HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CathedralBorrow

623 karma · joined March 28, 2019

submissionscomments
CathedralBorrow··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
Just genuine curiosity because I like this site and like how active you are in constructively moderating it: Why not simply ban people who have crossed the line this badly for this long? It certainly doesn't seem heavy handed or unfair.
CathedralBorrow··on Chat Bubble Blindness
Do you do a bit of research on your purchase before heading into a store? If yes, then that might be a big reason.
CathedralBorrow··on Show HN: Unscreen – Automatically remove video backgrounds with ML
My rule of thumb for advice on the Internet is that if it is mostly in the form of statements like "You need to do X, Y and Z" and has very few questions intended to dig deeper into the nuances of the product and business model... then it's not generally worth much at face value.

Essentially: The less information a person needs to dish out advice, the less value I am going to place on their advice.

CathedralBorrow··on Facebook says Apple’s iOS 14 changes could hurt its ad targeting
You left out the "whatever it may be" part.
CathedralBorrow··on Facebook says Apple’s iOS 14 changes could hurt its ad targeting
> So the ends justify the means, whatever that may be?

Do you honestly believe that is a fair summary of their words?

CathedralBorrow··on Hackers post fake stories on real news sites 'to discredit NATO'
Who is receiving those NATO payments?
CathedralBorrow··on Show HN: Deck for Reddit – A Reddit client optimized for desktop
Out of curiousity, where on Earth can you find "an unbiased neutral source of information about politics"?
CathedralBorrow··on 11M households could be evicted over the next four months
> It's not driven by the actual facts of the virus, there's something else at work.

What do you think that might be?

CathedralBorrow··on Sledding athletes are taking their lives
Why are you wasting all these words on something that is not at the top of your sorted list? What is the most important problem in the world?
CathedralBorrow··on Text-Only Social Network
> and Twitter isn't something most people enjoy being on but I think it's what people get on to seem/feel important

This feels like a "everyone is mostly like me" fallacy. A whole ton of people use Twitter because they actually enjoy it.

CathedralBorrow··on GitHub was down
I think you're right in that blaming Microsoft without any evidence is probably a mistake, but I also think "until the official statement, it isn't Microsoft failure" is putting a bit too much faith in corporate PR as a source of truth.
CathedralBorrow··on Can Our Ballots Be Both Secret and Secure?
The answers to all these questions are known and public when I vote. I know who counts them, where the figures are sent and who verifies them.
CathedralBorrow··on Can Our Ballots Be Both Secret and Secure?
No they can not. I put my ballot in a locked box filled with other ballots. It's not like I hand my ballot to a person and ask them to please record my vote.
CathedralBorrow··on Can Our Ballots Be Both Secret and Secure?
Just to be clear, is it your position that voter disenfranchisement does not happen in the United States?
CathedralBorrow··on Blog Anonymously
I'm still confused. I am completely free to choose whether or not to do business with them, but I am not allowed to tell them about my choice? Or am I not allowed to speak about it at all, regardless of who listens?
CathedralBorrow··on Blog Anonymously
I'm not dismayed at all, and would appreciate it if you could refrain from painting pictures of what you think my state of mind might be. Thanks.

Are you saying that I am breaking the law by telling a company that I will not do business with them as long as they employ some person? Just to head off future misunderstandings on my part I'd like to get this clear first.

CathedralBorrow··on Blog Anonymously
Ok I'm confused so can you please help me? My example was absolutely a "threat" in the sense that yes, I in that example would be serious about voicing my opinion and my intention to not voluntarily do business with that imaginary corporation while they employed that person. I would be "threatening" to do something which is entirely my freedom to do; to vote with my wallet.

But if I understand you correctly, this would be going outside my freedom of speech. Which implies that I do not have the choice to not do business with them. As in, I am obligated to purchase goods and services from them.

I am clearly misunderstanding this because that can't be right. Where did I go off track?

CathedralBorrow··on Blog Anonymously
I agree with everything you said. Can you comment on my question though?
CathedralBorrow··on Blog Anonymously
Sure, is my choice to boycott a company also an act of oppression?
CathedralBorrow··on Blog Anonymously
If I inform a corporation that I will not do business with them while a person is in their employment, am I oppressing that person or am I using my freedom of speech?
CathedralBorrow··on U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation
Did anyone ask you to feel guilt or to apologize?
CathedralBorrow··on U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation
What is this obsession with some people in thinking this is all about making them "feel bad"? Feels like such a self-centered point of view.
CathedralBorrow··on U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation
> I would not blame a child for their father's sins.

I think you are making this too much about personal blame, and sin, and ego. Your analogy falls apart right out of the gate because the premise is off. It's not about placing blame or making you feel bad.

CathedralBorrow··on The saddest “Just Ship It” story
> If you've used rsync/robocopy you might think it is ridiculous this product even exists

I mean, only if you also have no understanding of other people having different backgrounds, skillsets and experiences?

CathedralBorrow··on The saddest “Just Ship It” story
> "just ship it" is just as dumb as "never ship it". Why are people so prone to these oversimplified polarazations?

Are they precisely equally dumb according to measurements, or did you oversimplify to make a point?

CathedralBorrow··on Websites that look like desktop GUIs
I don't think there's need to ascribe some "Want to use X like it's Y" intentions to people. The tagline "simplifies your development workflow" certainly doesn't make me think of Dropbox at least.

Maybe it's mostly aimed at people who like the features of GitHub Desktop?

CathedralBorrow··on Dwarf Fortress Creator Explains Its Complexity and Origins [video]
For me, that title was recently taken over by My Summer Car.
CathedralBorrow··on You can't tell people anything (2004)
Are you thinking of income tax as the only tax that exist?
CathedralBorrow··on You can't tell people anything (2004)
Nothing wrong with that, I don't think there's a fixed list of "Learnable things" attached to any piece of content. It's mostly about the interpretation.
CathedralBorrow··on You can't tell people anything (2004)
> So if a kid doesn't watch enough superhero/disney/scifi movies they won't understand racism...?

There is quite a massive distance between "You can take some lessons about racism from this content" and "If you do not consume this particular content you will not understand racism."

← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →