HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CapricornNoble

1,420 karma · joined May 28, 2018

Defense industry consultant.

Information management, knowledge management, C4ISR systems, electronic attack, command & control, operations research, modeling & simulation, amphibious warfare, joint operations.

submissionscomments
CapricornNoble··on Hezbollah hand-held radios detonate across Lebanon, sources say
> If they could have executed this without a single civilian injury they definitely would have.

Why do you think that?

Look at what the leadership of the Israel government is saying when they aren't placating western audiences / media outlets:

Cabinet Member May Golan: "Proud of the ruins of Gaza" ( https://www.palestinechronicle.com/i-am-proud-of-the-ruins-o... )

Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich: Starving 2 million Gazans to death is right and moral but the world won't let us ( https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-08-05/ty-article/is... )

Minister of National Security Ben Gvir: We should tear down the Al-Aqsa Mosque and build a synagogue in its place ( https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20240826-israel-minist... )

CapricornNoble··on Hezbollah hand-held radios detonate across Lebanon, sources say
> In November 1947, the UN voted to create two states. Again, the Jews accepted the offer and again, the Arabs rejected it. Only this time, they did so by launching an all-out war. Jordan, Egypt, Iraq, Lebanon and Syria joined the conflict.

You are glossing over a TON of important events between January 1947 and May 1948. Primarily the destruction of Palestinian towns and rampant slaughter at the hands of the Zionist Haganah and Irgun militias. Israeli attempts to memory-hole the Nakhba have failed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deir_Yassin_massacre

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e9To_P8gX9c

^GDF cites many western and Israeli sources in this video

Also, between what you list as the 3rd Rejection (1967) and 4th Rejection (2000), you are omitting that the pro-peace settlement Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin was assassinated......by the Israeli far-right.....who are pretty much the same people now running Israel into the ground on a path of violence.

CapricornNoble··on James Earl Jones has died
For a while I had "Infidel defilers...they shall all drown in lakes of blood." as my ringtone.

"What is steel compared to the hand that wields it?"

Such an accomplished and memorable individual. RIP.

CapricornNoble··on [dead]
That headline made me think Lego made a Concorde model capable of supersonic flight. As if Lego Technic had really upped their game. Needless to say, I am disappointed.
CapricornNoble··on Fiber optic drone control beats any RF jammer
Hmmmm, I'll look for an approximation of a laser-guided 60mm mortar.
CapricornNoble··on Fiber optic drone control beats any RF jammer
Not all GDP's are created equal, though. The US/West has the capital to bury Russia....but isn't mobilizing it the same way it did in WW2. Which of course begs the question of "Why not?", the answer to which is: the US doesn't care as much about the fate of Ukraine as Russia cares about the fate of Ukraine. If we're not in it to win it, then why prolong the death and destruction? Unless the death and destruction was the point all along?

>>>Also the Ukrainians are fighting for survival from the top of the country to the bottom (motivation makes a big difference). For the other side, the view at the top is very different from the view of those going into the fight (often unwillingly) at the bottom.

Do you think the Ukrainians aren't suffering from serious motivation problems? Regular reports of men drowning in freezing rivers trying to cross into Romania. Hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian men in hiding from the roving bands of "mobilizers". [1][2][3] The Russians, by contrast, are mostly there because they are from impoverished regions of Siberia and the enlistment bonuses are gigantic.[4] Russia is basically depopulating its ethnic minorities from Siberia to fuel its war machine. For a country that has its very survival on the line, Ukraine has a TON of men who aren't picking up rifles.

[1] https://www.politico.eu/article/ukraine-faces-an-acute-manpo...

[2] https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/draft-dodgers-are-underm...

[3] https://archive.is/IeGf3

[4] https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/putin-doubles-signing-b...

CapricornNoble··on Fiber optic drone control beats any RF jammer
>>The models do not account for attack drones which kills most Russian soldiers these days.

If you have data that reliably attributes Russian casualties to the weapon systems causing them, I'd love to see it. I know that Twitter and Tiktok are chock full of Ukrainian "drone drop" videos but again that is part of the information operations and shouldn't be taken as an accurate reflection of the battlespace writ large. That said....if they were killing >500 Russians daily with drones, which almost all have recordable video footage, we should be seeing maybe 10x as much footage as is getting released.

One work-around would be to find the most appropriate weapon system that IS in the model and see if it could cover FPV drones. I think QJM aggregates weapons systems but goes down to the squad level, so maybe it accounts for specialized infantry tasks like snipers. Insert a weapon into the model that is a "sniper" but with a 10km effective range. Then run the numbers again. That still ignores the effects of Russian EW but hey...this is an iterative process.

CapricornNoble··on Fiber optic drone control beats any RF jammer
>>>Russian planning for the invasion began around the time of the retreat.

Do you have a source for that? I'd love to read any insight into that process.

My personal, totally unsubstantiated, opinion is that Russia began planning an invasion in 2019 after Poroshenko signed a Constitutional Amendment pledging Ukraine to seek NATO membership, which was followed up by Zelensky promising a NATO referendum the same year.[1][2]

I suspect Putin initiated planning but was unprepared for anything prior to mid-2020....and then invasion planning was derailed by COVID. Forces couldn't be postured until they got that mess under control, and then you also need a big annual exercise as pretext for moving that much combat power into their assembly areas. Hmmmm....I need to go back and take a hard look at the early force flows, as well as Russian rhetoric in response to the 2019 political decisions by Ukraine.

[1] https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-president-signs-constitution...

[2] https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-president-promises-nato-refe...

CapricornNoble··on Fiber optic drone control beats any RF jammer
EDIT: Made a major mistake in my numbers. Reworked the calculations but the substantive part of the argument remains the same.

A San Antonio has ~20,000 square feet of deck space usable for vehicles and cargo. If you stuffed it with TEUs you could fit 125.[0][1] Maximum mass capacity for a TEU is ~21t, let's call it 20t for easy math.[2] So a San Antonio moving containerized beans/bullets/bandaids is only lifting ~2,500 tons per sortie. There are only 12 active San Anontios, and keep in mind roughly 1/3 of any fleet is down for maintenance), so you would need half of all likely available LPDs (4 of 8 available with 4 in yardwork) of the largest (by tonnage, not hull numbers) Navy on the planet.

As for helicopters, you can carry palletized cargo internally on a CH-53 (one of it's few advantages over a CH-47). The K model, with stronger engines (and therefore payload capacity) than the E model, can move ~12t at 200km.[3] Let's just call it 10t at 200km, again for easy math. You would need 1,000 sorties in a day to move 10kt. If you pushed your aircraft to 3 sorties per day (limited by ground crew ability to turn the aircraft), you could do it with ~333 heavy lift helicopters. The US only has ~20 operational CH-53Ks, and ~140 CH-53Es. So no, moving 10kt per day is not a joke, and can't be shuffled by helicopters alone.

It would take both asset classes combined, let's call it 3xLPD for 7.5kt and ~80 CH-53s flying 240 sorties for 2.4kt. That would pretty much be a maximum effort for the Navy-Marine Corps Team, which is inarguably the largest and most capable military power projection and expeditionary logistics force on Earth.

So even in 2024, what they accomplished on D-Day is not a trivial amount of effort.

[0] https://www.navsea.navy.mil/Home/Team-Ships/PEO-Ships/LPD-17...

[1] 20000 / (20ft long x 8ft wide TEU) ~= 125 TEUs worth of deck space, assuming you use ALL deckspace but can't/don't stack them 2 high

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twenty-foot_equivalent_unit

[3] https://www.navair.navy.mil/product/CH-53K-King-Stallion

CapricornNoble··on Fiber optic drone control beats any RF jammer
I recommend reading Wages of Destruction: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wages_of_Destruction

Part of the problem is incorrect assessments of the balance of power, combined with stubbornness. Both the Germans and the Japanese assessed that their martial spirit would enable them to overcome their industrially-superior adversaries. Both were wrong. Also militaries the world over have a culture of stoicism under conditions of adversity. At the tactical level it sometimes means you can turn around what appears to be an unwinnable situation. I'd have to dig to see where this has reliably worked at the strategic level. My initial thought is "it doesn't, but military officers who have spent their entire adult lives inculcated to act otherwise will never acknowledge that".

Look at some of the ridiculous propaganda that was written at the start of Ukraine's 2023 summer offensive: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/06/09/british-made-tan...

There's been interviews where Ukrainian troops said "we thought the Russians would just run away after the first day of seeing our Leopards".

Both sides in this conflict have underestimated each other in different ways, but industrial attritional warfare is the great equalizer: it doesn't matter what men THINK will lead to victory if enough steel is thrown in the other guy's direction to remove all subjectivity.

CapricornNoble··on Fiber optic drone control beats any RF jammer
Despite saying that I'm arguing in bad faith, you actually have the only substantive response to my post. My interpretation of your comments is that either:

1. I am incorrectly interpreting the models because I am assuming aggregate/averaged rates of advance across a very large (~1000km) frontage. Or:

2. The models are incorrect if they expect rates of advance averaged across such a large front to produce reliably realistic results.

The task, then, is for me to dig back through the specifics of the models (I've got Dupuy's books and a couple of publications and related DoD-internal wargaming rulesets based on Relative Combat Power Analysis) to see if they articulate the scale at which they break down. I do recall reading that QJM was used to estimate the outcome of Desert Storm and produced surprisingly accurate results for that campaign. Given that, I don't think it's unreasonable to apply the model to the current stage of the Ukrainian conflict.

In particular you seem critical of the values I suggested for the "rate of advance" variable. I suspect that even if you dropped that value to 0.1km/day or even 0.....the models would still suggest a highly skewed rate of Ukrainian losses due to the lopsided-balance of fires assets in Russia's favor. The point is to get people to do the math themselves, and to get them thinking about the second and third order effects of a country with 1/3 of its attackers manpower pool losing men at a greater-than-equal rate.

As an aside, it's weird to me that a few paragraphs is derided as a "Wall of Text" but I guess it is to a generation who's baseline of social media engagement is mobile phones and Twitter. I developed my habits of internet discourse on places like bbs.stardestroyer.net in the late 90s: everyone was on a desktop, and everyone was expected to write long-form explanations for their positions, preferably with references.

This is how I write many of my posts on HN, twenty years later.

CapricornNoble··on Fiber optic drone control beats any RF jammer
>>This is by any measure not a big concentration of ships, armor, or anything. D-day landings were impressive in 1944 but today these won't be big at all.

The US pushed ~28,000 tons of supplies ashore in the first 5 days of Overlord. Eight days later it had grown to 117,000 tons. [1] Can you show us your loading and sealift plan for delivering 10,000 tons per day of supplies, sustained, in a partially-contested airspace, especially over a beach? We're not talking about unloading a Maersk Triple E-class [2] at a container port in peacetime.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_logistics_in_the_Norm...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triple_E-class_container_ship

CapricornNoble··on Tell HN: your next idea should focus on aged care
I moved to Japan 13 years ago. My mother developed early-onset Alzheimer's in 2021, and I'm her only child. I relocated her to Japan. It has been immensely stressful but I know she's getting better care and this also avoided the US healthcare system completely bankrupting our family and robbing us of our chance to build multi-generational wealth.

But living in a country with an outsized elderly population/terrible demographics, I can clearly see how the problem will eventually cripple most economies without significant technological augmentation. Large multi-generational families living in very close proximity at least provides for essentially unpaid labor who can share the burdens to prevent caregiver burnout.

CapricornNoble··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
Does this count?

https://www.amazon.com/Unrestricted-Warfare-Chinese-Wang-Xia...

How does someone do data collection on how the Chinese government weaponizes a social media platform? That would almost certainly involve Tailored Access Operations (or whatever they are calling offensive cyber warfare these days), not only of questionable legality but definitely compromising the sort of Tactics/Techniques/Procedures you REALLY don't want made public.

CapricornNoble··on Show HN: Real-time image generation with SDXL Lightning
I got some unattractive results easily:

https://fastsdxl.ai/share/dfxtkr3r0w3z

https://fastsdxl.ai/share/e70xgiudn8j0

But when I switched the prompt to include "portrait", yeah it produces women who are too attractive, like an actress wearing makeup to appear ugly for a role.

CapricornNoble··on Alexei Navalny has died
What was defensive about NATO's bombing campaign against Libya?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Unified_Protector

https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/news_71867.htm?mode=pre...

On Thursday morning at 0600 GMT, NATO took sole command of international air operations over Libya.

CapricornNoble··on Alexei Navalny has died
>> as every attacker has a higher loss than the defender

On what are you basing this assertion? I'm going to assume it's a flawed understanding of the oft-cited "3:1 rule", which a) isn't a rule, but a planning guideline b) never referred to casualty ratios, but to force ratios suggested for a successful attack.

>> Personally I have great hopes that an outsider like Kasparov could become President of Russia once Russia is defeated.

What influence does Kasparov have with Russia's security establishment? In other words, why would any of the men who actually wield power in the country support him?

CapricornNoble··on U.S. army drops requirement for high school diploma (2022)
> Also there is an increased chance Putin might order be mass mobilization after he wins the elections in May.

Increased but still highly unlikely. The Russian military inducts ~260,000 men annually just from conscription. Now that the Ukrainians have exhausted their supplies of ammunition, manpower, and funding, it's unlikely that the AFU can sustain its ability to attrite Russian manpower faster than it can be replaced.

CapricornNoble··on ICJ orders Israel to prevent genocide in Gaza, stops short of ordering ceasefire
Abortion is probably one of the leading causes of the demographic destruction (and by extension, destruction of political influence) of the black American community.

https://azcapitoltimes.com/news/2020/02/25/abortion-the-over...

Not only religious fanatics oppose it in its current form in America.

CapricornNoble··on ICJ orders Israel to prevent genocide in Gaza, stops short of ordering ceasefire
>israel in the same category as russia?

The Russian government kills unarmed civilians outside of Russia. Usually Russians, but not always. The Israeli government also kills unarmed civilians outside of Israel. So yes, in the category of "nation states that covertly murder people globally with negligible consequences", both are present. Hell even India is in that group lately...

CapricornNoble··on ICJ orders Israel to prevent genocide in Gaza, stops short of ordering ceasefire
> The problem is: it doesn't matter.

Clearly it does matter to significant portions of the people who either directly experienced it or are the children of those who did. I would argue it was a major driving factor for violent opposition to the Israeli state, now since replaced by Israel's current actions (current as in last 30 years) as the impetus.

> No matter what Israel did in Palestine, Arab Jewish people had no culpability.

I'm glad this discussion has forced me to do some research. I actually wonder how many of the early immigrant waves were even "expelled" in the first place, rather than moving of their own volition. Here's the example from Yemen: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Magic_Carpet_(Yemen)...

And in Iraq's case: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Ezra_and_Nehemiah "Like most Arab League states, Iraq initially forbade the emigration of its Jews after the 1948 war on the grounds that allowing them to go to Israel would strengthen that state; however, by 1949 the Iraqi Zionist underground was smuggling Jews out of the country to Iran at about a rate of 1,000 a month, from where they were flown to Israel.[23] At the time, the British believed that the Zionist underground was agitating in Iraq in order to assist US fund-raising and to "offset the bad impression caused by the Jewish attitudes to Arab refugees".

CapricornNoble··on ICJ orders Israel to prevent genocide in Gaza, stops short of ordering ceasefire
> How does something occurring in Palestine justify this?

The real question is, would that have happened if it were not for:

-demonstrated brutality against the Palestinian population

-explicit creation of the Israeli state tied to a particular ethno-religious identity

If there had been no violence, and if Israel had just been a newly-independent country with the creation led by but not defined by the culture of the Jewish immigrants, would there have been a purge across the region? Personally I think not.

I'm trying to highlight that there is significantly more nuance to the creation of Israel beyond "we just showed up one day and everyone was mean to us for no reason" which, IMO, has surprisingly crept into numerous comments even on HN where you would expect such an educated demographic to know better...

CapricornNoble··on ICJ orders Israel to prevent genocide in Gaza, stops short of ordering ceasefire
> Problem is no one will take refugees from Gaza even temporarily. If countries would the death toll would be much less.

Why should other countries bear the burden and costs for a problem that is overwhelmingly a consequence of the actions of the Israeli state in general, and the current far-right government in particular?

CapricornNoble··on ICJ orders Israel to prevent genocide in Gaza, stops short of ordering ceasefire
> you want a terrorist nation having a full functioning military and access to nuclear weapons? really?

we already have several: US, Russia, China....and Israel.

https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2022/01/20/the-murde...

Murder/attempted murder of adversary citizens in neutral territory is just one of a legion of examples of behavior the West constantly criticizes Russia for, by the way.

CapricornNoble··on ICJ orders Israel to prevent genocide in Gaza, stops short of ordering ceasefire
> Hundreds of thousands of civilians have been killed in Ukraine.

Can you link some credible references for this?

The OHCHR, as of October 2023, listed 10,000 killed and 18,000 wounded.

https://reliefweb.int/report/ukraine/ukraine-civilian-casual...

For that estimate to be off by AT LEAST an order of magnitude as you are claiming requires quite a bit of evidence.

CapricornNoble··on Knockoff Iranian drone sold on Alibaba was meant for war, documents show
SOME parts of Reddit serve as useful aggregators for news that would otherwise be scattered across a dozen Telegram chat groups and 50 Twitter accounts. It's just important to recognize when you are in a DEEEP (and therefore not particularly useful) echo chamber. Admittedly, that can be difficult on Reddit where most the sub-Reddits that give an air of neutral impartiality are some of the most heavily censored and astroturfed.
CapricornNoble··on Five richest men double their money as poorest get poorer
>the question is whether society should strive to prevent individuals from acquiring great power over the masses

Whatever people or person has the authority to prevent individuals from acquiring great power over the masses.....has great power over the masses.

The power-hungry don't like being told they can't do something. Another possible outcome is the uber-rich start converting their wealth into men-at-arms to secure their power. Every time my wealth ticks over from $998M to $999M I burn $1M secretly acquiring the loyalty of violent men. Eventually my wealth goes from $999M to $1B and the Equality Enforcers pay me a visit....only to find out the hard way that they didn't bring enough bannermen. I don't think its particularly far-fetched to conclude that eventually men with near-limitless resources and near-limitless egos will resort to armed conflict before they allow some paper-pushing bureaucrats to put them back in a box. Maybe that's not the character of Buffet or even Musk, but on a long enough timeline I consider it a certainty. It's better for everyone that they collect yachts and "atmosphere models"( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jSvvvrKhx0w ) instead.

> For example, poor people can't afford to buy a Tesla, so what has Musk done to raise the standard of living for the poor?

I think in a system as complex as the world economy it's difficult to pinpoint this with any certainty. MAYBE one could argue that Tesla forced a paradigm shift onto other automakers and that the entire industry dragging its feet to produce EVs is a net quality of life improvement for the civilization in the aggregate due to reduced emissions?

Why are we judging the wealthy by their utility to the poor anyway? Belle Delphine isn't a billionaire, but at one point she was making >$1 million per month shaking her butt on a webcam and selling used bathwater to lonely males. Are we going to judge EVERYONE by how they've raised the standard of living for the poor? Where is the cutoff point? $1B net worth? $1M annual income? The market principles which have elevated Elon Musk to the top of his industry have similarly elevated Belle Delphine to the top of hers, with massively disproportionate earnings compared to the bottom-tier OnlyFans content creators. Do we have enough moral outrage for them both? Why or why not? Who has the authority to judge?

> how much personal freedom would you trade just to have more material goods?

I'm a military reservist who is considering returning to full Active Duty for several years so trading away my personal freedom is.....quite normal to me. That said....I have pretty modest material desires, and am mostly trading my personal freedom for.....wealth accumulation! If you're going to own something, own something that other people need, and that generates revenue.

CapricornNoble··on Five richest men double their money as poorest get poorer
> How do you think many people become billionaires?

Pareto Principle, offering some of the best market options on a planet with 8 billion people? Let's say I make a product that is 10% better than yours (maybe I burned more midnights engineering it, maybe I just had a radical trip on some DMT that gave me special insight, whatever). Let's say my product costs me $.90 to make, yours only costs $0.75 to make. We both sell at $1.00.....but 90% of the 8 billion people buy my obviously better product, and only 10% buy yours (maybe they hate something about me personally, or maybe my marketing simply didn't reach or convert them). I make $0.10 * (0.9 * 8B) = $720M. You make $0.25 * (0.1 * 8B) = $200M. I'm already over 3x richer than you, and ALMOST as close to billionaire as you are close to being impoverished ($0 net worth in this scenario). What part of my competition wasn't fair? What workers were mistreated?

THAT SAID.....I don't disagree that many wealthy families are scummy thieves with a sheen of respectability (like the Sacklers, for example).....just, I prefer that we not instantly reach for that excuse and dismiss the entire concept of extreme wealth accumulation as "well OBVIOUSLY they've got to have done something evil, there is no other explanation, so let's collectively punish their entire class" which is how most of these conversations conclude.

CapricornNoble··on Five richest men double their money as poorest get poorer
> You can't sell your product if there's nobody that can buy it.

Our current model is capitalists get rich selling piles of cheap stuff to the labor class.

I think the future might be petite bourgeoisie selling high-end, long-lasting products to each other. Picture the guy who has his own AI company selling AI to the guy who has a robot company, who sells robots to the guy who owns a coachbuilder such as [1] or [2], who sells cars to the AI guy and the robot guy. Then the car guy buys a watch from a watchsmith in Switzerland. Watch guy doesn't have any robots but maybe he uses AI to help him design new watches, which he builds by hand himself. Then all four of these guys eat by buying meat from a guy who uses robotic cattlehands to coral his herd of free-range grass-fed bison or something. Each of these five people work at the companies they own. They have no laborers underneath them that aren't AI or robots. They are just exchanging a small amount of high-value goods and services between each other.

The HUMAN labor class is gonna die or be subsidized just enough to keep from revolting.

[1] https://singervehicledesign.com/

[2]https://www.fj.co/

CapricornNoble··on Five richest men double their money as poorest get poorer
>> And that's what the ultra-wealthy do. They exercise power over other people.

Arguably, there is always SOMEONE doing this, even without ultra-wealth. Perhaps the argument could be made that the ultra-wealthy are the least malign manifestation of power-hungry sociopathic megalomania?

It's not like Stalin in the 30s or Mao in the 50s were using wealth to buy people, for example. But they sure as Hell led to really negative outcomes for the people they influenced. Far more negative than any damage that Musk/Bezos/Buffet/et al are doing now, IMO.

← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →