HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CathedralBorrow

623 karma · joined March 28, 2019

submissionscomments
CathedralBorrow··on Tell HN: Triplebyte reverses, emails apology
Wait, I thought we were talking about kindness after they pulled the plug and backtracked on everything.

How am I being taken advantage of if I read that letter and think "Well, good for them to finally realize things and take the right steps"? And I hope you're not speaking for everyone when you talk about good faith.

CathedralBorrow··on A major reason for departures at Slack was “remote work request rejected”
Fair enough, thanks for clarifying.

Now, when you say that you read their comment that way... did you truly read it that way? Do you actually believe that brown9-2's position is that everything that is said in marketing messages is true?

CathedralBorrow··on Tell HN: Triplebyte reverses, emails apology
What's the penalty for looking too kindly at somebody in this context?
CathedralBorrow··on A major reason for departures at Slack was “remote work request rejected”
What exactly is true? That remote working is always better in all conceivable scenarios and that anyone saying anything else is stupid and wasteful and probably smells too?
CathedralBorrow··on A major reason for departures at Slack was “remote work request rejected”
This seems weirdly combative and aggressive. The original question was "I don't know why people think Slack is a remote working tool" so I'd say a legitimate answer would be "Well they say so themselves in their marketing copy, maybe that's why people think they are?"
CathedralBorrow··on A major reason for departures at Slack was “remote work request rejected”
> Obviously we won't decide who is "right" here in a forum.

Is there any debate to be had about that anyway? From what you've written here, you are right and everyone who thinks otherwise clearly hasn't thought things through well enough.

CathedralBorrow··on Unable to deal with Chrome Extension Team, Kozmos is shutting down
Effort, time, unlearning workflows and re-learning them in Firefox, etc. Switching costs would probably have been a better term to use.
CathedralBorrow··on Unable to deal with Chrome Extension Team, Kozmos is shutting down
Are you including the change cost here, which will be many times higher for most of the population vs. HN? Even if I thought that Firefox was a better choice, I'd recommend to my friends and family to keep using whatever they are using unless they have to switch for some reason.
CathedralBorrow··on Unable to deal with Chrome Extension Team, Kozmos is shutting down
What was the "other side" of leftpad? As far as I remember, the broken system wrought havoc, not the developer who chose to withdraw his modules. I don't think the developer's reasons are much relevant when discussing how reliable their word is.
CathedralBorrow··on She Gets Calls and Texts Meant for Elon Musk. Some Are Pretty Weird
In what world is this human interest piece an attack on Elon Musk? Is any non-fawning coverage a hit piece?
CathedralBorrow··on Students are failing AP tests because the College Board can’t handle HEIC images
Yeah, what a weird "solution" to be okay with. Wonder if they'd be as okay with repeating a workday because their hours weren't logged due to a system error.
CathedralBorrow··on Students are failing AP tests because the College Board can’t handle HEIC images
Everyone can look at a pen stroke and identify the color.

Can you say the same about a photo and identifying the file format?

CathedralBorrow··on Students are failing AP tests because the College Board can’t handle HEIC images
> Ok, first of, why should I (as an institution) care about the people unable to fulfil the conditions of my test?

Maybe you (as an institution) care about all your students?

CathedralBorrow··on Scott Forstall tells story about Steve Jobs, Microsoft, and a dead fish [video]
If it doesn't matter if you miss a hire or not, why would you be going through the effort of buying a large fancy salmon and shipping it to the candidate? You could just not do that and not care about the ones you miss since they don't matter.
CathedralBorrow··on Spotify signs ‘The Joe Rogan Experience’ to an exclusive multi-year deal
If all publishers, persons and organizations are censoring everyone who is not allowed to use their platform/property to express whatever they want... then it seems to dilute the meaning of censorship into nothingness.
CathedralBorrow··on Spotify signs ‘The Joe Rogan Experience’ to an exclusive multi-year deal
> what I am trying to say is that if someone believe he was transphobic, then it would be enriching of the conversation if they took care not to use the fact that he is making that distinction as an argument for that statement

Yes, I think I'm definitely not understanding you correctly. It seems like you're objectively stating that conversation would be of higher quality if people would construct arguments more like you do. But what if people do want to use that argument for their statement that they find JR transphobic?

"Don't use this argument; it's wrong and devalues the conversation" reads very strange to me when discussing something as fuzzy as "does this person exhibit transphobic behaviour?"

CathedralBorrow··on Spotify signs ‘The Joe Rogan Experience’ to an exclusive multi-year deal
> Agree or disagree with that I believe it is (still) important to be able to express that concept without being transphobic

I fully agree with this. But if he is viewed as transphobic then surely that falls flat?

CathedralBorrow··on Spotify signs ‘The Joe Rogan Experience’ to an exclusive multi-year deal
Where are you drawing that line, I'm really curious. Can you put me live on Zoom in your house so I can talk about things I like? If not, are you participating in censorship?
CathedralBorrow··on Spotify signs ‘The Joe Rogan Experience’ to an exclusive multi-year deal
I dont know, I'd say the front line of the battle is things like transgender persons having 9x the suicide rate of the general population. Is that a war that looks won to you?
CathedralBorrow··on Spotify signs ‘The Joe Rogan Experience’ to an exclusive multi-year deal
> And we all end up worse off.

That's a bold and simple claim about complex interactions. Can you support this position at all or is it more like a conviction you have?

CathedralBorrow··on Nearly 40% of Icelanders are using a Covid app, but it hasn’t helped much
I respectfully disagree that "we should" do what you would prefer to happen. Contact tracing is not a privacy issue here.
CathedralBorrow··on Nearly 40% of Icelanders are using a Covid app, but it hasn’t helped much
Iceland does not have the Patriot Act or anything like it, so I'm not sure how that's relevant here.
CathedralBorrow··on Nearly 40% of Icelanders are using a Covid app, but it hasn’t helped much
Ah, thanks.

Iceland is whatever you call the opposite of that. Grandma very rarely lives with her family, she lives by herself -- hopefully with her partner -- until she is unable to and then moves into a system that ranges from living-alone-with-help to typical old folks homes, and will gradually move towards more care as her health allows.

So that's wrong in the original comment, but the rest seemed pretty spot on to me, and doesn't change the argument much I think.

CathedralBorrow··on Bad Washington Post Story on Apple and Google's Exposure Notification Project
To be fair, the app was released at the tail end of the infection curve so there wasn't much pandemic to affect anymore. Could be useless, but I don't think this was a good test to generalize with.
CathedralBorrow··on Nearly 40% of Icelanders are using a Covid app, but it hasn’t helped much
Iceland has done quite fine through this with contact tracing as one of the main tools in the toolbox. I think a blanket statement of "not needed" needs something more behind it.
CathedralBorrow··on Nearly 40% of Icelanders are using a Covid app, but it hasn’t helped much
> multi-generational homes

Can you clarify what you mean by this?

CathedralBorrow··on Factors associated with Covid-19 deaths in records of 17M adult NHS patients
I don't think this kind of comment is obligatory, really.
CathedralBorrow··on 92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people
Couldn't these two situations be viewed as the same thing? You can hide information just as well by surrounding it with misinformation.
CathedralBorrow··on 92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people
> Dicks are easy to ignore

Deleted comments are also easy to ignore. Deleting your comments regularly might be construed as a dick move by some people, but as you say, dicks are easy to ignore.

CathedralBorrow··on 92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people
I regularly run an extension that first edits, then deletes all my comments.
← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →