HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

BrazzVuvuzela

413 karma · joined December 14, 2021

submissionscomments
BrazzVuvuzela··on Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety webpage
> are more

Typo of abhor?

BrazzVuvuzela··on Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety webpage
> The minutiae of where the scanning occurs is irrelevant because Apple's implementation is merely a way of performing the function without giving up the user's privacy (by scanning locally rather than sending all of your photos to Apple's servers for review.)

This is where you and I part ways. I don't think that's an irrelevant minutiae, because it normalizes on-device scanning. This implementation or others may change in the future and opposition to those future implementations will be hampered by "Apple was already doing it" arguments, which will sound fairly plausible to the non-technical public.

Maybe I'm making a 'slippery slope' argument here, but I've become comfortable with such lines of thinking. My cynicism has been rewarded too often before.

BrazzVuvuzela··on Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety webpage
> two intersection of two independent CSAM databases.

I don't think that offers meaningful protection. A malicious government could acquire or produce real CSAM, or at least a convincing fake of it, then modify that image subtly to match the hash of the political content they were targeting (I believe such engineered collisions have already been demonstrated.) They would then be able to get that manipulated CSAM into as many independent CSAM databases as they wanted, simply by uploading it to the web then reporting it to all those independent databases.

BrazzVuvuzela··on Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety webpage
If Apple would like us to believe they changed their mind, they might consider telling us they changed their mind. They haven't told us that, so why should we assume it?
BrazzVuvuzela··on Apple removes references to CSAM from its child safety webpage
> equivalent features are not being misused on Google and Meta/Facebook's properties

The objections come when such systems are to be run not on corporate property, but on end user property. I don't see anybody objecting to corporations scanning content uploaded to the corporation's own computers. Scanning content on the user's computer, which is the user's property, is what unnerves people.

Furthermore, while Apple may have implemented this feature in a relatively safe way (I don't fully understand it so I'm not confident of that, but smart people here think it so I'll assume it for the sake of argument), I believe that the general public does not really understand this nuance and Apple normalizing the practice of scanning personal computers will clear the way for other corporations to implement scanning in shittier way. If Microsoft were to start scanning all documents on a Windows computer by uploading those documents to their own servers, is that a distinction that would necessarily be made clear to the general public? I don't think so. The rhetoric will be "Apple does it and that's fine, so Microsoft can do it too". The technical differences in the two implementations will be understood in forums like this, but not by the general public at large.

BrazzVuvuzela··on Linux Touchpad Like MacBook Update: Touchpad Gestures Now Shipping
I use two-finger scrolling on my touchpad when using a terminal. Is it necessary? No. But it's certainly easy and convenient, particularly since it works the same as it does in every other application. I can scroll faster in man with my trackpad than I can using the j and k keys. I know I could also use pgup/pgdown, but with those I have to move my hands anyway and I'm more likely to visually lose my place in the document (same problem with d/u, and the others.)
BrazzVuvuzela··on Linux Touchpad Like MacBook Update: Touchpad Gestures Now Shipping
> libinput became the default because of political pressure from Red Hat

I don't know if this is true, but when comparing the KDE configuration screens for both, it sure seems like it must be true. libinput is missing much that synaptics has and doesn't seem to do anything better as far as I can tell. Unfortunately, just because a developer is working hard and pouring his heart and soul into something, doesn't mean the result is actually worthwhile.

BrazzVuvuzela··on Linux Touchpad Like MacBook Update: Touchpad Gestures Now Shipping
KWin is great, as are Dolphin, the 'System Settings' GUI, and many other KDE applications. But for the life of me I cannot understand the praise of Plasma. It crashes or otherwise breaks regularly for me (for instance, my autohiding panel will sometimes disappear completely, forcing me to kquitapp5/kstart5 plasmashell to get it back) Edit mode is a usability nightmare, I feel like I need to be super careful about where I move my mouse while using it because otherwise it does things I didn't intend with errant mouse hovers. And while it may not be the fault of plasmashell itself, many of the plasmoids are broken, janky, or generally just not very good. While I use KDE, I try to avoid all the plasma stuff as much as possible.
BrazzVuvuzela··on Saule Omarova says banks sank her chance to become a key regulator
Senator Kennedy and what he said is only 1/4th of that comment.
BrazzVuvuzela··on Saule Omarova says banks sank her chance to become a key regulator
> One would assume that if the law was intended that everyone can have a bank account, then ultimately one would be able to appeal through the courts

Maybe we should first socialize the legal industry, such that suing the government is actually a realistic option for the common person who, at present, cannot afford to hire lawyers for something like that.

BrazzVuvuzela··on Log4Shell update: second Log4j vulnerability published
> to make outbound connections to the internet (or more specifically to the Mojang auth server)

I believe you can forgo even that; a vanilla server jar can be configured to run in "cracked" mode by setting 'online-mode' to false in server.properties. Skins won't work though, players will have steve/alex skins.

It's documented on the no-longer-official wiki here:

> online-mode - Server checks connecting players against Minecraft account database. Set this to false only if the player's server is not connected to the Internet. Hackers with fake accounts can connect if this is set to false! If minecraft.net is down or inaccessible, no players can connect if this is set to true. Setting this variable to off purposely is called "cracking" a server, and servers that are present with online mode off are called "cracked" servers, allowing players with unlicensed copies of Minecraft to join.

https://minecraft.fandom.com/wiki/Server.properties

BrazzVuvuzela··on Log4Shell update: second Log4j vulnerability published
Keep the server on your LAN and you should be relatively safe, no? If it's just for your kids and not their friends too, any old spare computer should probably be sufficient to run it.
BrazzVuvuzela··on Saule Omarova says banks sank her chance to become a key regulator
> Omarova said she was unable to express her views personally to many senators, as is usually the norm in confirmation hearings.

This context is important. Refusing to meet senators on their terms while demanding they meet you on yours seems like a power play.

BrazzVuvuzela··on About Three-in-Ten U.S. Adults Are Now Religiously Unaffiliated
> Who are the two percent of people responding to this survey who have no religion and pray every day?

They might eat with their family, who are religious, and go along with the prayer because they think the slight inconvenience isn't worth rocking the boat over.

BrazzVuvuzela··on Saule Omarova says banks sank her chance to become a key regulator
Demanding one-on-one meetings with senators? Seems like a failed power play.
BrazzVuvuzela··on Saule Omarova says banks sank her chance to become a key regulator
That's not a very compelling refutation to the claims you're responding to.
BrazzVuvuzela··on Photos of a KH-12 Kennan Keyhole Secret Military Spy Satellite (2013)
NROL-82, launched this year early in April, is likely one of them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KH-11#Block_V
BrazzVuvuzela··on Photos of a KH-12 Kennan Keyhole Secret Military Spy Satellite (2013)
> Looking at the earth would blind it

Wouldn't that depend on how much dynamic range it has? Webb is intended to look at very dim signals in space so Earth would blind it, but if a spy-Webb were intended to track rocket or jet engines, things quite hotter than the rest of earth, perhaps it might be capable of that?

BrazzVuvuzela··on Ask HN: News site that provides world updates only when relevant?
> for every tool mankind has created - there are ways to utilize it in good VS bad outcomes

Counter point: Slot machines exist. (I suppose you might find some few instances of them being used to raise money for charity or something, but I don't think that redeems the technology.)

Recommendation engines are generally benign when the input content is benign. Pandora itself doesn't seem to cause trouble. Though even with benign content, content recommendation can encourage unhealthy behavior, such the content recommendation engine of netflix/etc encouraging binge consumption and couch potatoism.

But what does it mean for content to be benign and how is that determination made? When you have relatively little content that changes relatively infrequently, like netflix, you can have trusted humans perform the selection. That bakes the biases of those humans into the system, which is not inherently a problem (it's not as though any newspaper or book was ever any different in this regard.) But with things like youtube or the hypothetical Pandora for News, the the depth and breadth of content is too large for trusted human curation. I think we've actually already seen some examples of this manifest on Facebook, where the recommendation engine sends people down radicalizing holes of local news particularly.

There has been a lot of talk recently about the identification and suppression of disinformation and misinformation. D&M is problematic and tasking independent fact checkers to fight it may have some merit, but I think there is much more to consider. For starters, the local fact-checkers, who understand the language and cultural context of the material they are evaluating, are imposing their own potentially harmful biases onto the system. Secondly, and more importantly, some propaganda is neither misinformation nor disinformation. An example: racists love to pass around links to factually correct local news articles about crime. They will inundate their targets with news stories that support their narrative. Each of those stories, evaluated independently, might be factual and come from a reputable news organization. But the sum of those stories may mislead people by not presenting mitigating considerations, social or historical context, etc. If you create a system that recommends people the intersection of 'local news' and 'crime', you've automated the job of the racist propagandists. But if your content recommendation engine doesn't recommend such intersections, by lumping all local news into a single category, then it has little utility over simply visiting the websites of local news organizations. And if your system forbids local news entirely because the breadth of local news across the world is too much to moderate, then your system omits the news that directly impacts the lives of news readers the most.

I don't see any way around the above, but what makes a recommendation engine any worse than the local newspaper itself? Simply this: a newspaper is the same for everybody who reads it, when somebody is being sent down some bizarre radical rabbit-hole, those around them can read the newspaper and see what sort of thing their friend is reading. But recommendation engines provide personalized experiences. People can be radicalized without others in their community seeing what is happening, denying that community the opportunity to effectively respond and intervene. People withdraw into their own personal realities, losing touch with those around them. The further apart people grow, the harder reconciliation becomes.

BrazzVuvuzela··on Wolfram Cloud
Those instant answers are the ones I'm talking about. Sometimes they're calculated, but often they're regurgitated from web crawls and the UI doesn't clearly differentiate the two.
BrazzVuvuzela··on Wolfram Cloud
Taking google's answer for things they're calculating with math is probably safe, but if you get into the habit of reading google's answers to queries it will have you believing a lot of nonsense because many of the answers google offers are not calculated at all, but instead are regurgitated nonsense that google read on the internet and took at face value (example from Technology Connections: https://youtu.be/TbHBHhZOglw?t=58)
BrazzVuvuzela··on Former Harvard chemistry chair to stand trial for allegedly hiding ties to China
Propaganda is any communication calculated to further an agenda. Propaganda may contain lies, truth, or anything in between.
BrazzVuvuzela··on Omicron variant more resistant to vaccine but causes less severe Covid: study
Ironically if this is true, then the people loudly handwringing about "long covid" are the ones who are inflicting it on others, by encouraging people to fear it.

To combat this, perhaps we could swap the masks out with gags. /s

BrazzVuvuzela··on Ask HN: News site that provides world updates only when relevant?
That sounds like it would be a radicalization engine for at least some portion of the population. I strongly encourage you to not pursue this idea.
← PreviousPage 5 of 5