HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Attrecomet

309 karma · joined August 19, 2022

submissionscomments
Attrecomet··on Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems
A fitting reply to a total non-sequitur, more like. A huge corps handling of browser extensions has absolutely zero to do with encryption algorithms, and security is such a big field that "care about security" means nothing at all.

The comment was just a chance to vent anger at Google in an unproductive way.

Attrecomet··on 20 Years of "Not Even Wrong"
Taking criticism of string theory hogging all the budget as "it's literally taking over the entirety of physics budgets" instead of "in the field of fundamental high-energy physics, there's no budget left over for alternative ideas to be developed to a similarly detailed level" is strawmanning.
Attrecomet··on 20 Years of "Not Even Wrong"
I don't know if Woit explained it, but there are multiple attempts at explanation by other people who have been pointing out the self-serving nature of string theory publicity. Lee Smolin's "The Trouble With Physics" mentions access to funding and the absence of experimental pressure to divulge of unproductive theories: by dint of the hype in the 80s and 90s, many theoretical physics departments were staffed mainly with string theorists. This means that if you want to earn money doing theoretical physics, there are many people who won't complain too loudly if you choose string theory, and many people advising grants be written for string theory research. Other fundamental theories don't have this lobby, not because they are in any measurable way more wrong than string theory, but by historical happenstance and perhaps pure mathematical sexiness (as opposed to actual physical reasons). Usually, in a natural science, we can fall back on empirical data to correct such "intellectually nepotistic" networks that all humans are wont to fall into, but since the standard model is so frigging successful, this is missing.

But no matter the actual reason, I think anyone with a post-graduate science education can agree that it's a pretty big howler to call string theory an A+++ physical theory, when it so far hasn't predicted a single thing. That's a clear sign that the people talking are engaged in empty PR, not in informing the public in any meaningful way.

Attrecomet··on The Matrix Trashfire
The author tried the exactly one client that was available from element in the app store. Hard to fault him for that.
Attrecomet··on Technology holy wars are coordination problems (2020)
Not really OT, but what a beautifully formatted page. I especially love the convenient footnotes next to the text when on a wide screen, while being at the bottom for narrow windows.

This, however, is just hurtful, no need calling my tech stack irrelevant just because it's kinda true:

> People have ceased to debate Emacs vs vim not because any consensus was reached or either one disappeared, but because both are now niche editors which are more threatened by a common enemy—giants like Visual Studio Code or Eclipse or Sublime Text.

Attrecomet··on Was Atlantis a Minoan Civilization on Santorini Island?
>Oral tradition can be pretty good

That's very vague. Oral tradition was replaced by writing because writing is better, and the information content decays far slower. Do you have evidence of information transmitted orally across thousands of years? Best I know of is a few measly centuries, from the Iliad, where some passages obviously show knowledge of Late Bronze Age Mycenaean gear, but mixed up with later Archaic stuff.

>and it's not just the Black Sea that flooded, it's coastlines everywhere.

Which wasn't the specific claim here, which is "all flood myths go back to the Black Sea Deluge".

Attrecomet··on Was Atlantis a Minoan Civilization on Santorini Island?
My point wasn't that each flood has always been detrimental, but that there has never been a collection of people living in a place where there aren't also dangerous floods that kill people, so wild stories of floods destroying the world aren't really far out for the lived experience (perhaps across a few generations) of any human ever.

Edited for clarity

Attrecomet··on Was Atlantis a Minoan Civilization on Santorini Island?
> It seems that most early civilizations that developed on alluvial flood plains...

I'd go even further: there is no human habitat at all where floods are not dangerous catastrophes. The coast and alluvial plains trivially so, but mountains and deserts, too.

Attrecomet··on Was Atlantis a Minoan Civilization on Santorini Island?
That is a good question, and one where I had to do some self examination. I think it is because of the closeness of these claims to just-so stories, despite their posing as science ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-so_story ). That is, stories that fit empirical data to an explanation of it, without ever considering at any point if there is any reason to discard it, or if your hypothesis can even be disproved -- like the famous "not even wrong" quip by Wolfgang Pauli.

> I mean, to be honest I have no idea what's actually true, and I don't think anyone (including you) does either. So why be annoyed when people bring up a possibility, not disproven, just merely unlikely...

I'd like to point out that I'm not at all annoyed at people talking about the possibility in potentia. I disagree that it's a good possibility, but I am only annoyed when this is presented by professionals, most probably scientific journalists*, as something we should expect to be probable. This also extends (a bit unfairly, I guess) to amateurs repeating that claim as truth -- this is just bad pop science.

I do think, however, that the two quoted sentences above do at least imply a logical fallacy: of course we don't know the truth in this case. This does not make any kind of speculation an equally valid hypothesis to any other, there are distinctions, as per Russel's Teapot. And a claim as maximalist as "all the worlds flooding myths come from the Black Sea" better have some actual evidence to back it up, or be preceded with "In further publications, it might be interesting to look for evidence that ..." in the paper.

> As for how long oral traditions can survive without writing -- it's up to anyone's guess isn't it?

Similarly, the logical conclusion of that is not "there are stories that have been passed down from our common time in Africa 200k years ago, because who knows how far oral history can go" but rather "until there is actual evidence to the contrary, oral tradition remains suspect as a carrier of stories". We do know that correct details, at least, can be transported over centuries: the Iliad contains descriptions of soldiering that are, in part, clearly Late Bronze Age Mycenaean, though by the time it was written down the authors were unable to disentangle these tidbits from descriptions more fitting to the Archaic Age. That is the upper bound that I'm aware of: a few hundred years, information strongly mangled, but still recognizable if you know what to look for. How do you propose to go from there to an order of magnitude more? Of course, you might reply "you can't disprove it", to which my reply stays the same: then there is absolutely no reason to believe it true.

* I checked the original paper about the deluge, the authors didn't mention all of the worlds flooding myths at all in there. The wild speculation wisely appears in a book they published, which I do not have and which seems to propose a connection of all Indo-European and Egyptian myths. This is a far cry from "the Chinese are unable to think of a flooding myth themselves".

Update: a bit of searching around has mainly offered up thinly-disguised young earth creationist sites or sites clearly pointing out the problems as well as the allure of the "all flood myths are from the Black Sea Deluge" speculation. Maybe I should go softer on science journalism here...

Attrecomet··on Was Atlantis a Minoan Civilization on Santorini Island?
"Ancient people where to stupid to imagine measurements in a fictional account, therefore the presence of measurements is evidence of the story being factional" is a quite arrogant take, don't you think?
Attrecomet··on Was Atlantis a Minoan Civilization on Santorini Island?
I find it so wholly unconvincing that it annoys me whenever it is presented as anything more than quite idle speculation, even if by academics (not here in this particular comment chain, mind you).

It fails to convince me because it rests on two basic claims that I just cannot make myself believe: that humans are incapable of inventing grand, exaggerated stories, and that word of mouth, so inferior to writing for conveying information through the ages, somehow suddenly becomes a gold standard that can hold the kernel of a story true for a multiple of the time span of history.

Occam's Razor just screams that actually, every civilization across the world having their version of flood myths means that humans live in places where floods are important, life-defining catastrophes. this is true of every single habitat I'm aware of, up to and including deserts. It's "7000 (or whatever exactly) years of oral tradition before some Sumerian writes it down that captures anything useful" vs "Listen 'ere, grandchildren, did I tell you tykes the story of when I was your age, and my grandpappy put us all in boat with the sheep because of the flood? I couldn't see no land no more, so much water it was. Sigh, even the floods where better in my time, you don't know how good yer got it (repeat and aggrandize for three more generations)", and knowing humans, only one is instantly believable.

It also solves the annoying conundrum of Native Americans also having flood myths, despite the Black Sea flood happening definitely well after they lost contact with the Old World.

Attrecomet··on EBCDIC Is Incompatible with GDPR
The letters ß and ss are pronounced exactly the same, a hard 's' sound. Their effect on the preceding sounds is slightly different, though -- 'ss' makes the vowel short, 'ß' keeps it long. In all, a rather minute difference.
Attrecomet··on EBCDIC Is Incompatible with GDPR
German has an official and fully information preserving transcription to basic latin (which is really what all this talk about "anglo letters" is, just the basic latin letters in common use in the early modern era, with no diacritics at all), which can be used in official documents, too. Other languages, like latinized Turkish, obviously copied the diacritics, but seem to have left out the transcription rules, most probably because they borrowed the letters long after their history was relevant.
Attrecomet··on Debunking NIST's calculation of the Kyber-512 security level
How so? Or rather, taking change for a given, what are believable indicators that a secret organization outside normal systems of law and publicity has changed _for the better_? After all, the Snowden relevations lead not to the NSA deciding that creating a global panopticon for a super-surveillance state would be a bad idea, but rather them doing their damnedest that never again the American public would be informed of the true scale of their dystopian actions.
Attrecomet··on Eye comfort a priority for all-in-one desktop PC with color E Ink display
Easier said than done if your main source of light during the day is the sun through a window.
Attrecomet··on Why not punish families? A challenge for consequentialists
The heavyside-function is integrable and differentiable?
Attrecomet··on Why not punish families? A challenge for consequentialists
The correct function to minimize would be θ(-f(x))*(-f(x)), using the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heaviside_step_function
Attrecomet··on Why not punish families? A challenge for consequentialists
Isn't collective punishment in boot camp primarily used as a tool to increase the group cohesion of the trainees? In that case, it doesn't really fit into the other use cases, and must be argued against individually.

I'm not sure about the actual utility, but in abstract, it fits quite well to my impression of how humans, especially in small, "hunter-gatherer band sized", groups, work. And the military has a special need to create cohesion in its military that goes beyond what would be even vaguely acceptable in any liberal democracy for the general population. Especially in the special case of a criminal: which government would be stupid enough to increase the group cohesion of a dangerous criminal's family (including this criminal)?

Attrecomet··on Why not punish families? A challenge for consequentialists
Why would we put any weight to that promise in general? Or is the philosophical premise that humans never lie?
Attrecomet··on Death by a Thousand Microservices
Wait, that's still around?
Attrecomet··on Ask HN: I’m an FCC Commissioner proposing regulation of IoT security updates
Just as smart people agree that the manufacturer knows nothing about the situation at the appliance, and a forced update mechanism a la the first iteration of Windows forced updated ("update's here, restarting, too bad you're currently doing important stuff that won't be saved") is a stupid idea and outside of private use often a non-starter. That kind of condescension is generally only something you can do to private tech users.

Though I guess making the experience frustrating could keep more people from needlessly connecting everything to the network because it sound futuristic...

Attrecomet··on The low, low cost of committing cybercrime
Software engineers shouldn't be, and shouldn't want to be, licensed engineers. Being licensed a pain in the ass, a huge bureaucracy (have fun learning about thousands of ISO standards for trivial stuff for your license) and stifles innovation. We accept certain jobs requiring bureaucratic oversight because the effects of too low standards are unacceptable to us, but repeat with me, "licensing is a necessary evil, not a good in itself". It's ridiculous to demand that every library author or writer of a corporate website be licensed.
Attrecomet··on Hollywood movie aside, just how good a physicist was Oppenheimer?
That certainly sounds like bs. The pre-soviet famines' causes were directly the repressive, backward, exploitative and simply evil system that existed and forced the peasants to starve so the nobility and select bourgeois upper class members co-opted into the system could live lives of decadence.
Attrecomet··on Ability to see expertise is a milestone worth aiming for (2022)
This is beautiful, thank you

Edit: aww, ninja edit takes away all the fun :/

Attrecomet··on Using fluids to model inaccessible realms of the cosmos
This is literally just a string of buzzwords connected to form a grammatically correct sentence.
Attrecomet··on Kelly Rowland couldn't have used the =HYPERLINK() function to message Nelly
Corporations are "training" their people in MS products by showing them how to save and open documents. A half day of being shown that gives you some useless certificate or other that is often even required you hold (by corp rules). This is for people who actually work with these programs, and I assure you there are employees who need this information.

Of course billions of people who never have to use spreadsheets professionally will not realize what you can or cannot do with them. Or even recognize them if shown a few cells. Just because literally every one memeing on the internet cannot imagine a life without computers and beginners' knowledge about the common tools doesn't mean such knowledge is actually a common baseline in humans.

And honestly, what kind of fucked up wish is it for people to suffer Excel if they don't need to?

Attrecomet··on Blocked from Amazon Alexa for a week after racism accusation by delivery driver
Well, Amazon did try to lock him out of his smart home, and there is zero evidence that they would have cared had that meant him being homeless for a week. It just happens that he luckily was technically competent enough to have a flexible setup and know what to do with it.
Attrecomet··on UCLA computer grad constructs “crown jewel of cryptography”
That's true for a recipe that was developed in a past millennium. Trade secrets are still very much relevant for companies that work with more modern technologies than soda from before the Great War, and a useful protection against competition. Even if you do believe that companies within the US or EU wouldn't touch other's IP with a 10 foot pole due to strong laws, you'd have to be very naive to think this is valid in all parts of the globe.

Edit: it's also trivially not true for trade secrets in the legal sense -- if you upload your trade secret willingly to AWS, it's no longer a trade secret, unless you have extra contracts in place. With obfuscation, you could skip a lot of red tape to keep it secret.

Attrecomet··on UCLA computer grad constructs “crown jewel of cryptography”
> You should require positive proof that code does what you want.

That's just saying you should only ever solve simple problems with your computer.

Attrecomet··on Meta fined $1.3B over data transfers to U.S.
No. For one, even taken literally the way I wrote it it's about two different sets of people -- the EU must defend their citizens (and residents, BTW), of course!

For another, if one looks past my vague wording, the EU (or at least Germany, which I'm most familiar with) doesn't have the dogma that it's required to set up a world spanning total surveillance state, no compromises beyond the ones absolutely necessary with their own constitution (and even those are followed within a rather "liberal" framework for the three-letter-agencies: they do have all possible data they can get their hands on, just pinky-promise to not abuse it, if US citizens are impacted, in the eyes of secret courts).

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →