HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AsymetricCom

339 karma · joined June 7, 2013

submissionscomments
AsymetricCom··on Silicon Valley Has an Arrogance Problem
I can think of something more powerful than code.

All the hardware that enables code to do anything.

Code lives in an ivory tower. It's pretty easy to build something productive in that kind of environment, but then thinking that your productivity in an ivory tower will be matched in the real world is just ignorant.

To demonstrate this property, consider iTunes, probably one of the most key pieces of software today, responsible for distribution of many types of media across the globe while paying authors instantly, at a small cost of freedom for both parties.

Now write that code on pamphlets and drop it from a plane over Africa. Pay close attention to what happens. If you look close enough you'll notice not a god damn thing happens that is not related to the physical medium being re-appropriated for productive uses. They won't reverse engineer the code, they won't abstract away the key business principles and build a new prosperous Africa, they won't learn how to program either.

You see, Africa has no need for a digital distribution system with DRM. They don't even have a network capable of carrying it's data to 99% of the population. Even if you set one up and gave away iCrap to every African, you'd never recoup the astronomical costs selling copies of bits.

The thing SV needs to realize is they are not the first coders and they are already surrounded by code, at the level of societies, religions and governments. These coders are much better because they've been dealing with inconsistent platforms for hundreds of years without the benefit of virtualization layers or government-enforced standard protocols.

Sure, you can generate the same kind of code that runs governments and religions from a computer, but you're forgetting the fact that that computer exists inside the system of government.

As soon as you remove the government, your hardware gets stolen by people with better hardware, your software gets stolen by people with better software, and your communications data gets mined by deep packet inspection, extracting value just like an invisible tax or inflation. That last one was a joke, you need government for that.

AsymetricCom··on Silicon Valley Has an Arrogance Problem
Can you explain to me the opinion here? I think it's very cut-and-dry telling like it is. SV needs customers and customers are in US, living US ways. Where is the opinion?
AsymetricCom··on All around the world, labour is losing out to capital
Open your eyes and maybe you'll see why art can stop that.
AsymetricCom··on Seattle Mayor: I have Comcast, and I would like better service
The fact that it didn't happen means that the people it would have been transporting aren't worth the investment from an economic perspective. In the case of corruption, the city would unwittingly be investing in it's poorest citizens at a deficit to itself. -(-1) is 1.
AsymetricCom··on Western Union: Bitcoin isn’t ready for international money transfer yet
If it'd been in his own bitcoin wallet, he would have never lost the $20k
AsymetricCom··on Western Union: Bitcoin isn’t ready for international money transfer yet
Users can't control their hardware, so they can't control their bits, coin or otherwise. Institutions cannot stomach the idea of a populous with powerful computers that don't answer to them. Trusted Devices being the only electronic devices in existence is one solution.
AsymetricCom··on Western Union: Bitcoin isn’t ready for international money transfer yet
With a price from 1981
AsymetricCom··on Mint sucks, so why aren't there any real competitors in that space?
I'm not sure how thousands of companies blazing their own trail is synonymous with stopping advancement.
AsymetricCom··on The Quest to Build a Truly Free Version of Android
I thought the entitlement was google's when they used open source development to build their closed tools and betatest their api/protocol.

Of course the entitlement is theres because they convinced OSS devs to write code for them for free under the "do no evil" moniker.

So now if they want to keep their toolchains, they have to continue maintaining the oss-side google service apps to regain access to the tools they help built.

I think this is called bait and switch, and it's probably the #1 pattern used by big technology firms today. It's so easy to "switch" with IT. Carrot-stick pattern worked well for Microsoft, because they owned the only stick and most the bait, but no longer. I guess without a monopoly, the only way to secure customers is to fool them.

AsymetricCom··on The Quest to Build a Truly Free Version of Android
That's not technically correct. Your work is modulated by the device. A device with less parts modulates it less. Less modulation of your actions means you have more direct control.
AsymetricCom··on The Quest to Build a Truly Free Version of Android
A standardized open android just means easier rooting by hardware. No, you don't want to write to that location, mr. software, how about I link you a dialog about violating your EULA instead?
AsymetricCom··on Mint sucks, so why aren't there any real competitors in that space?
The issue with banks like that is the complexity is lying outside their ability to enforce it, so they have to rely on government/law to enforce that complexity instead of software. Such banks move slowly. Are there any banks with open APIs? Yes, not many though, there probably aren't enough to start a network effect.

Just because some APIS are "hard" and exist outside of an electronic network, doesn't mean that they cannot be automated in software to some extent.

Makes me wonder if Obama is trying to automate the government and military so Laws and enforcement can be automated so inter-banking can be automated. Didn't follow our NDA and are using our API to lander cash? Automated drone missile at your IP interface.

AsymetricCom··on Mint sucks, so why aren't there any real competitors in that space?
I'm not really sure how charging for API access would break your ability to out-maneuver Mint. Technology moves faster than regulation so today regulation comes after power of technology. All a framework does is abstract way complexity, which makes the banks that fall under it subject to a more-pure market and its effects. Banks with premium services can compete on price while working on the same customer data easier. Access to extended data can be bidded on by banks for those willing to give up personal information for better services. I don't comprehend why the banks would need to "open up" anything, or even agree to standardize their API. The framework can be a sanity check on banks as well. (we deposited $100, only $95 is reported, flag., handle flag by docking bank "determinism ranking"), banks that don't rate highly as handling the framework calls in a deterministic manner are not officially supported and lose mainstream customers. Consumers can regain control of their personal information, bringing a new market for personal data that isn't owned by someone other than that person.
AsymetricCom··on Easy Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison
As in I give you this money and you make sure I can keep giving you money.
AsymetricCom··on Mint sucks, so why aren't there any real competitors in that space?
So in effect, by cornering the market and developing many layers of cruft internally to deal with the various APIS, they've effectively stopped technology advancement in the personal finance space. Meanwhile, quantum networks and computing is being rolled out to big institutional investors.

The only way for people to regain any semblance of control (and transparency) of their financial situation, there has to be an FOSS initiative to build these tools openly, and to keep them on a license that prevents huge financial institutions from coopting public commons software. The fact that Mint can't seem to tally a month is indicative of deeply failed architecture, probably governed by business instead of engineers. If that doesn't scare you, well, perhaps you are already in debt up to your eyeballs, and as they say, if I owe you $1,000 it's my problem, if I owe you $1,000,000 it's your problem.

There is NO WAY for a startup to tackle the problem and make meaningful advancements in any metric except maybe a nice zero-sum race with Mint. At least not that I can see. No one is going to fund a startup deving under GPL2 and no startup staying private with their technology will be able to out-compete Mint's headstart, because any advancement you have with the banks is Mint's for free. With a open technology is everyone's (including mints) and any advancement they make is also yours. You've effectively changed the game from managing information logistics/frameworks to customer support.

You are playing a high-level game when you write financial software for profit. The only way to win the game this old, is to not play inside its rules. FOSS. The quickest and most assured way to guarantee your failure would be to accept startup funds with any strings attached, because as soon as you do, you're now subject to the rules of the game.

AsymetricCom··on Easy Amazon EC2 Instance Comparison
Provisioned IOPS is just a method for other large corporations to donate to AWS without C-level approval.
AsymetricCom··on The BadBIOS Analysis is Wrong
Ah, I see. This isn't about a critically important worm, this is about who can be as vague to the point of being unverifiable as possible.
AsymetricCom··on Introducing ART – A new Android runtime being introduced experimentally in 4.4
I can't wait for someone else to invest effort in making this a stable and secure runtime!
AsymetricCom··on Don't use autofill in your browser
Seems to be an issue with Chrome only, which is unsurprising.
AsymetricCom··on Those Comics in Your Basement? Probably Worthless
Circular logic is what keeps this economy going (in circles, around the drain)
AsymetricCom··on "BadBIOS" features explained
#1 feature: being able to sway large portions of IT-sector opinion, with unsubstantiated fear and security threats, to be pro-internet regulation.
AsymetricCom··on Those Comics in Your Basement? Probably Worthless
and those figures are worthless
AsymetricCom··on The Zen Programmer
I think any career advice that isn't coming from the people who've hired is good advice.
AsymetricCom··on Those Comics in Your Basement? Probably Worthless
That 7-figure stock portfolio? worthless.
AsymetricCom··on Clone Dropbox with a Raspberry Pi and BTSync
On top of that (literally and figuratively) is Pi's ARM's TrustZone hypervisor..
AsymetricCom··on The Logic of “Stupid” Poor People
I love this headline. I'd also love to see one about Evil Rich People to get both sides of the coin.
AsymetricCom··on The Battle for Power on the Internet
It seems Schneier is saying less and less specific, fundamental issues and speaking more of abstract, high-level political and social concepts. He seems to have lost all power over his understanding of important breaking security issues and is left playing catch-up trying to understand what has already happened. My guess this is a result of the privatization/monitization/markets of zero-days, re-establishing control of technology by the classic economic systems, and taking it from engineers and experts.

That said, I don't think I'll bother reading anything else from Schneier's desk from this point forward. If he thinks that the "battle" is being fought on the edge of corporate networks, he's lost the trees for the forest. The real battle is happening for eyes and ears, on the streets, like it always has been. Less and less, some random person who happens to be the descendant of some king thinks the way the entire IT market needs to move so that "society" doesn't collapse, less and less is anyone listening to that person or believing he has any power. Real Time web of things or whatever you want to call it, nobody is buying it. If he thinks that people buying an iPod is signing allegiance to Apple's security forces, well he's wrong. If he thinks EULAs are going to be enforced in court, he's wrong. So considering those two flaws in the foundation of his world view, the rest of his rambling screed has been lost to the world of fiction.

AsymetricCom··on Java Virtual Machine in pure Node.js
Why all the hate but none of the conceptualization?
AsymetricCom··on Adobe hack: At least 38 million accounts breached
You won't leave Adobe because you refuse to learn an alternative tool chain. Talk heavy, maybe adobe will listen and forfeit some of the massive power they have over the internet and users.
AsymetricCom··on Bidding farewell to Hassle-Free PC
Apple dev team will take care of my PC hassles from now on.
← PreviousPage 6 of 21Next →