HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Antibabelic

900 karma · joined September 1, 2025

submissionscomments
Antibabelic··on Jane Goodall has died
> Unfortunately, we will return to that level. Then 25 years later, we'll be only half that number (or worse).

What are your main reasons for thinking that?

Antibabelic··on An opinionated critique of Duolingo
Many people throughout the world certainly do not find it "easy".
Antibabelic··on An opinionated critique of Duolingo
I've never been to an English-speaking country and yet I'm pretty close to fluent. How come?
Antibabelic··on The Wind, a Pole, and the Dragon
The specificity of what they're trying to say and long Google Docs documents (apparently with their personal name in them) make me incline towards the other option.
Antibabelic··on The Simple Mathematics of Chinese Innovation
Let's put the question differently: let's imagine we already know Chinese. How much will we be potentially be able to capitalize on that knowledge in the coming years?
Antibabelic··on TikTok to Be Sold for $14B
Not all of TikTok, only the American stuff.
Antibabelic··on America's nightmare: China is moving at lightning speed to control the future
"Neo-China arrives from the future." — Nick Land

Is this a good time to start learning Mandarin?

Antibabelic··on The great sameness: a comic on how AI makes us more alike
LLMs and image generation models will also give crazy variable output when you give an open-ended prompt and increase temperature. However, we usually want high coherence and relevance, both from human and synthetic responses.
Antibabelic··on The Simple Mathematics of Chinese Innovation
Is it a good idea to start learning Mandarin in 2025 to be able to follow these Chinese scientific innovations?
Antibabelic··on The great sameness: a comic on how AI makes us more alike
> Which is why, historically, ~all scientific discoveries have been made by multiple researchers (or teams) independently, at roughly the same time

This is quite a big claim. All of them? I know there are many discoveries that fit the pattern you're pointing out, but I wouldn't go as far as to say all, or even the majority of them do.

Antibabelic··on Lee Gold, the Most Important Gamer in Roleplaying After Gary Gygax
The conversation at the end is painful. What were Gary Gygax's attitudes towards women?
Antibabelic··on How aesthetics destroyed privacy and polarized us
This post aligns well with what Hans-Georg Moeller talks about in You and Your Profile: Identity After Authenticity. Particularly, what he calls "second-order observation", we see ourselves how others see us (online).

> Tech CEOs talk about disrupting markets, but the concept of disruption has been detached from its social meaning: disruptive technologies change us, and our culture.

There is some difference in spirit between OP's attitude and Prof. Moeller's, however. Yes, our culture is changing. However, this doesn't have to necessarily be a bad (or a good) thing. Human life is always changing. Choosing to embrace this new reality is just as valid a choice as rejecting or fighting it, and perhaps a more healthy one. Or not. That's why this question is complicated.

Antibabelic··on The great sameness: a comic on how AI makes us more alike
There's a deliberateness to human creativity that goes beyond simply "remixing existing stuff", even if it's a significant part of it. Think about how you'd write a piece of software. The process behind writing a book or making a painting isn't fundamentally dissimilar. There's a reason why people use the word "derivative" pejoratively.
Antibabelic··on Genode OS Framework
> The framework aligns the construction principles of L4 with Unix philosophy. In line with Unix philosophy, Genode is a collection of small building blocks, out of which sophisticated systems can be composed. But unlike Unix, those building blocks include not only applications but also all classical OS functionalities including kernels, device drivers, file systems, and protocol stacks.

That's very interesting, but does it actually work in practice?

Antibabelic··on The great sameness: a comic on how AI makes us more alike
I'm not one to usually defend AI, but if I understand you correctly, humans also fail your criteria for being capable of creating original, innovative content. If you ask people the same question over and over again, I imagine the variability in the responses you'll get will be quite limited. Tell me if I'm misunderstanding your thought.
Antibabelic··on The great sameness: a comic on how AI makes us more alike
We still share a baseline reality. This is how people who are stranded in places with unfamiliar languages and cultures are still able to build bridges.
Antibabelic··on The great sameness: a comic on how AI makes us more alike
Are you sure? Yes, LLMs can be irrelevant and incoherent. But people seem to produce results that are more variable even when staying relevant and coherent (and "uncreative").
Antibabelic··on The Wind, a Pole, and the Dragon
- I am using "intent" and "intentionality" in their everyday manner, which, ironically, would've been clear to you if you paid attention to my intent, rather than the "words" that you seem to loathe so. From Dictionary.com: intent — the act or fact of meaning to do something; intentionality — the fact or quality of being done on purpose or with intent.

- It's great that you mention Stitch, because what I'm trying to tell you is directly related to his theory as presented in e.g. Mindreading. What he terms "desire detection mechanisms" are what I'm referring to as our ability to discern intent, which is how you're able to make sense of other people's actions (whether verbal or non-verbal).

Antibabelic··on The Wind, a Pole, and the Dragon
Logic shows that you can prove anything from a contradiction. No logic means everything is true. So I don't think the rejection of logic is conductive to constructive conversation.
Antibabelic··on The Wind, a Pole, and the Dragon
Just because I'm on Hacker News doesn't mean I'm an "engineer". In fact, my education is in linguistics, so the idea that we don't use language to think isn't novel to me (or relevant here). However, saying "there is no such thing as intent" is very strange. I've given you an example of intentionality in action, are you saying people don't act to bring about their desires? You seem to be refuting your thesis that "there is no such thing as intent" yourself by, for example, talking about your ideas here or having a startup. Which, I'm assuming, is trying to achieve something. That's intent by definition.
Antibabelic··on Resurrect the Old Web
What have you built so far?
Antibabelic··on The Wind, a Pole, and the Dragon
Of course there is such a thing as intent. When you're hungry, you formulate a plan about getting something to eat, which you then execute. It's more correct to say that there is no such thing as a "statement". People don't go around declaring "The sky is blue.", "My dog's name is Zeus". People go around influencing the world to achieve their goals, including with language. When you say "There is no such thing as intent", this is less of a statement about the state of affairs, as much as an attempt to alter the reader's model of the world to align with yours, one that apparently doesn't include the concept of "intent". Same goes for all the statements I've made here. Language is an API for indirectly manipulating people's cognitive states.
Antibabelic··on Microsoft blocks Israel’s use of its tech in mass surveillance of Palestinians
It was located in the Netherlands because the Netherlands has excellent privacy and data protection laws. It's the same reason so much cybercrime is traced back to Dutch servers.
Antibabelic··on The Wind, a Pole, and the Dragon
I think you're making a mistake in placing "meaning" within "context", rather than intent. This is why language works. Yes, it is "vague", but it's often enough for us to understand what our interlocutor wants from us.
Antibabelic··on Resurrect the Old Web
> this is about a post-symbolic era, which has some proprietary elements

What does this mean? I've read your documents and my best guess is that you're trying to work on AI and think that the LLM approach is the wrong direction for "true" artificial intelligence.

Antibabelic··on You didn't see it coming
I wasn't talking about "truth" in the abstract either. There aren't any more "deluded" people on 4chan than anywhere else. And yet it's full of people posting lies, hoaxes and made up stories. Why is that?
Antibabelic··on Top Programming Languages 2025
Clojure being so low, including below Prolog of all things, is so obviously wrong.
Antibabelic··on You didn't see it coming
Could you elaborate on what you mean? I'm not quite sure what kind of hidden truth you're referring to.
Antibabelic··on Introduction to Programming Languages
Doesn't seem to cover any logic programming, that's a shame.
Antibabelic··on You didn't see it coming
Ah, 4chan, the final bastion of truth
← PreviousPage 8 of 9Next →