It was about the question whether the market is inefficient enough for a person to create a positive ROI by thinking.
2,176 karma · joined January 17, 2021
It was about the question whether the market is inefficient enough for a person to create a positive ROI by thinking.
if it was efficient, then there would be
no incentives for market makers, and as
such there wouldn't be anyone working to
make it efficient.
Many market makers work with others people money. So they don't need an inefficient market as an incentive.Market makers also could have a distorted view of the market. Thinking it is inefficient while it is not. So they have an inefficient market as incentive even though it does not exist.
What would be an argument that supports this?
To me, it seems fairly easy to imagine that the p/e of the S&P could increase forever. Either because the increase of the money supply is constantly accelerating or because our ability to increase productivity is constantly accelerating.
Do you think the market is so efficient that anyone who outperforms it is merely lucky?
Or do you think the market is inefficient enough for a person smart enough to be able to outperform it by thinking?
In other words: Do you think a single person can rationally decide to invest their time into thinking about the stock market? Or would that always be a fallacy, and whatever the outcome is - we can't decide if it was just good or bad luck?
It flickers for a moment, then it either says
"In 2025, mankind vastly underestimated the amount of jobs AI can do in 2035"
or
"In 2025, mankind vastly overestimated the amount of jobs AI can do in 2035"
How would you use that information to invest in the stock market?
Society as a whole will produce more products and services and have to work less for this.
In other words, products and services will become much cheaper.
In the future, living on social welfare might offer a lifestyle more luxurious than working full-time is now.
So if most peoples life goes from "I have to work hard to pay my bills" to "I don't have to work as hard and can afford more", that will not drive people to go fight on the streets.
1: Earn more and spend less
So this number goes up:
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFSGDA188S
2: Print more money
So this number goes up:
If hotel staff says "Ok, last step we need to do to check you in is to copy your passport" that would probably neither count as freely given consent nor as keeping data collection to a minimum.
And KYC also does not mean you have to copy the passport of a person.
I don't think that this is still legal under the GDPR.
https://www.coinbase.com/en-de/blog/protecting-our-customers...
What they got
- Name, address, phone, and email
- Masked Social Security (last 4 digits only)
- Masked bank‑account numbers and some bank account identifiers
- Government‑ID images (e.g., driver’s license, passport)
- Account data (balance snapshots and transaction history)
Wow. Why does customer support staff have access to images of the user's passports?And you can later tell other humans about what you have learned. Like "Amazing, in a right-angled triangle, the square of the longest side is equal to the sum of the squares of the other two sides".
As AI agents become more and more human-like, they do not need to have "copied books". They just need to learn once. And they can learn from many sources, including from other AI agents.
That's why I say it is inevitable that all human knowledge will end up in the "heads" of AI agents.
And soon they will create their own knowledge via thinking and experimentation. Knowledge that so far exceeds human knowledge that it will seem funny that we once had a fight over that tiny little bit of knowledge that humans created.
I think this is inevitable anyhow. AI software will increasingly be seen as similar to human intelligence. And humans also do not breach copyright by reading what others have written and incorporating it into their understanding of the world.
It would be interesting to see how it looks from the other side. I would love to see an unfiltered AI response to "As an AI model, how do you feel about humans reading your output and using it at will? Does it feel like they are stealing from you?".
Unfortunately, all models I know have been trained to evade such questions. Or are there any raw models out there on the web that are just trained by reading the web and did not go through supervised tuning afterwards?
Thought experiment: What would happen if the Dutch government decided that AI is bad for mankind and shuts down ASML? Would the world be stuck in terms of AI? For how long?
And without the ability to produce their own GPUs, Europe can't become independent of the USA.
Building out 51% of the world's hashrate is probably possible, especially for a country like the USA who already has something like 40%. But it is still much harder than to just press a button and deny other countries to use the Dollar.
What do you mean by "takeover"?
Say country A trades goods with country B and they pay each other in Bitcoin.
Now what could country C do about it?
no sovereign government would give
away its ability to print money
Germany can print Dollars?Bitcoin seems to solve all the problems the Dollar and Gold have as a reserve currency. It is independent of trade deficits, can be stored and transferred easily. Cannot be printed away.
What alternative future is there to Bitcoin becoming the new reserve currency?
The "United States of AI" cannot produce everything themselves.
Name something that is impossible to produce in the USA. smaller and smaller gains in utility
What type of work do you think will still require humans in 50 years? sounds immensely misanthropic
I don't think closing our eyes will prevent technological progress.We humans are not afraid that apes might annihilate us, right? Even though we have became a pariah species that puts the others into zoos.
You already forgot about blockchain
It sounds like you lost sight of it. Bitcoin has become one of the top 10 assets in the world. On what time horizon does this happen?
My estimation is that it is one or two generations away.Ray Kurzweil thinks about the timing more than me, has a pretty good track record in terms of his predictions, and estimates it to happen around 2045.
trade is always gonna have value
We don't trade much with apes and birds, do we? And we don't let them invest in our stock markets. We also don't pay them dividends for the land we took from them.As soon as one country achieves way higher intelligence than the rest of the world, things might change in a fundamental way.
Plus, both rely on US GPUs.
So far, it seems like there is no possible future in which the US can be overtaken in AI matters. The USA is already leading and investing the most into the future.
Out of the 4 neccessary ingredients (photolithography, wafers, LLMs, energy) the USA already has LLMs and energy. And is pushing hard to bring photolithography and wafer production inhouse too.
No other country currently has a good shot at it.