HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ArchTypical

160 karma · joined April 2, 2018

submissionscomments
ArchTypical··on Show HN: Easy-to-use curl command to send email notifications
I've worked at multiple companies where we created something like this internally for email and text messages.

Curl an API and out it goes. It's trivial to setup for yourself.

ArchTypical··on The Homeless Crisis Is Getting Worse in America’s Richest Cities
> give people housing.

The population of the tent city in Santa Ana california was an unmitigated disaster for those who took the vouchers and residents. That did not work because the population of people living on the street in Southern California are doing it by choice (be it for the freedom to do drugs, mental illness or other defect). People who want help, generally don't get turned away in high income areas - every single church in the wealthiest areas, have a program and members willing to help those in need.

ArchTypical··on The Homeless Crisis Is Getting Worse in America’s Richest Cities
> This is just provably false

Utah is not an example that proves anything. It's a fairly unusual area when talking about this problem. Utah's entire population is less than Los Angeles.

The claim that 91% of Utah's homeless population was abated is somewhat suspicious, given the remaining 14k would mean they had a previous 155k+ - which outstrips the homeless count of most major cities (including Los Angeles). This is not as cut an dry as "make more housing" because that isn't demonstrated. Certainly not with numbers that are all over the place.

ArchTypical··on Is eval evil? Just-in-time compiling
> any eval is bad

Saying eval is just confusing the concept with the implementation. There's no evidence that metaprogramming is "bad" unless you are ready to define "bad". Might as well say pointers are "bad" in the same vein.

ArchTypical··on If I were to invent a programming language for the 21st century
> Being more english like is actually a hardship not a benefit because naturally language is famously ambiguous and difficult to decode

The rules are not any worse to express the exact same operations and relationships. English would need to be augmented to necessarily express the same things. The syntax would change, but thats the point. It doesnt solve anything. Making programs more verbose and approachable is a common theme in scripting languages already. How far is too far?

ArchTypical··on Subsidies to Amazon Are Uneconomical, Un-American, and Unconstitutional
Dominate the market, conservatives like it, liberals decry it. Take subsidies because you want to get some free money, you get the reverse edit: liberals also hate subsidy corruption (good note).
ArchTypical··on Orangutans are the only great apes besides humans to ‘talk’ about the past
> is a bird or a honey bee more intelligent?

That's a broader question than chicken or bee. A crow is definitely more intelligent than a bee.

ArchTypical··on I Used to Be Homeless
Another problem is the conflation of homelessness with heroine users. Forget the professional homeless (which my fiancee's parents have been at times). The problem is we treat both as "homeless" when they are very different animals. Social programs tend to elevate and help those who can be and it doesn't look like a dent is made because, statistically, the remaining homeless are either deranged (renting to newly rehabilitated homeless has wrecked properties I managed) or drug users.

>You can start by not judging the homeless.

It's not a complex topic, but the judgement is based on information and the existing information speaks volumes.

ArchTypical··on Google, Facebook, and Amazon benefit from an outdated definition of “monopoly”
> But so can anybody else. Google sells ads on their search engine to anyone.

There's no guarantee (read the demand partner legal disclaimers, there's specifically NO guarantees) that there's an equitable distribution. There have been analyses to show that the algorithm has short-circuits to benefit Google products, featured here on HN and other places. I don't have them onhand, but it's openly discussed (meaning beyond being taboo):

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/09/21/google-staff-discussed-tweak...

ArchTypical··on Google, Facebook, and Amazon benefit from an outdated definition of “monopoly”
> Google's only product is online advertising

That's not true. Not even from a particular viewpoint. You might want to rephrase that.

Google's primary revenue stream is from online advertising. They have a myriad of products, without which, the revenue stream would dry up. Youtube is a platform and a product and a brand. Google Search. GMail. Etc.

ArchTypical··on People are “consistently inconsistent” in reasoning about controversial topics
When there's no candidate, it's still money that wins initiatives in the western USA. I don't care what that particular study concluded over 40 races of self-financed Gov candidates because it's not compelling. Existing studies of interest that acknowledge definitive correlation only differ in how to measure the degree and where diminishing returns occur.

> There's a large empirical literature on the issue and the conclusion is that money is more or less irrelevant in politics.

That's simply nonsense.

ArchTypical··on YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation financially impossible
> If we can replace generic, low quality content...

When you put up guardrails (so many that people can't even keep up to date with what the automated system detects), that's exactly what you get. The words and images of countless properties would have to be filtered and pulled.

Regardless of what we would hope to happen, people simply ride whatever bland waves generate the most views. This is partly why we have streams of people eating and such, although the "newsy" channels would be hamstrung by this, you can imagine even the "food" streams would be impacted if they dared to say or show the icon of the food they are eating!

This is the technological culmination of capitalistic corruption of freedom vis a vis intellectual property.

ArchTypical··on YouTube CEO calls EU’s proposed copyright regulation financially impossible
The advertising budgets spent on DFP (now the overwhelming majority of budgets) makes it obvious. Youtube makes money. It prints money by information trading on top of that. Subscriptions on top of that. Google covers costs. Maybe not all that money comes back to Youtube as a department, but published revenue numbers are a game for an organization of that size.

A guaranteed adserv on every CDN delivery (and again over a certain number of minutes) is more than the content and serve cost. CPMs for video are net 3$, at least. I don't know who's doing the math, but a link would be interesting with someone demonstrating how they are upside down.

ArchTypical··on C2x: the next real revision of the C standard
> The C language is finished

There's no evidence of this. There's just existing code. Ok. There's existing code in lots of other languages with different syntax (large and small differences). So what?

The latest video about Oden was a fantastic primer on QoL changes that should be standard, but there are people who always think what they learned is optimal. These are the same people who trivialize evidence to the contrary, in defense of their particular viewpoint.

ArchTypical··on China confounds all that western liberals believed about the net
> There’s a vast chasm between the government being used as a tool for collective action and government being used as a tool for control.

Doesn't matter how deep. It's a short jump. The former is a characterization of the latter. They achieve the same goals and someone is awaiting their turn to use that tool.

ArchTypical··on ‘Remarkable’ global decline in the number of children women are having
> Raising one kid yields far more purchases than a Tinder Plus subscription and a pack of prophylactics.

That was described by the parent post. That's why the push for immigration can be traced back to increased capitalistic opportunity.

> It is certainly not the "capitalism" strawman pushing aggressive gender politics.

Again, he did not describe that.

> You're also ignoring agency completely

No, he described it in sweeping generalities eg Why would someone have a kid in the current environment? - a direct reference to the wealth-education of the middle class, where you're smart enough to maximize, but not able to ascend leveraging those choices.

The primary issue with the rant is how he starts with "You" to mean a nebulous powers-that-be and then asks questions and makes statements from the perspective of the middle class.

Read it again for clarity. There's nothing about his comment that hasn't been said before.

ArchTypical··on What’s the real reason Costco employees check receipts at the exit?
Correct. It gives time for the staff (eg security) to decide what they want to do with you in the case of suspected theft or deception. You don't have to stop, and sometimes I don't. It's not a legal requirement and any legal challenge is less cost effective for them if you aren't a suspect.

The fact that isn't obvious, is not surprising but it is elementary, regardless of professions to the contrary.

ArchTypical··on Sundar Pichai: ‘Technology Doesn’t Solve Humanity’s Problems’
> Face the truth. If you want no killing, Your enemy isn’t Google, it’s your neighbour.

> it's not Google's fault either.

Starting from a false truth, you can come to any conclusion. Google is responsible for choosing to enable immoral acts and pretending there are no fault actors is one of your faults.

ArchTypical··on Ads just work, no matter what you think
I can tell the difference between Coke, Pepsi, Diet Coke, Diet Pepsi, fountain or bottle or can, and often which fast food establishment the coke came from if it's fountain. There's nothing about special about it, anymore than telling the difference between tuna and toro. After a bit of experience, it's not challenging.
ArchTypical··on What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick?
> then ask them to make a decision

You don't see the irony in that, when talking about the Placebo effect? This discussion is about an implicit assumption.

ArchTypical··on What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick?
> Autonomy is not a problem of medical treatment,

Talking about it outside of the specific conflict, is disingenuous. Everyone understands how important Autonomy is. That's part of the issue, not a supporting argument to value it over the health of a patient. If there's no patient, there's no Autonomy either.

ArchTypical··on A List of Open Questions
> Is there something qualitatively different about personal meetings, and if so, where is it? Is it eye contact? Body language?

Over 50% of our communication is nonverbal language. Body language largely, and no small part olfactory plus auditory (which video conferencing interferes or blocks). This is not an open question.

> when humans have engaged in unarmed combat for millions of years and every major country has long lineages of specialized competitive martial arts

Because combat wasn't formalized then funded to be inclusive and communicated to the world. This is not an open question.

I'm sure there's more on this list, but maybe someone can update it.

ArchTypical··on Engineers Shouldn’t Write ETL
I wrote plenty of ETL. Maintained high throughput using whatever I could find. Then I got another job and had to write ETL for AdTech, where the volume is unlimited. Nothing about it is surprising or hard. Engineers are great at handling known data and transforms, then adapting to unknown data.
ArchTypical··on Instant runoff voting is the system we need
But it's harder to understand consequences, which change over time. So the explanation is deceptively simple. Like the game of life. Random Ballot is simple to explain and is a lottery pool. Simpler than IRV.
ArchTypical··on Ask HN: Task list/to-do tools like Trello, but with checkboxes?
Asana is the elegant todo list they are looking for.
ArchTypical··on SF fines two landords $2.25M for illegal Airbnb rentals
Idioms are not literal. The implication of my original comment, is now spelled out.
ArchTypical··on SF fines two landords $2.25M for illegal Airbnb rentals
You literally need to look up the definition of what literally means.
ArchTypical··on Philosophy Has Made Plenty of Progress
> Because suffering creates a need for religion

Life is suffering. There is always pain and sometimes joy, due to our biology. Which is why religion will always exist, even if it's just a lucky rabbit's foot.

ArchTypical··on The End Is Near for Mobile Apps?
This is very common around anyone who is a heavy phone user for photos or as their main digital device.
ArchTypical··on How I lost my faith in Lisp (2002)
> some of these are more insulting than others, and care should be exercised before applying this word to people who you do not wish to offend

This is not in the definition. Please try to stay honest when chastising someone for not being accurate.

> a : destitute of knowledge or education

> also : lacking knowledge or comprehension of the thing specified

> b : resulting from or showing lack of knowledge or intelligence

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →