HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Attrecomet

309 karma · joined August 19, 2022

submissionscomments
Attrecomet··on Black holes might be defects in spacetime
Interesting. During my time in solid state physics and later quantum information, we just used "(topological) defects", not "topological solitons", though of course papers trying to sound cool could use that term. It takes about 2 uses to not conflate "defect" with anything deleterious, just the breaking of an otherwise functional symmetry.
Attrecomet··on Meta fined $1.3B over data transfers to U.S.
US laws and executive orders are the actual anti-internet culprits here. Until the US recognizes that non-citizens also have rights, and they can't just do whatever with them, the EU MUST fight for their own citizens' rights. Anything else would be a rank betrayal.
Attrecomet··on Meta fined $1.3B over data transfers to U.S.
Lets hope not, given that the stances are

US: "we demand the right to spy on anyone for any reason, except US citizens where we absolutely must recognize their constitutional rights"

EU: "we demand basic protections for the rights of our citizens"

Attrecomet··on Fake research papers are alarmingly common
I'm especially angry about the insinuation that the problem is false research not from pure research institutions. As if there isn't a huge pressure of publishing as much as possible especially at these institutions. It's the places where researchers under pressure can hide behind these stupid assumptions that will be the actual problem, not a few randos undertaking the work of publishing without a .edu email.
Attrecomet··on The EU's new Cyber Resilience Act is about to tell us how to code
European law is a lot less precedence driven that common law (though it still is a bit), so why shouldn't we demand clear rules instead of dangerous vagueness?

And for a small open source project, a 500€ fine is enough to make development and publication unattractive, a percentage of a devs yearly income is painful, and tens of thousands of Euros would be dangerous to the long-term financial well-being of the developers. Even if the fines are a lot lower than 15M€, this proposal stays shit as written.

Attrecomet··on The EU's new Cyber Resilience Act is about to tell us how to code
The carve-out of FOSS is rather weak. Anything that involves money can be a commercial activity. And suddenly some haskell core dev is on the hook because there are companies using it in prod. We can hope that it won't end that way, but there's nothing in the text suggesting that this should not happen.
Attrecomet··on The EU's new Cyber Resilience Act is about to tell us how to code
>Overall I don't think EU will go after smaller projects, since that would hurt the economy in an undesirable way. I think it's more likely that they'll use this to go after bigger corporations since that's an actual security risks for member states

That is a very rose-tinted view of EU regulators. Europeans are people like everywhere else on the planet, we're not somehow immune to regulatory capture (though I feel it might help the institutions that we haven't yet powerful blocs like the GOP that set out to destroy any kind of regulation in order to prove it's infeasible). Heck, German industry giants are practically married to the state here, there's absolutely no fucking way a company like VW or Opel will go under if a rich government like Germany can do anything about it.

More to the point, the author themself is pro-CRA for a range of things that seem to have purely positive effects, as they spell out quite clearly in the article. The points brought up are nevertheless important: we shouldn't be okay with legislator making objectively shitty laws devoid of any technical comprehension or economical realism and hope it'll kinda be fine when the bureaucracy and courts actually implement it. Just having the danger of having to pay 15M€ for my open source project because it might be used commercially is a horrendous imposition.

Attrecomet··on The EU's new Cyber Resilience Act is about to tell us how to code
First we're all akin to lawyers and doctors, now each software developer is effectively working to build an airplane...

Everyone here seems to forget that we regulate these industries so finely because they are in a uniquely dangerous position to harm people, and act as if this is a blanket statement that's true for any kind of software development. This is most definitely not true, and we should think hard and long before regulating a thriving industry out of the world in order to feel superior to all those rubes over there obviously doing it wrong.

Regulation is a necessary evil, not a positive good in itself.

Attrecomet··on The EU's new Cyber Resilience Act is about to tell us how to code
All the extra red tape and auditing doesn't come for free, so startups and SMEs without huge amounts of cash somehow lying around will struggle.

Also, nothing about compliance is actually about "consolidating security debt" or "quick decisions". It's about paying someone to go through checklists and, like a reviewer of a scientific paper, find something, anything, no matter how inane, to criticize, before handing you a certification. Any slightly unconventional new idea to improve security in your product will be suffocated beneath the blanket of compliance.

> I'm totally rooting for this because its the only thing that will improve security.

So does the author. Well, they strongly endorse a sensible version without the vague phrases and open-source-killing blanket statements, and without brain-dead sentences like "your product must be un-DDoS-able". I do wonder, though, why you're rooting for legislation that would kill any open source project that might, conceivably, be used in a commercial setting?

Attrecomet··on The AI Bubble of 2023
I especially like the entirely random factor of two thrown in there -- everybody will get two accounts because why?
Attrecomet··on Why big tech companies need so many people
Hey now, you want them to sell us off cheaply? My life is worth more than a discount bargain on the dataset!
Attrecomet··on Why Finland Selected the F-35A (2021)
>Yet we keep flying it in the face of repeated attempts to retire it, with the USAF even going on the record that the A-10 will be kept in inventory "indefinitely"[1]. The A-10 is clearly not obsolete and continues to proudly serve the USA and its friends and allies, and enjoys much adoration from its pilots, mechanics, infantrymen, and civilian fans.

Because the US has, in the past decades, not waged a war against a near-equal opponent who could have held together any kind of air force or air defenses for at most the first few days of a US invasion. In all of the US wars since the A-10 might have been obsolete against a near-equal opponent, it was more advanced than the mass of opposing tech, and could be used well. For counterinsurgency, the cost of actually modern tech is more of a problem, given that the cheap old stuff is still far superior to anything a Taliban commander can put in the field, and given that guerilla warfare has as it's aim not tactical victories, but increasing the cost to the bigger party into politically untenable regions.

It is very much obsolete in the sense that the US also requires air capabilities for large, near-equal conflicts, and there is no unsurprising way for A-10s to be useful there. In summary: keep enough A-10s around for CAS against outclassed opponents, but don't plan on having enough to take on China, seems like a wise strategy.

Attrecomet··on I've procrastinated working on my thesis for more than a year
I cannot recommend this enough, it's what got me over the finish line after waaay too long, including a year with zero progress writing my thesis, just like the article describes.

Each day, it went the same: sit down, try to write about the work, find some meta problem to occupy myself (like "is this the correct order of topics that I'm planning to write in my outline" or "under which topic does this idea belong") before actually writing about the thing itself, cue an unproductive spiral of research into these distractions. After a couple of hours of not actually doing any progress, drift off into the internet "as a break", and only come back to the thesis for 20-30 minute intervals that are exactly as useless as they sound. Become more and more frustrated, but no more productive, as time goes on.

Vomit drafting suddenly gave me a productive focus. Suddenly it was clear that yes, where I want to put this topic is good enough, or there is this one other place where it makes a lot more sense. No more long internal debates over meta-questions. And I realized that yes, I do have a wide range of knowledge about my specialty, something I'm convinced I was subconsciously blocking on before ("what do I do if I try to write about this topic but realize I'm just too stupid to get it, and was just bluffing all the time?").

Attrecomet··on Plant-based meat is turning out to be a flop
Except, despite all the hate because it's not "unprocessed" (a stupid categorization), it does REDUCE: No more need to stuff a meat machine with plant based products for a 10% or worse ROI. BAM. REDUCTION.
Attrecomet··on Plant-based meat is turning out to be a flop
Good news! We're on our way to do both, scale down the population AND the standard of living!
Attrecomet··on Plant-based meat is turning out to be a flop
> All cows

Entirely untrue.

Attrecomet··on Papers and patents are becoming less disruptive over time
Sorry, bad phrasing on my part. I didn't mean that peer reviewing doesn't lead to gatekeeping, but that simply making something peer reviewed isn't enough, because ludicrously bad attempts at science can be peer reviewed.

Peer review is also obviously a bad solution for the reproducibility problem, given that we've got the problem now, concurrent with generations of peer reviewed manuscripts.

Attrecomet··on Papers and patents are becoming less disruptive over time
It's doing a rather bad job at filtering out obvious flaws, given the reproducibility crisis we've got on our hands. Everyone says peer review is very important, but when it comes to reviewers putting in the hard and boring work of actually checking the raw data, almost none do, so in truth, peer review is NOT important to most scientists.

And we nevertheless pay the price of adhering closer to orthodoxy for it, since effort being put in is a rather superficial "this paper sounds reasonable to me" filter, perhaps with some boxes that must be checked like p-value or sample size.

Attrecomet··on Papers and patents are becoming less disruptive over time
Fun fact: peer review isn't gatekept. There are peer reviewed young earth creationist articles out there: https://www.cnet.com/culture/creationists-launch-peer-review...

So "peer review" isn't holding back kook theories at all on its own. At best, journal prestige is bolstered by it, which the journal can then translate into holding them back. The track record is a bit unclear, though.

Attrecomet··on Papers and patents are becoming less disruptive over time
https://theconversation.com/hate-the-peer-review-process-ein...

This article mentions Einstein being offended that his paper was submitted to peer review by Physical Review, and submitting it elsewhere instead:

"We (Mr. Rosen and I) had sent you our manuscript for publication and had not authorised you to show it to specialists before it is printed. I see no reason to address the – in any case erroneous – comments of your anonymous expert. On the basis of this incident I prefer to publish the paper elsewhere."

I just recently ended up there via this blog: https://experimentalhistory.substack.com/p/the-rise-and-fall...

which argues, not unconvincingly IMO, that peer review is a failed experiment which tries to stop bad science at the price of also stopping brilliant, unconventional science, where instead we would profit more from letting the scientific public do the sorting instead of hand-picked specialists. The author phrases it as science being as strong as its strongest links, not as weak as the weakest one, and we should do everything to get the brilliant crazy ideas.

Attrecomet··on Python 2 removed from Debian
And modern C++ is still being held back for deathly fear of breaking ABI despite clear improvements it makes impossible. People here seem to underestimate the cost of keeping backwards compatibility forever -- either you change very, very slowly (C) or your change is a clusterfuck of disparate requirements that keep blocking each other (C++).

Of course, "We want this code to run forever the way it is" is a value option that a company can choose - just not with any language it wants. And somehow, people seem a bit reluctant to switch from Python to C to be able to keep running the same programs forever, guaranteed.

Attrecomet··on Python 2 removed from Debian
The bad thing about significant whitespace is it breaks copy-pasteability of code, with no way to get broken formatting back without understanding what the code does.

That is a lot worse than formatting squabbles, especially for a glue language where you are expected to be able to copy snippets for short scripts all the time.

Attrecomet··on Musk’s Twitter Buy Makes No Sense – Unless It’s Part of Something Bigger
Satellite mounted weapons systems that can block ballistic missiles, i.e. reach at least into the upper atmosphere, but can't ever be used offensively? That seems like a tall order.

In addition, anything making MAD impossible will have very, very far reaching consequences for world politics, many of which are offensive. Any state that can unilaterally deploy nukes without fear of reprisal is on it's way to the total global tyranny you mention.

Attrecomet··on Musk’s Twitter Buy Makes No Sense – Unless It’s Part of Something Bigger
Military technology is subject to very real, very dangerous prisoners' dilemmas. In a way it doesn't matter if one side is starting it or not, the real question is if it can be ruled out that either one of the sides could be doing it.

And it's shit, because unilaterally declaring you're not gonna do it won't work at all, so there needs to be enough trust between the parties to institute a supervision regime, otherwise, if something is technological possible and promises military benefits, it will be done sooner rather than later.

Attrecomet··on Nokia and Airbus elected as judges at the UPC, an unheard corruption of Justice
It's corruption, pure and simple. "Not optimal" and then giving an excuse is a pretty sad reaction to (government sanctioned!) private justice by corporations as a weapon against any smaller competitor.
Attrecomet··on Being Ridiculed for My Open Source Project (2013)
You can also, like an adult, confront the other party with what they did and, as in this case, get them to reflect on their words and retract them, making your environment a little bit better in the process. You all are just hating on her because she admitted to having emotions, an adolescent take on the situation if anything.
Attrecomet··on I strive to be a 0.1x Engineer (2016)
Might as well try to keep score in Calvinball
Attrecomet··on I strive to be a 0.1x Engineer (2016)
"If a decision is made not to automate something, someone is going to have to do that boring repetitive work that could have been automated."

You did read the little sentences under the big bullet points, right? It's "first, let's see if it's smarter to not do the work at all, before we commit to automating", not "don't automate the boring stuff"

Attrecomet··on I strive to be a 0.1x Engineer (2016)
"Before we automate it, we should think about if we can avoid doing the task altogether" is a red flag to you?
Attrecomet··on Being Ridiculed for My Open Source Project (2013)
That's not at all what happened here. Criticism implies that there were any useful hints on what exactly is bad or should be done differently, instead of vague ridicule and insults. And BTW, excusing asshole behavior like that is not a good thing to do.

She actually tweeted back both of them asking for details, a level of understanding neither tweet actually merited (but still a good strategy), and got no answer.

There, now you won't even need to read TFA :)

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →