4,242 karma · joined July 30, 2009
The fact you find this trivial is kind of the point that's being made. Some people think having an agent is some kind of voodoo, but it's really not.
It's not "accept things that are not upsetting"
Have the grace to accept things I cannot change, the power to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference.
An intelligent person usually knows a lot about a lot. The more things you know about, the more chances you have to make a mistake and think changing something is in your court, when it's really not.
There's also a good chance, since she was interviewed, that that's how she described herself first.
"Tell me about yourself."
"Well, I'm a grandmother..."
If you're going to advertise a product at least go the content marketing route to give the discussion here a bit more to chew on.
Not everybody everybody. Some people want to charge/pay/receive the maximum reasonable amount. Where "reasonable" is informed by social norms. The existence of so many amoral corporations, and sociopathic individuals running them, has absolutely skewed social expectations though.
Such people are certainly less common, but they do exist (anecdata of one, me)
Homo economicus does not actually exist.
"PS: definitely not ElReg's aMfM"
It is far from that simple. It takes understanding how people will read between the lines of what you say, seeking unsaid meaning where there was none. I fight this constantly in my life. It would be so, so much easier and simpler for me if I could just say what I mean and have others understand that.
On the one hand, there are responses like that describe this as bizarre and tone-deaf, accuse it of LLM levels of fake empathy, or say how if they were laid off they would absolutely despise getting such a message.
On the other hand, there are responses from people who actually received such messages when they were laid off saying how valuable and meaningful even a simple "sorry to hear the news" message was to them.
Though, at least as I post this, there aren't any responses describing being laid off and disliking such messages in practice, it's all hypothetical hate. Not entirely sure how to interpret that. Maybe they'll appear as more comments get posted.
There's a lot of layers here and many reasons why such strongly opposed sentiments might arise. It would be fascinating to get a better understanding of all this. Is it a personality thing? Is it a past experience thing? Is it from how a person views their relationship to work and their employer? How do these opinions distribute across the neurotypical/neurodivergent axis?
One detail that specifically interests me is this idea that wanting to offer condolences, but not automatically obligate oneself to anything beyond that seems to draw ire. Those expressing this opinion seem to be saying there is a clear, stark line for what constitutes "enough" that this approach clearly falls short of. But where that line is is going to be pretty strongly influenced by social convention, which not all people are not tuned into to the same degree, for a variety of reasons.
See this comment by an OpenJDK tech lead: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37666793
"to most developers who are most likely to interact with this code over its useful lifetime."
This means accounting for the audience. Something unfamiliar to the average random coder might be very familiar to anyone likely to touch a particular piece of code in a particular organization.
At a glance it seems this would only remain true so long as American interests and the interests of the corporation align. Which they do, up to a point.
The question then becomes where is the "triple point" between "A globally competitive USA", "Corporate oligarchy", and "Power to the people"? If such a balance can when exist
However, it is fit for purpose if your purpose is showing user-facing ids that can't be trivially incremented. For example, in a url, or in an api response. It does, in fact, "protect" against the "attack" of "Oh, I see in the url that my id is 19563, I wonder what I get if I change it to 19564.”
Now, the system should absolutely have authorization boundaries around data, but that doesn't mean there's no value in avoiding putting an "attractive nuisance" in front of users.
Do we though? Sure, we communicate sequentially, but that doesn't mean that our internal effort is piecewise and linear. A modern transformer LLM however is. Each token is sampled from a population exclusively dependent on the tokens that came before it.
Mechanistically speaking, it works similarly to autocomplete, but at a very different scale.
Now how much of an unavoidable handicap this incurs, if any, is absolutely up for debate.
But yes, taking this mechanistic truth and only considering it in a shallow manner underestimates the capability of LLMs by a large degree.
Humor is welcome here, but it needs to have some substance behind it.
The bar for legal consequences is expected to be much higher than mere association.
It has never been perfect, nor uniformly applied in all circumstances, but it is and should remain a nominal goal of the justice system. For that to no longer be considered the case, even in a casual conversation like this, is a devastating shift of the Overton window towards authoritarianism as the norm.
In the case things "merely" get fairly shitty, but society continues to more or less function, then gold has historically shown good staying power in terms of it being a highly sought after good, despite lack of actual function in many cases.