HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Capricorn2481

2,028 karma · joined June 26, 2022

submissionscomments
Capricorn2481··on Xbox wants you to pay 24 to 40 cents per hour to stream games you bought
You originally said this

> Feels bad to buy an expensive piece of hardware, a $60+ game, and then be asked to pony up another hourly fee

That's why people were confused. You made it sound like you couldn't use your hardware to play games. Why are you streaming from cloud PCs in the first place if you have the hardware?

Capricorn2481··on Jailbreaking the Switch 2
From what I understand, it puts up way more fuss investigating exploits than it does reverse engineering. Right now I think you can pretty much put any Ghidra output into Claude and it won't care.
Capricorn2481··on EA is shutting down BioWare
Meh. Plug your ears if opinions offend you. I just explained why a lot of people don't like him. He's a really bad film critic that lacks domain knowledge, but he's stumbled into a dead horse he can kick.
Capricorn2481··on EA is shutting down BioWare
> That's a sweet but also very baseless accusation. You should do better research

Okay, here he is doing just that. Didn't watch it, tries to weigh in on it for clout. His own comment section is not having it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1ubB8tjL04.

> I very much doubt he calls every woman lead a diversity hire. I think you are overreacting and putting him in the chuds tribe you are already very opinionated about.

You don't have to take that literally. He wears kid gloves for male actors. He takes on a different tone when talking about women.

> I think you are overreacting and putting him in the chuds tribe you are already very opinionated about.

I didn't call him a chud, you're just inventing stuff now. But it's definitely easy to see who butters his bread.

In his Sydney Sweeney video, which is a pretty bad video in general because it doesn't engage at all with why people might not like her, he has a very long rant (for him) about liberal women and how broken they are. How they've been corrupted by college and they're just secretly jealous of beautiful women. Just empty ranting full of every stereotype he could pull out of a hat. He doesn't respond to the fact that it's a gambling ad at all, which a huge amount of people criticized. He boils everything down to "She's hot and women hate that." He doesn't even think it's worth mentioning what people actually said. He posts a bunch of completely unrelated studies to the point he is making.

Then he, for whatever reason, attacks the interviewer that asked Sydney about the American Eagle ad? Implying she's a secret liberal placed there to make her look bad? Even though she gave her the most softball questions possible. Like, I think anybody can understand this is an interviewer giving a person a chance to react to news. Why is he just seeing a woman and implying she's secretly seething with anger? It's an extremely creepy way to talk about people. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DlVovsQQGdk

Capricorn2481··on Security Disclosure
For the record, there was a bunch of non-functional vibe coded fixes flying around during this PHP bug. If you were just running the first thing AI made because you were worried about "not reacting," you would likely end up running a crap script.

AI is quite good at finding vulnerabilities, but it's been rough for patching them. The old adage "defenders have to be right every time, attackers only have to be right once" applies to AI security patches.

Capricorn2481··on EA is shutting down BioWare
> Respectfully, you are taking him far too seriously. He is playing the character of a drunk, grumpy Scottish guy complaining about things

That is a very tired thing to say. You don't need to look that hard to see how untrue this is. Take a brief glance at his twitter or his communities and you'll see how much of a "character" it is. They barely even talk about media anymore. They post the same gender war slop shit that bots are posting all over Reddit right now. Critical Drinker takes a bit of a "boiling the frog" approach to his content and his true character isn't obvious on a few listens.

> I am not a fan of him and don't like the culture war stuff

You are likely underestimating how much he does it now. It's night and day different from his earlier work. He was a ghost writer for James Patterson. He knows how to follow the money. He's essentially a parody of himself now.

> and he has much valid criticism of films/games where he highlights how badly written many of them are

I don't think such a vague and easy to defend criticism is worth handwaving the substance of the channel. People have been pointing and laughing at video game writing for 30 years. That's an uncontroversial vague post. And that is the best you're going to get from him, because he rarely talks about games or films in a specific way, he usually just copy pastes the same beat for beat plot complaints that better critics have, and putting an anti woke slant on it. Sometimes he reviews shit he hasn't even seen or played because he wants to get in on the discussion.

> He has a huge fan base on YouTube. You don't get that by being dull or not having any valid criticisms. You are way off base

Huh? Sure you do, if it has morphed from entertainment to outrage bait. That is dull, and profitable in the algorithm age. Are you under the impression cynical, lazy pop posting cannot survive on Youtube?

> I would imagine he has a more diverse audience than you would expect

I don't recall saying his audience wasn't diverse, I said his fans often don't play video games. So it's annoying to see people that don't play video games weigh in on the problems with the industry. It's nakedly obvious to the people that have grown up loving games when they are talking to a person who has just engaged with outrage content over the medium and not actually held a controller.

> A lot of people like watching people shit on popular media. Cinemasins was doing the exact same thing a decade ago

Ooph. That's exactly my point, though. Cinemasins is the kind of low brow film criticism that people who enjoy film will despise. It's pop entertainment, which is harmless, but there are 1,000 more interesting channels that can talk about film and are still entertaining. So when someone comes into a film space and you can tell they are just regurgitating Cinemasins videos, it's pretty clear they are not film watchers.

The difference is Critical Drinker has leaned heavily into the culture war stuff and has convinced a legion of fans that the reason everything is bad is down to a bunch of easily violated wokeness rules. I don't necessarily like the movies he dislikes, but the conclusions he comes to and the audience he caters to moronically shove the same 4 woke buttons into any media discussion, ad infinitum. It's extremely reactionary content. Every woman lead is a diversity hire, but every male lead in a bad movie is just an "unfortunate miss." Everything "woke" is going to fail, except whoops, for all of those things that were wildly successful, those are actually not woke anymore. It's just a channel that actively diverts discussion away from actual criticism, and makes it about algorithmically pleasing political content.

One of the funniest things I see is when Critical Drinker fans want us to return to non-woke franchises like...Metal Gear Solid. Maybe the gayest franchise of all time. A game where woke writers weren't trying to humiliate men! Except you're actually disarmed and ass kicked by your surrogate mother like 40 times.

Capricorn2481··on EA is shutting down BioWare
No they are right. That Youtuber is extremely dull and sidelines actual issues of the gaming industry in favor of inflammatory culture war topics with little evidence or thought behind it. Being a fan of him is a litmus test for tribalism.

I've also learned a lot of people who listen to him don't play games to begin with and are usually just larping. It is what it is.

Capricorn2481··on EA is shutting down BioWare
> I can't help but read that in the Critical Drinker's voice

Sounds like a horrible existence. Might as well listen to a cheese grater.

Capricorn2481··on PHP 8.2.35
Every year, several of my clients say "We will upgrade next year"
Capricorn2481··on PHP 8.2.35
Is there some reason the biggest company on earth who likely had advanced notice of this cannot put out a patch?
Capricorn2481··on PHP 8.2.35
It's great they are doing mitigations, but they admit themselves, in fine print, that this will not protect you from the vulnerability

Why is word circulating that you can just sign up for Cloudflare and be 100% protected from this? They are burying the leed and trying to get new customers, and it's working.

Capricorn2481··on PHP 8.2.35
> OpenAI and these security companies sat on this for 2 months, decided for themselves who gets access to an early fix

Amazingly, AWS Linux has not been patched yet.

Capricorn2481··on PHP 8.2.35
This is extremely damning for Cloudflare. I had a bunch of clients telling me Cloudflare is all they need to prevent this, and they want to get that on their site instead of upgrading PHP.

I have not seen confirmation Cloudflare is doing anything except playing whack a mole with certain request patterns. PHP Core Devs have been clear you need to upgrade. If this is true, it's disgustingly opportunistic that Cloudflare is using this critical security time to lie to people that they are safe.

Anyone from Cloudflare want to speak to this?

Capricorn2481··on The Elizabeth Holmes documentary “You Can See Everything” is deceiving
This particular review aside, whenever movies get talked about on HN, it's a shit show. I have learned that if you're interested in art beyond what is spoon fed to you, this is the worst site to get takes, and it's not even close.

It's clear some people take a straightforward view of media they consume, and they do not want to spend their limited energy digesting something that is supposed to be for their entertainment. Which is fine. But I think a smaller subsection of HN users actively hate art, resent that it has any cultural impact, and only engage with it out of some sense of social obligation. It's another way for them to climb the ladder. When the same people comment on movies like this, they have an extremely low bar for what is considered "art for snobs." Everything must fit in a box. Entertainment must be pulp, in your face. Documentaries must be all facts. Do not play with the medium at all. Do not even jump around in time. I saw a comment on here saying the twist in Oppenheimer was that we were jumping around in time.

It's a bit baffling to read comments that say "Just read the book" about this particular movie. Even if you have no idea who Nathan Fielder is, surely you're not watching the trailer for this movie and thinking this was going to be a great film to get all the facts.

Capricorn2481··on Zuckerberg's Meta Takes Down No Kings Instagram During Protest Day
There's maybe 40 people on this list you could remotely consider "critics of woke censorship." And they are certainly not critics of censorship, wholesale. JK Rowling is a billionaire who has used her fortune to threaten legal action against multiple critics, forcing them to retract what they wrote about her. That does not sound like someone who is against censorship to me. Or is censorship okay as long as it's not "Woke"?

And even if your description did apply to everyone on this list, so what? A small handful of academics write a letter condemning Trump. How did you spin that into "People that criticize woke censorship don't like Trump." Are you under the impression that the world is comprised of ivory tower academics, and everyone else is a non-entity?

If you were paying attention at all, you'd see the entire anti-woke movement has become a young person's game, and it's completely divorced from censorship. It's more about open, malicious resentment towards anything non-white, now.

Capricorn2481··on The Elizabeth Holmes documentary “You Can See Everything” is deceiving
How did the film let her off the hook?
Capricorn2481··on The Elizabeth Holmes documentary “You Can See Everything” is deceiving
If you're going into a Nathan Fielder documentary expecting a funnel of factual information, you must not know who that is.
Capricorn2481··on Zuckerberg's Meta Takes Down No Kings Instagram During Protest Day
> "Free speech absolutist" was a strawman used against anybody who spoke out against deplatforming as a dangerous idea, which included a lot of liberals

Definitely not on the scale you're implying. People disagreed on who should be deplatformed. People generally didn't call you a "free speech absolutist" if you didn't self identify as such. That was a term people dubbed themselves (and often failed to live up to).

You're making it sound like there's a large group of people that were concerned about deplatforming in general and they were randomly and derogatorily labeled free speech absolutists against their will, to shut the conversation down. Maybe that happened in a few very specific places on the internet, but that's not what the broader conversation was.

Capricorn2481··on Zuckerberg's Meta Takes Down No Kings Instagram During Protest Day
But I wasn't saying "someone should", I was talking about a person with a following saying "go kill this person." I said "direct people to kill someone."

Your distinction that money has to be offered seems completely arbitrary. It implies people only do things for money and are otherwise impervious to influence. You really underestimate the level of stan culture America has.

When you believe that is okay and libel is also okay, by your standards, I can tell the world my neighbor is a pedophile who assaulted me as a child, and ask people to decapitate his whole family. And as long as I don't offer money, that's fine.

Capricorn2481··on Zuckerberg's Meta Takes Down No Kings Instagram During Protest Day
So words aren't violent action in anyway, because you haven't acted on anything. But offering money is violent enough to be legal even though you haven't paid anyone?
Capricorn2481··on Zuckerberg's Meta Takes Down No Kings Instagram During Protest Day
Do I support a ban with no reasoning behind it? Not particularly.
Capricorn2481··on Zuckerberg's Meta Takes Down No Kings Instagram During Protest Day
You probably shouldn't be able to threaten somebody or direct people to kill somebody, so I guess by your definition, I don't believe in free speech.
Capricorn2481··on Zuckerberg's Meta Takes Down No Kings Instagram During Protest Day
It's not weird at all, it's pointing out most free speech absolutists just mean speech for themselves and their friends. Musk will be silent about this.
Capricorn2481··on Steam Client is now faster than Epic's new vibe coded launcher
> All of these require moderation

Kinda funny to say in a conversation including Steam.

Capricorn2481··on Steam Client is now faster than Epic's new vibe coded launcher
It's an AI meme site. They don't do real reporting. That's why their source of how long it takes to open Steam is a single out of context clip with no comparison to anything else
Capricorn2481··on Steam Client is now faster than Epic's new vibe coded launcher
Wow this is really the unthinking man's blog post. This is a known slop news site and HN should not allow it here. I like Steam, but at least Epic actually gave a comparison that we can interpret as two load times on the same PC. These metrics are completely useless without that.

Somebody clipping how long it takes Steam to open on their computer with no other context is pretty meaningless. For all we know, it's running slower on their computer today. There's no before/after, no comparison to Epic. Yet this article just confidently asserted the figure as universal. Moronic.

Capricorn2481··on Passkeys are not a trap
The line of thinking, I guess, is that you shouldn't be forced to buy a specific companies device just to access your own money. And in 10 years time, the companies approved to make devices like this will be DisneyAppleFlix and TeslOpenAI.

That's my guess, at least. I know next to nothing about attestation and passkeys.

Capricorn2481··on Passkeys are not a trap
No, the commenter is letting people use Passkeys. They didn't say anything about not letting other people use it, they just expressed why they don't find them useful.
Capricorn2481··on ICE Planning $100M 'Nightmare' Domestic Spy Program
When the government is shooting citizens in the face, disenfranchising voters, dismantling election committees, and encouraging militant groups to show up to polling places and intimidate vote counters, all while claiming every election they've been a part of was rigged against them, it's natural for people to look outside of voting to make an impact.

I will be voting, like I always have, but I live in a state where that's easy to do. This administration is testing the limits of what people will put up with.

Capricorn2481··on Passkeys are not a trap
> And finally, YOU are not OBLIGED to use it. Let the rest of population use it.

They are.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →