legal if the society has decided it to be.

Isn't that the difference between legitimate and legal? Maybe `legitimate == legal` would be the ideal world (not thought hard enough about it).

AnonCoward42··on Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-to-end encryption
You underestimate the selection pressure. While I agree that many people would become corrupted, the profession (so to speak) attracts certain people. It is even to the point where you need some negative traits (explicitly: skeletons in the closet) to rise up, because it means you're easier to control.
AnonCoward42··on Add opt-in transparent telemetry to Go toolchain
Actually the name for it previously was spyware or the act of spying. The term telemetry is/was more neutral, but it also has a bad reputation by now (euphemism treadmill).
AnonCoward42··on What Wikipedia Did
> What's a good source of truth?

In my opinion none.

> You say that people who want to corrupt will be attracted to it. Aren't there protections against that? Does it happen often? Is it so frequent that you have zero trust or you think it's "bad source of truth"

Why are people so obsessed with a source of truth? We never had that and we still don't disregard how much we pretend that we have or wish we had one. It's not the first time in history we pretended that one exists either, but it usually ends bad.

AnonCoward42··on What Wikipedia Did
Among the reasons is that it comes with great power and authority and therefore attracts the wrong people. It is really effective to slander people for example. Another reason is that an established source of truth is inflexible and hard to change from the outside even if it is wrong, because it is used as reference for the truth (circular logic).

Using Wikipedia as an example: Everyone can edit Wikipedia, however if your edit survives is determined by a hierarchical structure that involves people (with an opinion). It doesn't need a big conspiracy, but only a few people that select which people may act on their behalf. A concrete example would be the Wikipedian Feliks in German Wikipedia who is by now convicted of defamation (via Wikipedia) and still remains part of the "Politburo" of Wikipedia altho obviously violating the official ethos.

In regards to changing Wikipedia, try removing opinions (or just circular citation) from an entry of Feliks or Kopilot (or anyone of the Politburo) and look what happens. Most likely your account is gone, but if you're lucky your edit is just reverted.

Much of it is how Wikipedia is being treated. It is/was an excellent reference book for quickly looking up information about a topic - well, just like an encyclopedia, however it's bad as a source of truth.

AnonCoward42··on What Wikipedia Did
The point that is (probably) wrong is "at request". The remaining part however is true. You can see it in the edits and discussions. In Germany the Wikipedia has a bunch of people with almost universal power in the Wikipedia - inofficially called "Politburo" (by Wikipedians that had the pleasure of editing one of their entries). These are (to our knowledge at least) not directly controlled by gov, but they however do what is in their interest.

Wikipedia is being corrupted and you should be aware of it. Having a (single) source of truth* has to end like this.

edit: *: More precisely institutions and people treating it like a single source of truth.

AnonCoward42··on What Wikipedia Did
If you put yourself on a pedestal don't be surprised if you get knocked off of it.

The response from @GSR6669 resonates with me:

> Wikipedia suspended edits & changed the definition of recession at request of the US Government. Everyone likes to poke holes in Elon’s Twitter yet no choice is infallible.

> Throwing rocks in a glass house is what makes you a real hypocrite though.

AnonCoward42··on Show HN: Boring Report, a news app that uses AI to desensationalize the news
I don't think it makes a difference in what tone you're being lied to.
AnonCoward42··on James Webb Space Telescope detects water vapor around alien planet
It's highly likely that aliens have to deal with that as well. It's to combat the mismatched division of the planet doing a full rotation around the sun and the planet doing a full rotation itself. They might even have more oddities.
AnonCoward42··on Dr. Mengele, USA Style: Lessons from Human Rights Abuses in America [pdf] (2022)
The alpha-variant was in decline and not the most common iirc, when the widespread vaccination started. Either it rains or it doesn't, but having a rainmaker tell you why his service is necessary is comforting.

> Against the early variants the vaccines were pretty effective in reducing transmission.

Even if it was true, what does it matter?

AnonCoward42··on Dr. Mengele, USA Style: Lessons from Human Rights Abuses in America [pdf] (2022)
> The alternative was panic and worse.

Either panic or (false) advertising an experimental vaccine. This does look like a false dichotomy. You might instead educate people about the potential risks and clarify the limits, so they may decide.

In the defence of vaccine producers I want to say that they at least did point out early on that they did not develop it with the goal of stopping transmission. Which maybe led some to believe "there is a chance", but it's the code for "it does not do it". This was known even before the fourth phase of the study (approval of the vaccine).

> There were already MILLIONS of people worldwide thinking the vaccines were a ONU/bill gates pedophile-satanic conspiracy, etc. A lot of people not only didn't want to understand the science, but was attacking ALL SCIENCE. Even democracy got at risk. The system had to reorganize somehow, or the bases of civilization would be at risk.

Either you believe in the vaccine or in an absurd (and very specific) conspiracy. These are both extreme view points and gov/media did themselves a disservice by sticking with one of them.

AnonCoward42··on DuckDuckGo removed the ability to filter search results
At least BingAI does provide its sources and ChatGPT/BingAI are made to be conversational, so you get the opportunity to ask actual questions and get an answer. As with everything on the internet take the answers with a couple of grains of salt.

You can also directly ask for the sources btw. In the end LLMs with access to the internet can be an abstraction to search engines. If it is good can only be assessed once you actually tried as it heavily depends on your use case and your approach.

LLMs are just a tool like everything else.

AnonCoward42··on DuckDuckGo removed the ability to filter search results
> [...] A good search engine is an investment that could pay phenomenal dividends for me, allowing me to make better decisions for my business by having better information as input. [...]

It sounds a bit like the use case of ChatGPT/BingAI. Depending on your specific use case it might be the wrong fit - especially if you want to look up PI - however it is excellent as a rubberduck/idea provider.

AnonCoward42··on AMD’s 7950X3D: Zen 4 Gets VCache
Just a small reminder that the CCD with V-Cache has way lower boost clocks and therefore performs worse in almost everything beside gaming. For casual use this is irrelevant I think, but it is still significant in many workloads. The only workload I know where V-Cache benefits more than it is hurt by lower boost clocks is gaming.

The advantage of the dual CCD design is that this only/mostly hurts in highly threaded workloads at least.

AnonCoward42··on Nuclear Power Is the Answer to Global and Environmental Energy Woes
Coal power plants, wind turbines and mostly anything else. They can end up catastrophic in a sense, but not to the same degree nuclear fission plants can end up.
AnonCoward42··on The day Windows died
The standards for what constitutes adware are a bit higher than on other OSes, however I also see this as a warning sign and I despise snap. As someone who also vets Linux installs for some relatives I used Ubuntu on these and I regret it a bit. It's nothing you can't fix yet, but it becomes an annoyance.

This and the silent introduction of phased updates and some broken updates makes me avoid Ubuntu in the future for sure. My go-to would probably be Debian which I personally use, however something like Silverblue or microOS might also be attractive in the future ... but not yet for casual users.

edit: Or maybe vanillaOS, if I ever get over the waste that is a/b partitioning.

AnonCoward42··on The day Windows died
Similar story here, but with Windows 10 instead of Windows 8. Adding advertisement to the basic UI is unacceptable and not even Android does this by default (I think even the Pixel isn't doing that). However there are some Android derivates that are doing this or are even built to do exactly that (FireOS).

I already hate the future when this becomes so ubiquituous that you cannot avoid this anymore without shooting yourself in the foot.

AnonCoward42··on The day Windows died
It depends. With new hardware you're bound to have some trouble especially on "old" Linux versions (i.e. using Ubuntu 22.04), however these issues are very often fixed by installing a newer kernel. YMMV
AnonCoward42··on Reassessing relative temporal lobe size in anthropoids and modern humans
Good point. It's still not clear if our way of surviving as a species is more successful as the "old" selection method. For the individual this is also an arbitrary goal even if some buy it as-is.
AnonCoward42··on My mindfulness practice led me to meltdown (2021)
> I wasn't born Richard Alpert. I was just born as a human being and then I learned this whole business of who I am, whether I'm good or bad, achieving or not - all that's learned along the way. And you see all those learn things separate, so you start to have this dissociative experience, where all that can become is a point of awareness. I remember the first time this happened to me, I got a terrible panic, because indeed I was gonna cease to exist.

-- Richard Alpert aka Ram Dass

I hope it's transcribed correctly.

AnonCoward42··on OpenTTD 13.0 Released
> I don't think that requiring the original game files is a huge hurdle, unless the game is very esoteric and hard to find. There are many widely-used game engines that require the game files, such as ScummVM, Rollercoaster tycoon, etc.

But then the question is: Why not use the original game with ScummVM, DosBox or a VM (with whatever OS necessary)?

AnonCoward42··on An astonishing regularity in student learning rate
It fits a common narrative in that all humans are absolutely equal in mostly everything and can be sculptured like clay.
← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →