HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Bakkot

275 karma · joined July 20, 2011

Not really here anymore.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/bakkot; my proof: https://keybase.io/bakkot/sigs/sX5pEib_QojhhLoU5OS9fpJaxDq_gvgNcXTq9HO626Q ]

submissionscomments
Bakkot··on Whoa, dude, are we in a computer right now? NASA scientist thinks we could be.
Yup. But this certainly isn't unique to consciousness: In theory the axioms of Turing machines can prove that our best-candidate BusyBeaver(6) runs for around 10^36534 steps, but that doesn't provide an explanatory ontology. But you don't need to invoke magic for the theory to be true.
Bakkot··on Whoa, dude, are we in a computer right now? NASA scientist thinks we could be.
You've conflated a couple of things here, and I think my position must have been a little poorly stated as well. Here's some points, in roughly ascending order of important. (Anyone reading this: skip to the bottom if you're not going to read it all.)

First: 'Science' does not embody the whole of human knowledge, not at all. That's not even what it's for. It is a true thing that 1+1=2 (with standard definitions, Peano arithmetic, etc), but science has nothing to say on this matter.

Second: The fact that other people talk about this fruit they see, and you yourself have this fruit that you see, is very strong evidence that people have fruits, even if, with our current understanding, we can't verify it from physics.

Third: I do believe consciousness exists. I think (in fact it seems self-apparent to me) that consciousness is a property of processes or algorithms. Can I explain how exactly it arises? No, but then for virtually all of human history we had no idea how, say, biology or magnets or fire could come out of physics either.

Fourth: Just because a process has some property doesn't mean we'll ever understand it in a satisfying way - even very simple processes (care to explain how the current best-candidate for BusyBeaver(6) works?) This is not the same as that property not existing.

Finally: This was in my original post as well, was in fact the entire point of said post, and I can't seem to find a response in your post. If you accept (as is a part of the p-zombie postulation) that the reasons you say things like 'I am conscious' are entirely because of physics, do you think that this means your consciousness has nothing to do with your claim to be conscious? That seems absurd to me, and to me it seems that the conclusion must be, given the above, that consciousness does in fact fall out of physics.

For clarity, here's that final argument spelled out again.

1. My claim to be conscious does have to do with the fact of my consciousness. (Agree?)

2. My claim to be conscious is completely determined by physics, since I would also make it in p-zombie world (that is, the world which is by hypothesis completely determined by physics). (Agree?)

3. Therefore, the fact of my consciousness must fall out of physics. (Agree?)

Or in set-theoretic terms, because that's how I think:

fact-of-consciousness \subset reasons-for-claim-to-be-conscious \subset physics implies fact-of-consciousness \subset physics.

Do you disagree?

Bakkot··on Hacker holds alleged Romney tax returns ransom for $1M in Bitcoins
You think? I'm pretty sure they already have sufficient motivation to shutdown Silk Road, which for laundering purposes is essentially a bank. By what mechanism do you propose they raid Silk Road's records, assuming such even exist?
Bakkot··on Whoa, dude, are we in a computer right now? NASA scientist thinks we could be.
I'm sorry, you believe the physics of this universe could be simulated but still accept that the p-zombie argument is valid? So in p-zombie land, there's an Xcelerate making claims about being conscious for exactly the same reasons you are (ie physics), but only you are actually correct? Moreover, you're correct entirely by accident, because your reasons for making your claim to consciousness (ie physics) have nothing to do with the actual fact of your consciousness? I just can't take that seriously.
Bakkot··on Hacker holds alleged Romney tax returns ransom for $1M in Bitcoins
Wouldn't 'laundering' look exactly like 'sending the BTC to any of the dozens of services which store BTC for you in a centralized account, (SR, instawallet, etc) and then withdrawing that same amount? This produces bitcoins not visibly linked to the originals - it's exactly like depositing and then withdrawing money from a bank (a bank which doesn't make a record of people's identity).
Bakkot··on How to Write a Malcolm Gladwell Book
Zach Weiner might not be 'spectacularly' successful, but he's not exactly doing poorly for himself. Most recently: http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/999790007/trial-of-the-c...

In any case, I think you missed the thrust of the post, ie, that the content is formulaic (and bad), not that the writing isn't compelling.

Bakkot··on Hacker Opens High Security Handcuffs With 3D-Printed And Laser-Cut Keys
Re "download a handgun", that debate is already happening:

http://boingboing.net/2011/09/20/3d-printed-ar-15-parts-chal...

Bakkot··on 'Unprecedented' discovery could propel quantum computers to reality
Not sure if you meant to imply the brain is an inherently quantum system or not, but if so:

> Theoretically then systems of the brain/mind should be able to be duplicated.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-cloning_theorem

It's actually theoretically impossible.

Bakkot··on Tumblr. "Full Disclosure" or Why I Hate Reporting
Great catch as always. I wish you'd included a tag so we could see how your post is spreading.
Bakkot··on Facebook’s 1st-Quarter Profit Falls 12%
> Any email provider also has your social graph.

They really don't. Not the way Facebook does; not for the post-Millennials. People email bosses and professors and acquaintances; they use Facebook for friends.

Bakkot··on Show HN: A Way To Hack HN's Karma
CSRF couldn't stop this particular attack, since it's not actually cross-site. You need to guard against both.
Bakkot··on As more hackers start to die, when do we finally do something about it?
True, outlive-the-heat-death-of-the-universe immortality would be a curse. For people who are happy, living indefinitely would not.
← PreviousPage 3 of 3