HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

BeniBoy

809 karma · joined April 22, 2016

submissionscomments
BeniBoy··on System76 Launch Configurable Keyboard with Open Source Code
I am the only one that is very ill-at-ease with that PCB [1]? The routing seems.. off? No straight trace, irregular component placement. Its the kind of work where seemingly "superficial" concern like that are in fact quite usefull, a clean PCB makes it easier to find issues and do repairs.

[1]:https://github.com/system76/launch/blob/master/pcb/launch-pc...

BeniBoy··on French watchdog fines Google, Amazon for breaching cookies rules
It's called ePrivacy. Necessary trackers are excluded from consent. This is a directive so each country will have its specific interpretation, for the french one, you can go to the CNIL's website. The final document is not translated, but you can read the draft[1], specifically the 9th paragraph.

[1] https://www.cnil.fr/sites/default/files/atoms/files/draft_re...

BeniBoy··on French watchdog fines Google, Amazon for breaching cookies rules
The reason France could act on his own is that ePrivacy is not subject to the one-stop shop mechanisme. Each country can choose to act independantly. They are not saying that Ireland is not relevant for GDPR-related issues.
BeniBoy··on French watchdog fines Google, Amazon for breaching cookies rules
You should probably get familiar with the actual regulation before writing such a critical comment.

Of course it takes into account the finality of the cookie (or any tracker for that matter).

BeniBoy··on A woman who is allergic to water (2016)
You could just put the image in the relevant meta tag, there is no need to actually display it in the article.
BeniBoy··on Ask HN: What can replace my iPod for podcast listening?
I love my Walkman NW-A55. Good DAC, solid bluetooth and long battery life. Two things that sucks:

* The proprietary cable. Seriously, in 2020..

* It does not support album cover in JPEG 2000. Seems like a detail, but if you like your library well organised, it can be a time sink !

BeniBoy··on I am seriously considering going back to desktop computers
If you are on Windows, some USB-C hub allow to have two external display (and not mirror ones, for three different display). Not compatible with OSX though.
BeniBoy··on My chatbot is dead – Why yours should probably be too
That reminded me of this experiment [1]. Augment your CTR with simulated mouse cursor /s. But yes, the home page is unusable for me too..

[1]: https://javier.xyz/control-user-cursor/

BeniBoy··on After simple dental surgery, a man lost his ability to form new memories
I'd say those are some scultping tools.. Like those [1]

[1]: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1827273916.html

BeniBoy··on Only 9% of visitors give GDPR consent to be tracked
Yeah, no. This about the ePrivacy directive, if you don't have proper consent, you can't read/write tracers regardless of wether this is personnal data or not, except for tracers needed to establish the communication or demanded by the user (carts, login, etc).

EDIT: Thought about it, and if you only record the button click and does not identify the user, it works, and I am wrong! In general ePrivacy is very restrictive, only about access to terminal and not about personnal data ( and btw PII is not a GDPR thing, we say personnal data), but here it's ok! So yeah, no to me!

BeniBoy··on Brave Browser, wiping history still leaves trace of visited sites
I've met Johny Ryan and he seems like an honest and privacy-focused guy. He seems to really care about his work.

I must admit that does not quite fit with a lot of the thing I've read about Brave over the years.

BeniBoy··on Carving out a niche as a small artist on Spotify
Am I the only one that received an email from Google telling me that Google Play music was going to close soon and that I should transfer my playlists?
BeniBoy··on GDPR guide for developers
It's a good question and I don't thing any DPA has said anything specifically on this issue. But if your logs contains personnal data related to the user which made the deletion request, you might be in trouble. And personnal data has a very broad definition.

But honestly this is a very minor point, if that's what is keeping you up at night, you are amongst the most compliant ones !

BeniBoy··on GDPR guide for developers
This is a bit saddening to read your take on this guide.

The goal is specifically to make the GDPR less daunting and more accessible! I guess it missed the mark.

But yeah, the GDPR has to formalize a lot of common sense practices, if you don't consider your user as "data trove" you want to abuse, you will be mostly ok!

BeniBoy··on GDPR guide for developers
You are right. The rights of the user depend on the legal basis you choose.

This is covered here[1]

Basically:

* The right to object is not applicable if your processing is based on contract, legal obligation or protection of vital interest

* The right to erasure is not applicable in case of a legal obligation or public interest

[1]https://github.com/LINCnil/GDPR-Developer-Guide/blob/master/...

BeniBoy··on GDPR guide for developers
I think the "Prepare for the exercise of people’s rights" part is critical.

If you are a software architect, you need to ask yourself: can I delete a single user data across all my infra easily? If not, you might be in trouble a couple a year later when you are hit with thousands of deletion request and technically can't honor them.

Another side of tech debt I guess!

BeniBoy··on Ask HN: What's your quarantine side project?
Non tech-related, but I have been building a touring bicycle. Very satisfying to get to learn the standards, choose the parts, assemble. Even builded my own wheels! And now I am fixing my friends bike with the tools I have accumulated.

Getting a little off the computer was nice, plus this summer local bike touring will propably be the only option. Can't wait!

BeniBoy··on No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU data protection body
Nope, the law allows cookie that are necessary for a functionnality that allows the communication or is asked by the user.

For exemple, as I said in another post, is explicitely allowed:

* Cookies for login/session

* Cookies for shopping carts

* Cookies for interface personnalisation (language, etc.)

* Cookies for load balancing

* Cookies to retain user choice regarding cookies

And quite a few other. So really you can run your website without consent notice if you care enough. One grey area is analytics, it varies amongst european DPAs. That I know of:

* In France it is allowed if you respect a few rules (no cross-processing, no localisation, etc..)

* In the UK, it is not per say allowed, but the ICO said they would not prosecute on those grounds.

BeniBoy··on No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU data protection body
No it's not.

I can't talk for other countries, but for France, the local DPA explicitely said so[0]!

Loose translation: "The analytics tool do not fit within the consent exemption when their provider reuse data for their own profit. That includes most big analytics service available (see for exemple Google Analytics confidentiality policy)"

[0]https://github.com/LINCnil/Guide-RGPD-du-developpeur/blob/ma...

BeniBoy··on No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU data protection body
The link you provide is not a DPA nor a EU body. I would advise getting better sources, as cookies to remember user preferences are allowed without consent.
BeniBoy··on No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU data protection body
Well, this is a little more complicated, because the cookie issue stems not from the GDPR but from ePrivacy.

This directive explicitely targets reading/writing into the user terminal without autorisation, hence the application to cookies.

Edit: removed a post, that was not explicative enough.

But the articulation is: ePrivacy says you need to consent to write non-essential trackers. GDPR defines how you can obtain the consent. So both laws take part in this ruling.

BeniBoy··on No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU data protection body
Get familiar with the regulation before posting.

Explicitely allowed:

* Cookies for login/session

* Cookies for shopping carts

* Cookies for interface personnalisation (language, etc.)

* Cookies for load balancing

* Cookies to retain user choice regarding cookies

And quite a few other.

BeniBoy··on How to avoid Amazon: guide to online shopping
For bike equipement, both bike24.com and bike-component.de both are great! Good selection, great customer service and fast shipping, even now.. Amazon can't compete with that.

In general German eshop are the best (shopping from France).

BeniBoy··on I got my file from Clearview AI
Well I would advise everybody to file a complaint to their local DPA. Even if you can oppose the processing, they rely on legitimate interest (doubtful their balancing act is acceptable) and they acquired the data in a legal way, they failed to inform the user of a second-hand data collection[1].

So If they have data on you, that is older than a month, and did not contacted you to inform you of it, you can file a complaint!

[1]https://github.com/LINCnil/Guide-RGPD-du-developpeur/blob/ma... (In French sorry)

BeniBoy··on Publicly available data under the GDPR
Though keep in mind that to rely on legitimate interest you have to do a "balancing test" between your interest and the ones of the user.

This is not an easy legal basis to rely on, and most of the time DPA are quite wary of processing relying on it!

BeniBoy··on Alphabet earnings show Google Cloud on $10B run rate
This is a more complicated question that it seems!

Cookie banner are not directly related to the GDPR, but to the Eprivacy directive, which, not being a Regulation, is subject to variation in national law transcription. So the answer may vary depending on your country!

Still in an effort to have a uniform position on the question, DPAs( Data protection agency) are working at the EDPB (the European Data Protection Board, a sort of council of DPAs) to have a common position.

One of the currently shared position is that a cookie wall impedes the "free" part of the consent, since you have to support a negative consequence.

In a communication regarding the (future?) Eprivacy regulation, the EDPB clearly stated that:

"In order for consent to be freely given as required by the GDPR, access to services and functionalities must not be made conditional on theconsentof a userto the processing of personal data or the processing of information related to or processed by the terminal equipment of end-users, meaning that cookie walls should be explicitly prohibited." [1]

If I remember correctly the Austria DPA is not of favor of a cookie wall ban though..

From memory, not a legal advice!

EDIT: try to make the explanation clearer!

[1]: https://edpb.europa.eu/sites/edpb/files/files/file1/edpb_sta...

BeniBoy··on Roam: Why I Love It and How I Use It
Unfortunately, I tend to agree. I was pretty excited skimming over the post, not realizing this was a hosted solution. Any good self-hosted alternatives with the same features? Or good thread about personnal knowledge management?
BeniBoy··on How to Download Live Images from Government Weather Satellites (2018)
Trying to find that as well!

The best I could find for now is the EUMETSAT feed[1], but it is updated every hour and not as good as GOES-16 at night.

[1]: https://eumetview.eumetsat.int/static-images/MSG/RGB/NATURAL...

BeniBoy··on The problem isn’t data protection, it’s data collection
Well, publisher and advertiser made it a joke, by trying for the last ten years to extorcate unappropriate consent from users (and bothering them as much as possible in the process).

And regarding the option to set your preferences at the browser level, of course this is the best possible solution, but if you are following the ePrivacy reglement discussion, the article 10 (permitting browser to obtain consent for website with a standardized interface) is pretty close to getting killed.. Money talks.

BeniBoy··on The Greening of Paris Makes Its Mayor More Than a Few Enemies
The ground. Paris's ground is not strong enough to support high rise building especially in the southern part, where a lot of it have been excavated in the last 500 years (and filled with dead bodies, ie the catacombs). Of course with clever engineering everything is possible, but that really limits the development of such towers.

It is true that the main limitation still is the construction code, which preserves the global proportion of the city.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →