HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

BlackFingolfin

624 karma · joined February 21, 2014

submissionscomments
BlackFingolfin··on Explain mathematically a video from a space station (2011)
No, he answered that in 2011 :-). And he and many other famous (and not so famous) mathematicians contribute to MathOverflow
BlackFingolfin··on Unix Is Not an Acceptable Unix (2015)
Of course one any of those filenames contains a space, your first two examples break down, and in the worst case result in the wrong files being deleted. Of course one can work around that, but in reality, this quickly gets difficult, and often is forgotten. The print0 works for some cases, but not in general (e.g. when one needs to do more complex processing)
BlackFingolfin··on Gail, not Gmail
How on earth could one do something "more productive, and helpful, to society" with gail.com that one couldn't do just as well or better with some other domain name?

I don't buy this argument at all.

BlackFingolfin··on Math Professor Fighting Gerrymandering with Geometry
Thing is, "fixing gerrymandering" sounds a lot like fixing the wrong problem - instead of devising complicated clever plans for fixing it, engineers will feel compelled to adress what they perceive as the "real" underlying problem.

Whether doing so is realistic or not is another question, but as a non-american, I can totally relate to this attitude - the whole problem just seems bizarre to me. But don't get me wrong, I am neither judging, nor do I think that "just switch to proportional representation" is realistic for the US without a revolution, or at least some miraculous bipartisan effort.

BlackFingolfin··on Theranos might be on life support
Not necessarily so if the company goes bankrupt...
BlackFingolfin··on GitLab’s Secret to Managing Employees in 160 Locations: Write Everything Down
By trained or by untrained people? Domain specific experts, or newbies? .And why "clicks"? For many tasks, the way to get them done realy quick is with keys...

I had to do some IT support for a doctor's office many years ago, and (unrelated to what I was doing), had a chance to look at the system the front desk lady used to manage the patients, appointments etc. and it used a "clunky" old text based system (perhaps even DOS based?). TO me, it looked utterly bizarre and incomprehensible. But man, the front desk lady was lightning fast doing anything with it. Of course she trained on the system for years, and just entered keypressed rapidly that didn't make sense to me, but achieved the desired result... So, zero clicks, low search times, no (for me visible) user errors... so I guess they never should have switched, as this was the "objectively optimal" UI?

Personally, I don't think so. I.e. I think the UI could have been better, and easier to learn. But of course it's also important to see how usable it is once you do learn it... I was at that doctor's office again, not so long ago, this time as a patient... new lady (the old one retired, I assume), new system... flashy graphics... everything done with clicking, I don't even know if there still are shortcuts, the new lady certainly didn't seem to use any. And it did feel slower overall -- though this is of course a subjective evaluation only, with many years between the two observations. Plus it's somewhat unfair to compare somebody who trained a decade on a system with somebody who for all I know started a week ago... but I guess that's exactly my point here...

BlackFingolfin··on GitLab’s Secret to Managing Employees in 160 Locations: Write Everything Down
I think you still missed the point: If he is there every now and then, then he still has missed all the water cooler discussions that happened while he was not there. It's not as if they will see him and say "ah, right, now that I see you, we discussed this and this last week when you are not here.".

The only way to fix this is with some concious effort to reproduce the results of water cooler discussions explictly -- and if you spend that effort anyway, you might just as well do it via Skype or Slack... He doesn't have to be on-site.

BlackFingolfin··on Apple proposes new web 3D graphics API
Because Vukkan is too low level for the web, and thus not a good impedence match. Here is a nice writeup: https://floooh.github.io/2016/08/13/webgl-next.html
BlackFingolfin··on Apple proposes new web 3D graphics API
Quoting from their proposal:

> We don’t expect this to become the actual API that ends up in the standard, and maybe not even the one that the Community Group decides to start with, but we think there is a lot of value in working code.

I think it's pretty natural to write what is essentially a proof-of-concept with tools one is ga,iliar with.

BlackFingolfin··on Problems I Have with Python
Your post quite strongly alludes to it being either due to incompetence, or politics, or both. So I think grandparent has a very valid point, and you might want to change the tone of your post a bit; then it'll produce fewer knee-jerk reactions, and might be taken more seriously.
BlackFingolfin··on Scientists must fight for the facts
"... of all facts being subjective and equally applicable"

I guess you meant to write "objective" there instead of "subjective", at least otherwise I can't make sense from what you write...

The thing is: Facts are, by definition, obective: "a thing that is known or proved to be true". However, their interpretation is not, and it may well be influenced by additional facts being revealed -- thus, whenver somebody says "given the facts, it is clear that XYZ holds", what they really mean (whether they are aware of it or not is another question) is "given the facts I am aware of, XYZ holds".

But again: these are additional facts, not alternative facts.

So all in all, I don't think your suggestion about an eventual legitimate need for the term "alternative facts" holds gound.

BlackFingolfin··on ThinkPad X1 Carbon
Or you could have glanced at the article and seen that your guess is wide off the mark.. ;-)
BlackFingolfin··on Geometric Constructions Game with Straightedge and Compass
In principle, this is the right construction. However, you did not perform a proper construction, as can be seen by the two tiny red circles: Instead of constructing a circle passing through the end points of the given line, you "eyeballed" the circle diameter. Which may look right at this resolution, but if you were to zoom in sufficiently, you would inevitable end up with a circle that oh-so-slightly misses to go through one of the end points of the base line.

In the smartphone app, to do this right you need to select the circle tool, start at one end point of the line, then drag your finger exactly to the other end point -- it'll "snap" to that, and create a circle through the second end point.

BlackFingolfin··on Taking a month off from OSS volunteering
If you did that, wouldn't the customers whose already agreed-upon reservations you just ditched be rightfully upset, and call your behaviour "unprofessional"?

I think the professional response here would be "sure, I'll sell the restaurant to you, but only after I had a chance to fulfill the obligations I entered into, as otherwise my professional reputation gets tarnished".

BlackFingolfin··on Traditional JavaScript benchmarks
"It is probably fair to say that JavaScript is the most important technology these days when it comes to software engineering."

Uhh ... no?

BlackFingolfin··on Libtiff goes offline
It doesn't seem to be actively used in the past few years, though; isn't there a process one can use to claim unused github user / org names? Might be worth talking to GitHub staff about...
BlackFingolfin··on [dead]
Well, having the list is certainly nice, though I don't really see a fair comparison there, more a list of "reasons why I think those other tools suck" ... :-). Some links to those external projects would also be nice. Just saying -- of course the author has probably better things to do than provide a link list to alternative software, but if you go to the trouble of making such a list, that might be handy.

And of course there are more alternatives out there, e.g. it perhaps Fabric <http://www.fabfile.org/> should also be in the list?

BlackFingolfin··on [dead]
I am not quite sure what "it uses binary SSH" is meant to say. It sounds as if you were refering to the SSH protocol (which of course is "binary"), though my guess is that you mean to say that it relies on executing a separate "ssh binary" (note in particular "ssh" vs. "SSH"). If the latter interpretation is right, perhaps rephrase what you wrote in your README?
BlackFingolfin··on Sorting algorithms visualizer
This is a really nice page!

It would be even nicer if there was some way to find out who made it and/or how to contact the author(s); and/or how and whether one can add more algorithms (e.g. I'd love to see timsort and introsort).

As it is, this site seems to be completly anonymous. Which is of course a valid choice by the author(s), but IMHO quite sad :-(.

BlackFingolfin··on How to Distribute Binaries for OS X Using Homebrew
That's a really weak justification. For most of those "braindead" packages, it is actually fairly easy to get them to install into arbitrary locations. After all, both Fink and MacPort have been doing that with great success for over a decade.

Sadly, you are correct about "not every single Homebrew formula has actually been tested with a non-/usr/local install path". In fact, while there are many Homebrew formulas of great quality, my impression is that there are also m many of rather poor quality, with other problems in them. E.g. just yesterday, I discovered that the Homebreak lmdb formula does not build properly versioned shared libraries -- because upstream didn't, and the packager either didn't notice or didn't care to fix it

I rarely (if ever) this kind of issue with MacPort and Fink, which try hard to avoid such problems (at the cost of a higher entry barrier for packagers -- for better or worse). Mind you, I am not everything is golden with them, either.

Disclaimer: I've been involved with the Fink project since OS X 10.1 or so.

BlackFingolfin··on Go-style concurrency in C
I didn't see any assembler code in libmill, nor does it use ucontext. Not sure what you are talking about here?
BlackFingolfin··on NoSQL Benchmark Compares PostgreSQL, MongoDB, Neo4j, OrientDB and ArangoDB
I think this is a classical case of "use the right tool for the right purpose". If you want to do "classic database" stuff, use a classic SQL database. But if e.g. graph traversal is a cruicial operation for your application, then looking at NoSQL solution seems to be quite interesting.

In other words: I wouldn't call a screw driver a bad tool, just because it's not as good at driving nails into wood as a hammer.

BlackFingolfin··on NoSQL Benchmark Compares PostgreSQL, MongoDB, Neo4j, OrientDB and ArangoDB
Why so hostile? Personally, I assume this is just an instance of them not being PostgeSQL experts. So, before jumping to conclusions (namely that they deliberatly skewed their test, despite being very open in the way they described the setup), I'll instead wait and see -- perhaps they'll explain why they used json instead of jsonb, or perhaps (better!) they can updat the test to also include jsonb.
BlackFingolfin··on PyPy warmup improvements
"Wirbel" ist german for whirl, swirl, vortex, ... -- and "wirr" means roughly "confused" or "light in the head" -- my guess is that this user speaks German and the nick is a pun ;-).
BlackFingolfin··on Auditing GitHub users’ SSH key quality
Of course that is an "if" one should carefully think about -- e.g. it is OK if all you are using is OpenSSH at version 6.5 or later. (That can be a problem with many older boxes). But other than that, last I checked only SSH.NET and tinyssh supported ed25519 keys. Shameless plug for some more data on this: http://ssh-comparison.quendi.de/comparison.html (yeah, that page could be a lot better -- pull requests are welcome)
BlackFingolfin··on Swift: Madness of Generic Integer
> Of course, at that point, why not simply reinterpret the array buffer directly...

... because then the behavior of the code depends on the endianess of the CPU, and thus is a potential future portability gotcha... ? :)

BlackFingolfin··on Secure Secure Shell
For fun, I started work on this. It's still rather crude, and the code is hackish, but anyway: Comparison page: http://ssh-comparison.quendi.de/comparison.html

Git repository: https://github.com/fingolfin/ssh-comparison

Improvements are highly welcome; not just adding more clients, but also on refactoring the code, improving the UI (I suck at HTML), adding features... The TODO already lists some ideas.

BlackFingolfin··on Secure Secure Shell
Looking at which key exchange protocols, HMACs etc. various other SSH implementations out there support, it seems that many of them would be barred from accessing a server hardened like that :/. In fact, it almost seems like the intersection of mutually supported protocols is empty resp. only contains known-to-be-unsafe ones... :(.

Which makes me wonder: Is there anywhere a comprehensive comparison with tables that show which SSH clients (and servers) support which algorithms for key exchange, HMAC, etc.? That would help determining whom one is going to shut out by disabling which protocol, and thus help in making an informed decision on that.

Of course, to be really useful, such a table would also need to take into account which version of each listed software added support for which protocol -- as it is, the OpenSSH shipped in e.g. Mac OS X 10.8 (5.9p1) does not support curve25519-sha256@libssh.org which the OP recommends...

Sources: http://www.libssh2.org/ http://api.libssh.org/stable/ https://support.ssh.com/manuals/server-admin/44/Ciphers_and_... http://www.lysator.liu.se/~nisse/lsh/lsh.html

BlackFingolfin··on Systemd has 6 service startup notification types, and they're all wrong
But $NOTIFY_SOCKET and how to use it is documented, see here: http://0pointer.de/public/systemd-man/sd_notify.html
BlackFingolfin··on Visual Programming Languages – Snapshots
I don't understand why Squeak or Self (with or without Morphic) would be considered visual programming languages. Don't get me wrong, I think Morphic is a pretty slick system, but still... Perhaps because it was not made quite clear what is considered to be a "visual programming language".

Based on what is in this list, though, it would seem to me that e.g. the combination of "Objective-C and InterfaceBuilder" could also be added to the list, which feels silly.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →