HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Brave-Steak

128 karma · joined January 13, 2020

submissionscomments
Brave-Steak··on I Was Tortured for Days at Guantanamo Bay
> Unless the terrorist attack provided greater utility than preventing it, then you wouldn't want to stop it. Utilitarianism is real worrying, isn't it?

Again, it depends on what your goal is. Utilitarianism is as worrying as moral relativism, and I don't see people worried about that either.

Brave-Steak··on I Was Tortured for Days at Guantanamo Bay
Utilitarianism is about whether the consequence justifies your course of action. If your goal is to prevent the 9/11 attacks, torturing whoever is the wrong solution. If your goal is to make people feel better, maybe, but even then I'd posit that you'd make them feel better by preventing 9/11.
Brave-Steak··on Procrastination is about managing emotions, not time
If hyperactivity is one end, I'm on the complete other end. And I always associated ADHD with being hyperactive.
Brave-Steak··on Procrastination is about managing emotions, not time
> ADHD (particularly the attention side, as an adult)

I take it that means hyperactivity wasn't one of your symptoms? I have the suspicion that I suffer from ADD (you basically described the same life I've had), but the hyperactivity part makes me unsure of myself.

Brave-Steak··on “Like” at Your Own Risk
> Another one is the ability for someone to change privacy level of a post from private to public. So that risky like that you thought was a safe one among friends could then be opened for everyone to see.

This seems like a difficult problem in general and reminds me of this episode of Hidden Brain (https://www.npr.org/2019/09/06/758281834/you-cant-hit-unsend...). Where sharing shocking/"inappropriate" memes in a private WhatsApp led to everybody involved losing their spots in university.

Brave-Steak··on Procrastination is about managing emotions, not time
Yeah, that's the problem. That's why I'm reading this stuff about procrastination. What's your point? Are you saying I should just give up?
Brave-Steak··on Procrastination is about managing emotions, not time
> is pretty strong evidence that there's more to the human experience than biologically reinforced operant conditioning.

I'm not sure that follows. The reward system can't produce output by itself. It requires an input. Any input. It requires an environment, a context. And one of the possible outputs is, well, his point of view. But that doesn't invalidate the reward system. It just shows how unpredictable it is.

Brave-Steak··on I Was Tortured for Days at Guantanamo Bay
If the argument is "he could sue", the justification would be something like there's a miniscule risk that a lawsuit could lead to a Supreme Court decision that puts their kidnapping, torture and black site policies at risk. I don't think money is relevant here.
Brave-Steak··on Procrastination is about managing emotions, not time
What makes you think we are anything more than the output of a reward function? Dopamine and other hormones function as our reward system and are so fundamental and drive effectively all of our behaviours and our learning from the moment we were born.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reward_system

https://academic.oup.com/endo/article/151/5/1978/2456493

Brave-Steak··on I Was Tortured for Days at Guantanamo Bay
> This is a pretty classic example of a utility monster. It's part of the reason that many have issues with utilitarianism.

I'm not sure it's even utilitarianism. Otherwise he'd be admitting that "Well, torture doesn't give us any actionable intelligence, so we shouldn't be torturing anybody". Utilitarianism isn't about doing pointless actions in the remote hope of the victim giving up anything useful or true.

> Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that determines right from wrong by focusing on outcomes. It is a form of consequentialism.

Stated otherwise: Suppose you had some information about 9/11 one week before and you torture your informant to get the precise date and location. You don't get anything because torture doesn't work, and it draws resources away from more useful investigative efforts to track potential attackers, while undermining US strategic and diplomatic efforts overseas. Should you have tortured that person or not?

Brave-Steak··on Procrastination is about managing emotions, not time
My subconsciousness wants to eat, sleep, fuck and play video games. I'm not sure I want to be taking its advice.
Brave-Steak··on Procrastination is about managing emotions, not time
While I've spent a lot of time reading everything he's written, I never felt that any of it helped me overcome my procrastination. It was just recognition and a shallow, fleeting satisfaction in that recognition.
Brave-Steak··on Procrastination is about managing emotions, not time
I've made a similar realization recently. It seems that I've built a life around consumption. Watching TV series, movies, playing games. I think we're not made for this. There's nothing there to really push us to grow as a person (especially if it's all we do), thus the emptiness (and often loneliness). I've thought about how to restructure my life into one of production instead of consumption, but it's difficult (to find what to produce, and then to get started) and takes so much more effort than passively consuming whatever media teams of people spent weeks/months/years creating.
Brave-Steak··on Procrastination is about managing emotions, not time
Is the channel purely informational or does it also provide methods for how to deal with it? Or is the best solution medication (in the case of ADD)?
Brave-Steak··on TLDR pages: Simplified, community-driven man pages
Or I type ‘tldr’ and don’t waste my time? I swear to god, engineers are so focused on efficiency and yet are so eager to waste so much time and effort on repeating crap like this unnecessarily. Just think about the context switches alone necessary to type all that.
Brave-Steak··on What is Rust and why is it so popular?
/ = or

As in C or C++. I didn't mean it as its own language. And C++ has plenty of issues where I'd consider it equally unsafe. Unless you're a god tier programmer, and even then, it's impossible to write safe code without insane amounts of effort that can't be expected in most projects.

Brave-Steak··on TLDR pages: Simplified, community-driven man pages
Yeah, no. The use cases for man and tldr are completely different, and trying to convince every single project to make their man pages more friendly to people who just want to get their work done is just ... well, an impossible amount of effort. tldr coalesces a community around a common goal, and they can work towards that goal without fighting hundreds of different maintainers on making man pages more accessible.
Brave-Steak··on TLDR pages: Simplified, community-driven man pages
tldr doesn't remove man pages. You're free to check the man page for what whatever flags used in a command in tldr mean.
Brave-Steak··on TLDR pages: Simplified, community-driven man pages
The thing is - I don't want to go to some website or pour through pages and pages of documentation when I want to do one specific thing. I want to do something and move on with my life. My job isn't learning every command line switch under the job.
Brave-Steak··on What is Rust and why is it so popular?
> To me the Rust community seems to want to argue that everything should be rewritten in Rust

I haven't seen this. At most, I've seen the push for rewriting important libraries where security is a core issue in Rust. I don't blame them. I'm tired of C/C++ being used everywhere because of performance, leading to the current-day situation of so much fundamentally unsafe code running the world.

Brave-Steak··on Boeing has temporarily stopped making 737 Max airplanes
I'd assume this is only temporary. How many orders for the Max do they still have unfulfilled? That'd be a significant loss if they intended to not fill them sometime in the future.

Edit: It says in the article

> The assembly line in Renton, Washington, has stopped building Boeing's bestselling plane, the company confirmed late Monday. Boeing announced plans to temporarily halt production for an undetermined period in December, but it had not previously announced a precise day for the shutdown.

Brave-Steak··on Nvidia GeForce RTX 3080, RTX 3070 Leaked Specs: Up to 20GB GDDR6 RAM
Unfortunately, it seems they're more than happy with the current state of things and they don't particularly care who buys their cards. They can push up the price and the used market will move in lockstep because demand is so high.
Brave-Steak··on Nvidia GeForce RTX 3080, RTX 3070 Leaked Specs: Up to 20GB GDDR6 RAM
At this point all I care about is the price. The price of GPUs has ballooned in an insane way recently and it’s impossible to get a decent deal that’s significantly faster than what I have now (and I haven’t upgraded in years). The used market seems to have been decimated, with even last gen cards going for crazy high prices. I suspect the 30x0 line will be even more expensive than the current one, and I hate it.
Brave-Steak··on Staff emails claim Boeing 777X ‘shares Max problem’
I don't think it's a wrong characterization, imo. The problem with the MAX isn't necessarily the MCAS, but the culture and business/engineering processes that allowed MCAS to go all the way to production and allowed the company to convince their customers not to implement pilot training. There are multiple levels of failure beyond just MCAS being a thing, and the emails might suggest that (some of?) these systemic issues are also affecting the design of the 777x.
Brave-Steak··on Nototo – Build a unified mental map of notes
It looks like there’s no desktop app of any kind? The idea looks fascinating, but unfortunately it’s a complete no-go for me without a native and offline option.
Brave-Steak··on A Sad Day for Rust
Found a working copy of the original Github issue: https://gist.github.com/mafrasi2/debed733781db4aba2a52620b67...

Aside from maybe the second to last comment, I don't see anything here that deserved deletion.

Brave-Steak··on A Sad Day for Rust
All discussion I saw about the issue was quite civilized.

https://old.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/epzukc/actix_web_repo...

https://old.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/epoloy/ive_smoketeste...

I get that people hate Reddit around here, but pushing this on them as vitriol by the Rust community there is wholly unfair. The impression I've gotten is that the developer of actix used unsafe too much, made no attempt to inform users that his framework was thus not safe to use (to the level expected of a Rust project), and rejected plenty of PR's where these issues would've been fixed, while being belligerent about continuing to write unsafe code.

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/648807492931026953/66...

He'd even started deleting comments and entire issues just for pointing out unsafe code. And it seems like he's had the archives deleted, since the archived pages which used to exist are no longer accessible (I didn't even know that was possible?).

http://web.archive.org/web/20200117043715/https://github.com...

Frankly, after years of seeing people defend C/C++ projects because "well, just get better", I think it's a good thing that security-consciousness is at a point where developers are being rightly criticized for playing fast and loose with security. There are always complaints about how we have no idea what kind of code being used on NPM or other package systems. But make some effort to improve it and now they're the bad guys? Oh, come on. You can't have it both ways.

And as somebody else has already pointed out, plenty of other projects also had PR's regarding safety issues, as linked by the original article which tested all these projects. The actix author is the only one who rejected them, and he's the only one facing complaints.

Brave-Steak··on Germany looks to step up coal exit timetable
They don't even have enough spare capacity now. I think I remember reading that when peak loads were particularly high recently, they had to import power from Germany.
Brave-Steak··on Ever Plugged a USB in Wrong? (2019)
Okay, and what’s your trick for knowing which way around the plug is?

Edit: Whoops, meant port.

Brave-Steak··on Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training Requirement
I'd really be interested in knowing at what level these two employees were at. How deep does the rot go? Even if the CEO is gone, these people are still around.
← PreviousPage 3 of 3