HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Bakkot

275 karma · joined July 20, 2011

Not really here anymore.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/bakkot; my proof: https://keybase.io/bakkot/sigs/sX5pEib_QojhhLoU5OS9fpJaxDq_gvgNcXTq9HO626Q ]

submissionscomments
Bakkot··on How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers
On any other problem whatsoever, people would readily grant that having the developers understand the problem domain confers an advantage. I don't see why this should be any different.
Bakkot··on Google Glass
I'm 20 and can never recall having had the experience the OP describes.
Bakkot··on Basic quantum computing concepts implemented in Python
Hasn't SymPy done this for a while?

http://docs.sympy.org/0.7.2-py3k/modules/physics/quantum/ind...

Bakkot··on Cory Doctorow: RIP, Aaron Swartz
Also http://lesswrong.com/user/aaronsw/overview/
Bakkot··on L-systems In Minecraft
I was hoping this would be from in-game mechanics. Just drawing isn't that impressive.
Bakkot··on Mass Shootings, Political Correctness, and Magical Thinking
... I'm sorry, how levying taxes against the Constitution?
Bakkot··on Why 256 bit keys are large enough
Quantum computers have a fairly well-studied mathematical abstraction about which we can reason quite well. Algorithms for quantum computers exist which will break RSA; no similar algorithms exist to break AES.

And the link actually only applies to traditional computers; quantum computers have no analogue of destructively setting a bit, because all operations on a quantum computer are fundamentally reversible, and hence do not entail any inherent energy loss to entropy.

Bakkot··on The Quiet Wikideath of BBS History
Prefacing this, I'm largely with Jason Scott on this (and most issues). That said:

The deletionist argument is not and has never been been that it's going to save storage or bandwidth. (Generally, it's about it being difficult to keep up the average quality of the encyclopedia when there's a lot of less notable stuff. Which is absolutely true.) You should at least try to understand the argument for the opposition before you make up your mind.

Policy debates should not appear one sided, etc, etc.

Bakkot··on Killed by Homeopathy
The thing to ask yourself in these situations:

Which is more likely - coincidence, or that all of science is wrong? Because make no mistake, nothing less is required for exorcism or homeopathy or astrology to work.

Hint: It's the first one.

Or, to quote Minchin: 'You know what they call alternative medicine that's been proved to work? Medicine.'

Bakkot··on MySQL Local/Remote Account Password Cracking
Easy enough to make it return instantly when switching to the current user. This would still allow for someone to crack their own password (a problem if someone has access to the database without having the password, say by an SQL injection), but would mitigate most of the problem without breaking things for almost anyone.
Bakkot··on Inside Google Spanner, the Largest Single Database on Earth
View all pages: http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2012/11/google-spanner-...

Also: > “We can commit data at two different locations — say the West Coast [of the United States] and Europe — and still have some agreed upon ordering between them,” Fikes says, “So, if the West Coast write happens first and then the one in Europe happens, the whole system knows that — and there’s no possibility of then being viewed in a different order.”

That's a large enough scale that you have to deal with relativity (light takes almost precisely 0.03 seconds to go from Palo Alto to Paris, eg). So in some sense there is no correct ordering. Anyone know how they deal with this? Have they just chosen some arbitrary point to make their reference frame, for purposes of ordering commits?

Bakkot··on Stripe Would Be Perfect If...
It seems to me that creating several dozen subscription plans on Stripe is indicative of a deeper problem: that you have several dozen different prices consumers end up paying. How about instead you advertise the prices that consumers will actually have to pay? Bump up all of your prices across the board by the expected cost of taxes to even out the cost.

(Unless there's some law about not charging consumers in different provinces a different pre-tax cost, or some province charges so much tax that to make other provinces eat a share of that cost would be unreasonable.)

Bakkot··on How to Crack the Toughest Coding Interviews
I assumed it was intentionally ambiguous (like a lot of problem statements in practice), to see how the interviewees respond. There are a few interesting interpretations, some of which are obviously exponential time, infinite time, or impossible (ie uncountably many solutions).
Bakkot··on Google Drive desktop client requests login credentials only once
Of course it can. Google can obfuscate it if they like (presumably quite well, being Google), but ultimately it's just data on the machine. Malware has just as ready access to that as everything else.
Bakkot··on Outlawed by Amazon DRM
Which is why I donate to the EFF.
Bakkot··on Show HN: GBA.js, a Game Boy Advance emulator written in JavaScript
You should let Jason Scott know about this. He's been pushing a similar project for MAME. http://ascii.textfiles.com/archives/3685
Bakkot··on Why is processing a sorted array faster than an unsorted array?
Several months old, but still worth a read - especially for the end of Mystical's comment, where he discusses the different optimizations performed by different compilers. Particularly interesting is the Intel Compiler, which effectively optimizes out the benchmark itself: something to keep in mind when testing your own code, if you want your results to make sense.
Bakkot··on Humble eBook Bundle
I find it interesting that they still provide payment breakdowns by platform... and that Linux and Mac OS are still so much higher than Windows.

When those two were paying for games it was obvious why that should be, since games on Linux are so comparatively scare, but it doesn't make so much sense with eBooks.

Bakkot··on Factorization diagrams in Haskell
> Of course, this really only works well for numbers with prime factors drawn from the set {2, 3, 5, 7}.

So express the number as a sum of numbers with factors drawn from that set, and draw a several diagrams, one for each summand. A quick bit of Python confirms that every number under 14925 can be expressed as the sum of no more than three such numbers in the most obvious way possible (ie using a greedy algorithm).

For example, you might write 9999 as 9800 + 196 + 3, all of which have nice factorization diagrams.

Bakkot··on The CIA and Jeff Bezos Bet on Quantum Computing
Those approaches are increasingly well-studied and a lot of them (Grover's algorithm, anyone?) look an awful lot like magic.

(For people who don't want to look that up, Grover's algorithm does searches on unsorted databases in root-n time, that is, in fewer operations than would be required to inspect every element of the database.)

Bakkot··on How We Doubled Our Android Install Rate in One Hour
I'm not sure, honestly: I imagine the differential of a new design varies depending on how users come across it. If when not being featured Dwellable mostly gets new installs from word-of-mouth, say, I bet that the new design doesn't have as much impact. (I'm sure it would still be a big difference, but maybe on the order of 1.5x instead of 2x, say.)
Bakkot··on Markets are efficient if and only if P = NP
Of course this doesn't mean markets aren't within some small constant factor of being perfectly efficient.
Bakkot··on Google Drive SDK
It likely didn't exist yet. These things take time.
Bakkot··on Google says no plans for iOS 6 mapping app "yet"
The context on the 'maybe you shouldn't be doing it' quote is that Google is not going to disobey court orders to protect your privacy. It was never Google's responsibility. Please let's move on from this particular dead horse.
Bakkot··on The Last PC Laptop
The basic premise of your post is that people only use technology to do work. To put it lightly, this has not been my experience.
Bakkot··on Kickstarter vaporware of the day, Lifx edition
They could, but honestly they should just be more insistent that project founders make more use of the existing tools. They provide a way to say there's a limited number of awards available at a given tier; if you're not going to be able to scale past ten thousand quickly, then don't let more than ten thousand people sign up to receive the product - at least not from the first round.
Bakkot··on Does infinity exist?
Infinity is not a number.

There is no room 'n+infinity'. There's just not such a room, anywhere, even in principle. Each guest n can move to room n+1 because the guest there is moving to n+2. This works. That's the point.

And you couldn't, in fact, tell the guests to run down the hallway to find an empty room: There is no empty room until you move everyone.

Infinity is counterintuitive, you say? Well, yes, that's the point of this illustration.

Bakkot··on Does infinity exist?
> A strong AI can certainly do this.

A strong AI can say something different than the thing it's about to say? That's a neat trick. Not a part of any definition of strong AI I've ever heard, though. Could a human do it?

Bakkot··on OSX password script for everyone to know
No, last week's was root only, operated by searching through RAM for various keys, and was notable for displaying passwords for every logged-in user, which this will not do.
Bakkot··on Whoa, dude, are we in a computer right now? NASA scientist thinks we could be.
> I believe your idea of consciousness is that it is an emergent phenomenon that arises from simpler processes, much like how biology arises from the simple laws of QM. Is this correct?

I wouldn't call that a definition. Here's a working one: my consciousness is the part of me which thinks and feels, which enjoys music and mountains and friends and so forth. Computers as of now can take input, but can't experience input the way I do; the gap is what I call consciousness. (To this definition your above description does apply.)

> "Do you think that this means your consciousness has nothing to do with your claim to be conscious?" Yes, that is exactly what I think. Although replace "consciousness" with "the act of experiencing existence" and that is a much closer semantic match to what I am attempting to convey.

This is the bit I'm having trouble with. For me, I experience things, and then state that I experience things. The relationship is direct and causal. From what I understand you experience things and then state that you experience things, and these facts are completely unrelated? I'm pretty sure Occam had something to say about that.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →