HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Capricorn2481

2,028 karma · joined June 26, 2022

submissionscomments
Capricorn2481··on Passkeys Are Not a Trap
Aren't password managers like Bitwarden essentially zero trust? Even if they hacked the entire database, what would they do with that?
Capricorn2481··on Gemini 4 Argon
The puzzling part is that it can't fall back to a dumb assistant for stuff it could always do. The slow part has not just been interpretation of the task, Gemini is actually slower at doing the task.
Capricorn2481··on Passkeys are not a trap
People who are more tech libertarian don't like when critical aspects of their life requires a smart phone from either Apple or Google. The ability to avoid these companies is becoming increasingly difficult, and attestation is one piece of that puzzle.

I don't think that means throwing out passkeys entirely, but that's why you're seeing a lot of "slippery slope" stuff in here

Capricorn2481··on REA Reverse – Engineer Anything
What do you mean by this? We already have good decompilers. People are not using AI to decompile things, they are using it to interpet decompilation.
Capricorn2481··on REA Reverse – Engineer Anything
> I can't imagine it worse that the current hell hole of SaaS

It literally is SaaS.

> but here we are sending Microsoft billions a month

Who do you think is behind OpenAI funding?

Capricorn2481··on REA Reverse – Engineer Anything
Indie games are really good right now, I don't know what you're on about. There's more of them than ever, there are really creative ones, and there is a wide range of stories and themes.

Your focus on a few games you personally don't like is more exclusionary than the people you criticize. And tying those games to a problem with the very concept of a gamedev community is completely incoherent.

Capricorn2481··on Gemini 4 Argon
It's really puzzling. I was really happy with the original assistant, now it feels slower at literally everything.
Capricorn2481··on Character.ai has initiated voluntary Chapter 11 bankruptcy
> These same people are fine with going to the island, but ask a chatbot about sex and they'll hang you in the square

That's the most understandable read of it, they're giant hypocrites. Sam is beholden to the government, and the U.S. posture is to be as involved in the sex life of its citizens as much as it can, feigning prudishness, while politicians cheat on their pregnant wives with prostitutes.

The fact that we are bringing back abstinence programs when the very people against abortion also disapprove of contraception just shows what a sexually stupid country we are.

Capricorn2481··on Gemini 4 Argon
As an android user, this worked perfectly like 10 years ago.
Capricorn2481··on Software engineers don't get to be Luddites about AI
> US the minimum wage and benefits are some of the highest they’ve ever been.

That's completely expected. You could say this at any point since 1938. But minimum wage is dramatically behind inflation

Capricorn2481··on Leaving Tech
Alright enjoy the phantom arguments
Capricorn2481··on Leaving Tech
> He's not imagining his accomplishments

I didn't suggest that.

Capricorn2481··on Leaving Tech
I don't know this person, so maybe there's a greater embarrassment to him getting rejected based on his previous experience, but this is kind of a puzzling read.

He applied for 36 jobs and he cannot take the rejection? Isn't that an extremely modest amount of applications to already be claiming mental anguish? This seems like a lot of doomerism for not that much effort wasted.

Capricorn2481··on 500B tokens later: Letting AI agents decompile a first-person shooter
That I'm not sure of, because this isn't my area, my info comes directly from youtubers working on this.

But from what I understand, Bevy doesn't come with those things and they did not use something like Havoc, so AI had to translate them as close as it could to match the movement correctly.

To answer your question, it seems like these decompiled game engines are not humongous by themselves. So I wouldn't be surprised if it could be done with Assassin's Creed. But a Youtuber did mention the games they are doing this with (MW2, Skate 3, Minecraft) are ideal starting points.

https://github.com/vladtrc/iw4L

Capricorn2481··on 500B tokens later: Letting AI agents decompile a first-person shooter
A lot of people replicating these games are not replicating the art assets. They are making a new engine that points to the old art assets, as redistributing the art assets could get them in a lot more trouble.
Capricorn2481··on 500B tokens later: Letting AI agents decompile a first-person shooter
> If you make a program with a simple logic, anyone can vibe-copy it in a day. You cannot sell it.

I just don't think this is true. People have had the option to Pirate for many years, but many don't. Balatro was in Love2D, so it was effectively open source. But it was one of the most successful indie games in recent memory. Someone made an entire recreation of the the World of Warcraft back end up to wrath of the lich King, effectively letting you play on custom servers for free, and yet people would rather pay for wow classic

Most people don't want to download a random exe outside of the steam store, and even less people will try reverse engineering themselves. Maybe if one of the modifications is really good, or somebody makes it extremely convenient.

I could see one of these engineers getting a lot of attention in the media, and then maybe a company will step in and insist that anthropic put some restrictions on this type of work. But I don't think Activision is going to see this as humongous threat to their bottom line.

Capricorn2481··on 500B tokens later: Letting AI agents decompile a first-person shooter
It doesn't seem to care. I had it do this for a small game the other day just to try it out. I fed it decompiled Ghidra code. It doesn't seem to have the same restrictions that developing malware or hacking web servers has.

Maybe companies will ask anthropic to crack down on it at some point.

Capricorn2481··on Sorry, I'm in a meeting
That's a good way to put it, most people wouldn't flag it as AI, but it sounds extremely put on.
Capricorn2481··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> it increases every remaining voters relative share equally regardless of which side theyre on

You just restated exactly what I said

> you can't retroactively attribute abstention to the winner simply because they won

Sure you can. If you transfer your share of the vote to everyone else, you are absolutely responsible for the outcome. Being indecisive and giving other people the power to make your own decision for you is a choice. You are participatory in government whether you like it or not. And complaining about the results afterwards while throwing responsibility off yourself is, again, childish.

Capricorn2481··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
> Most likely because sarcasm isn’t really encouraged here.

Sarcasm probably accounts for half of the comments on this site.

Capricorn2481··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
> Claude was instructed never to log in, create accounts, enter personal data, make purchases, or submit anything destructive

Wow great safety protocols.

Capricorn2481··on Anthropic discloses 2 months old fake tip to police among new rogue AI incidents
It's not a rogue entity, they literally just ran Claude with no sandboxing and let it ping websites. They only stopped it because of who it pinged.

This is extra embarrassing. The police departments spam filter caught it before Anthropic did.

Capricorn2481··on Anthropic discloses 2 months old fake tip to police among new rogue AI incidents
I'm sorry, but how can you call it a test suite if it has access to the outside world and is able to submit requests? Sounds like they didn't even bother sandboxing to this time. This is the lamest example of "Rogue AI" I have seen so far.
Capricorn2481··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
Seems completely irrelevant? You were arguing that non-voters had no role in a candidate winning, and now you're pivoting to "but was your vote satisfying." Do you have a point or is this just general misanthropy?

People don't vote because it's perfectly satisfying every time, or they expect to win every time. That's a pretty childish way to look at the democratic process. But if you believe the current president is obviously terrible and you wonder, aloud, how he came to power, revealing that you didn't vote is bound to earn you some groans.

Capricorn2481··on Yes, and
> If whatever you built is good enough for you, then the model was ipso facto sufficient

You literally don't know what it does, though. And it's not a given that QA testing the program will lead to an answer before it leads to a bad outcome. There's an understanding, when we use software we can't read, that some humans looked at it and talked to other humans about how it works. Maybe got calls from customers about bugs, made workarounds.

If I'm just vibecoding stuff for me, and I don't understand any of it, I would not feel safe running it on my computer. And I'm not convinced a lot of people are even going to do this, because non-technical users seem to intuitively understand they are rolling dice in some way.

Capricorn2481··on Yes, and
> You can vibe code without knowing what a function or a variable is

You certainly can, but you can't tell people anything about how it works, if it's safe, whether it spies on people, when it needs to be upgraded, etc. Is there going to be a market for vibe coders who sell services they don't understand? I don't know.

For documenting business logic, code is highly specific and dependable even with non-deterministic compilers. We can look at code and say "Yes, we can connect this to our Stripe account, because we have reviewed what it actually does." We can mock services and test that it works. We can do all of that without reading build output

The same, obviously, cannot be said of LLM prompts. And due to the flaws (and strengths!) of Natural Language, I'm not sure that will change. If someone told me their vibe coded app was safe because they politely asked it to be, I obviously wouldn't use their service. If they told me they asked it to write tests and do mocks, I wouldn't know if it actually did. A pure vibecoder can, at best, reread the prompt they gave, and maybe ask the LLM if there are vulnerabilities, hoping that it finds something.

Maybe we will get to a point where people are feeding 80 page specifications to LLMs as the input, but I'm not sure a person who is capable of writing that level of detail but incapable of learning to read code really exists. I don't think it will get that far. I think people will keep their prompts short and just roll the dice, QA testing.

Capricorn2481··on Platforms' Violent Content Rules Are About to Meet The Pentagon's Firing Squad
> How many people outraged at this have clicked out of a tab of streaming toilet cams?

Excuse me? What is this?

Capricorn2481··on Sorry, I'm in a meeting
Hell no it's not. It's extremely uncanny.

What would "lay people" even be in this scenario? I'd wager most people know what a meeting sounds like.

Capricorn2481··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
Nope. If you're one of four people voting for something, you have 25% of the voting power.

If you decide to abstain, everyone else's vote is now more valuable, at 33.33%. You have given your voting power to other people, it didn't just disappear. And now whatever the outcome, you are participatory in it.

In the U.S. this matters more on a state level, but it still applies.

Capricorn2481··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
> This is not "the US", this is one or two very unpopular politicians whose tenure will be short

Trump has been in office for 6 years. Because 2/3 of America either voted him in or didn't bother showing up. I've been reading people say "he's unpopular" for a decade. But America voted him in again, this time with more power than he's ever had before.

There is no way to decouple his legacy from America anymore. You would have to have a blowout midterm with a Senate supermajority that can roll back everything he's done.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →