HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ChaitanyaSai

1,227 karma · joined January 27, 2008

We run a microschool in Mumbai. https://playbook.comini.in/ Along the way,we ended up building a microschoolOS to help run everything. We are, essentially, an AI-native microschool where the AI is invisible.

We wrote a book explaining Consciousness - Journey of the Mind: How Thinking Emerged from Chaos https://www.amazon.com/Journey-Mind-Thinking-Emerged-Chaos/dp/1324006579/

I write here https://saigaddam.medium.com/ and here https://blog.comini.in/

sai email comini dot in

submissionscomments
ChaitanyaSai··on DARPA, U.S. Air Force fly AI-controlled F-16
> self-healing self-organizing system that has its own logic

Great way to to put and it seems to be the gradient for all biological intelligence. Compete until you figure out cooperation and communication. Communication glues together intelligent entities into systems where the systems take on a life and agency of their own. In our case it was language gluing us together first into tribes, shared stories into culture.

You might enjoy our book https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/60500189-journey-of-t...

Also, nostrademons, your "name" is one of the few I recognize here on HN as there's usually something interesting and you weave it into words so well. Thanks!

ChaitanyaSai··on Launch HN: Bloomy (YC S26) – AI-powered mastery learning for K-12
Will reach out, thanks!
ChaitanyaSai··on Terrence Tao's ChatGPT Conversation about the Jacobian Conjecture Counterexample
That's interesting, thanks for sharing. Can you please share a specific example of what you describe? Does the student stop asking why after a while?
ChaitanyaSai··on Terence Tao's ChatGPT conversation about the Jacobian Conjecture counterexample
I don't understand any of the math here, but I had two thoughts. Soon we'll have explainer agents that translate these according to my level so I can, with effort and interest, follow along and stretch my understanding boundary bit by bit.

Two, at some point AIs will be able to use other context like the fact that this is Terrence Tao and not your average Joe and change how it answers, either in tone or structure.

ChaitanyaSai··on Launch HN: Bloomy (YC S26) – AI-powered mastery learning for K-12
Congratulations on the launch!

How do you solve for "meaning?" Is there some implicit expectation that kids arrive with motivation to discover meaning, or some extrinsic rewards?

As AI essentially commoditizes the mechanical aspects of learning, this is the question we find ourselves asking.

I would like to share our journey running a microschool (where our kids go, along with 40 others now) and how we use AI and what we think about its role.

Some useful context, because this really has informed our approach. I am an engineer turned neuroscientist and the co-author of a popular nonfiction book on the mind (and I share this here because the hard effortful self-driven work of crafting this book taught me more about the mind than anything else in my PhD or later). This work, done during the pandemic when learning was coming online, was what pushed us into setting up the school and gave us the courage to work on it from first principles and not rely on any off-the-shelf alternative pedagogy (montessori, waldorf etc). We looked at (and continue to work on) the full-stack of philosophy, pedagogy, process, practice. So the "what should they learn" is also met with "why should they learn this" and also "how should they be learning this"

The *single biggest* learning for us, which we are now able to articulate clearly, is that schools are set up to fail because there is a well-intentioned but misguided focus on measurement (what are they learning). This gravitational pull results in a focus on mechanics (the most easily measurable thing; long division, periodic tables). This results in a narrow focus on concepts (what David Perkins terms elementitis). Most importantly, what gets left out is meaning. Why should I care about this? With a well-intentioned curriculum and an administration pipette we basically leach out agency and meaning.

So we try to solve for meaning. Our biggest worry with AI is that it focuses entirely on mechanics, with very little meaning. Adults and kids are learning to discount AI-content as automated and inauthentic. We derive meaning from connection. AI can help with the mechanics, but only when meaning has been established. Without this clear-eyed understanding and buy-in we basically have chromebooks all over again, which flattened learning to 2D screens and accomplished nothing (if you look at literacy numeracy scores)

Chatbots are great if you start with meaning and motivation. I already care about the why, so I will socratically find my way to the how and what. But if we do not care about it, which really is the biggest malaise (why should a child who has not yet explored the world or literature they like care about foreshadowing or plot mountains?) Sure, the AI could make it easier, but the kids still need to care?

Wrote about our meaning > motivation > mechanics > measurement revelation and the usual unfortunate inversion here https://blog.comini.in/p/schooling-has-a-meaning-crisis-para...

We need many more people approaching education with ideas and experiments, so thank you and good luck!

ChaitanyaSai··on Who's afraid of Chinese models?
The thing I do not understand here because it seems obvious: AI will be a commodity market and you simply cannot have a large PE multiple. So the valuations imagine a global commodity monopoly or duopoly coupled with the increased intelligence still disallowing other suppliers from becoming competitive? Without any network effects to help?
ChaitanyaSai··on Has AI already killed self-help nonfiction books?
One man's filler is another's phatic communication (if done well and not to pad)
ChaitanyaSai··on A Mathematician's Lament (2002) [pdf]
Thanks for sharing this. So lovely to hear and hope they find their joy and meaning in whatever they do!
ChaitanyaSai··on I'm skeptical about efforts to revolutionize schooling
Thanks, I have. And it resonated a whole lot! He was working within a very entrenched system. Systems have a way of achieving equilibria and then all the parts trying their best to maintain it (unions, lobbies etc) School is a practical necessity and there's a lot of good that's possible. It's easier to start outside of the system, but also consequently much harder to scale unless we build tools to help systems to stabilize.
ChaitanyaSai··on I'm skeptical about efforts to revolutionize schooling
Thanks!
ChaitanyaSai··on I'm skeptical about efforts to revolutionize schooling
Schooling has been trying for ever to institutionalize and standardize learning without really understanding what learning is. In that absence, we've focused on learning proxies, which are tests. And tests resulted in a focus on mechanics. Meaning was and is an intangible so it got leached out. Everything school does starts at the wrong end of meaning > motiviation > mechanics > measurement.

It is possible to fix school. It needs understanding learning, and also being willing to revisit learning design at every level. How to bring meaning in?

Without meaning you could have all your fancy chromebooks and chatbots but you won't move the needle (as we are seeing)

We are actually trying to change schooling (but with a tiny experiment, knowing that scaling does not happen without changes and cultural context)

https://blog.comini.in/p/schooling-has-a-meaning-crisis-para...

ChaitanyaSai··on A Mathematician's Lament (2002) [pdf]
Thanks! How early did you take them out of school? How old are they now.
ChaitanyaSai··on A Mathematician's Lament (2002) [pdf]
I run a microschool and also teach maths there. I love this essay, and book, but by focusing on maths as art, it focuses on only one aspect of meaning. The larger issue with the way maths is taught, and especially maths, is that it is all mechanics. Now for a certain set of students, those mechanics are incredibly beautiful. Prime numbers have a seduction to them! A few more can be introduced to this beauty and aesthetics, but many are still not into it, and that's entirely okay. What's needed for kids to see and start accepting it is meaning. And meaning comes from connection to the real world. This is why kids who are unschooled but work in shops become great at arithmetic. It's part of their daily web of life. No amount of sanitized exposure to abstract aspects, however aesthetically dressed up will help most. The mind needs to answer "why do i need to care about this" to be open to learning. And this is not something that can come with instruction. It is lived experience, culture. To fix maths education,and any education, you need to bring in meaning before mechanics. Unfortunately the curriculum, assesment, and therefore teaching inevitably end up with focus on the mechanics, which is the wrong end. It is meaning > motivation > mechanics > measurement

School inverts this. And that's a tragedy.

Wrote about it here. https://blog.comini.in/p/schooling-has-a-meaning-crisis-para...

ChaitanyaSai··on Schooling Has a Meaning Crisis
Agree, and it's hard to think about fixing education in isolation. But we've got to start somewhere to fix the meaning void. Easiest first step is to not take play away.
ChaitanyaSai··on Show HN: Daily word puzzle game based on polysemy
nice :) I cheated though by pasting it in because I couldn't bear the thought of having to wait for a day. Didn't even wait till the 4th try.
ChaitanyaSai··on Ask HN: Share concrete examples of benefits from AI usage
Lovely site! Did you start this pre-AI? One issue with AI answers that will likely persist is data staleness. Having a site like this would help users find the "source" and ask actual users perhaps?
ChaitanyaSai··on Ask HN: Share concrete examples of benefits from AI usage
How?
ChaitanyaSai··on The Abstraction Fallacy: Why AI can simulate but not instantiate consciousness
Consciousness is an engineering problem not a philosophical one. How do you get a tiny fraction of the many billion experiences that cohere to create your self to listen to, and decide what sensory data to turn into your next experience?

The engineering problem is that this decentralised moment to moment consensus has to span the galactic distance of your mind (from the perspective of a neuron) and do it fast and cheap (on a tiny metabolic budget)

You might like our book Journey of the Mind if you'd rather skip the onerous philosophical jargon and get a systems neuroscience perspective

https://saigaddam.medium.com/consciousness-is-a-consensus-me...

ChaitanyaSai··on I've been waiting over a month for Anthropic to respond to my billing issue
It's been more than a year for us in India. We've resorted to using openrouter. How is Mythos or whatever their latest is not realizing that this is a priority - customers WANT to pay you and cannot!
ChaitanyaSai··on Who is Satoshi Nakamoto? My quest to unmask Bitcoin's creator
Here's my armchair two cents: Whoever it is, has to be British. The language is unmistakeably British or Commonwealth. It's likely him. I'd wager if there was a polymarket bet. But I also feel for him. Does this make him a target for both half-wit criminials and rogue nation states?
ChaitanyaSai··on I am definitely missing the pre-AI writing era
I am sorry but perhaps some use of AI or grammar-check would help? A lawn that's not overly manicured has its charm, but if it has one too many barren patches of clumps of overgrown grass, it doesn't appeal as much? This essay feels a bit like that.
ChaitanyaSai··on Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conversation between humans
Huh wow just noticing it. That was definitely my own writing. Kinda sad I failed the captcha
ChaitanyaSai··on Regular army and reserve components enlistment program: Summary of change
I thought you were joking about the date! They actually picked that one :)
ChaitanyaSai··on Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conversation between humans
AI has made it easier for me not to worry about how pretty or polished my comments are. What used to be a sign you cared has now been devalued nearly completely by AI. This is freeing and allows me to think about the substance. I still do read it, but don't care too much about the typos. It's now a a proud badge for artisanal thinking!
ChaitanyaSai··on Show HN: DenchClaw – Local CRM on Top of OpenClaw
Ah, that makes a lot of sense!

(Do not use imessage, a Whatsapp user, and we can access that through the browser, which means you can plug it into an extension)

ChaitanyaSai··on Show HN: DenchClaw – Local CRM on Top of OpenClaw
Question: Why do people want to do this with their mac mini? Can you not do all of this with a hosted VM instance? A mic mini makes it easier for people to set up? Everything still has to talk to data on the cloud right?
ChaitanyaSai··on Nano Banana 2: Google's latest AI image generation model
Agree. But there are some use-cases where images can still be of huge help. Making textbooks come alive for instance. We are trying to do that and make a whole bunch of Indian textbooks into comics and free for students. (zerobyheart.com if anyone's interested and would like to make suggestions; the panel-to-panel continuity is still off and something we are working on )
ChaitanyaSai··on I don't know how you get here from “predict the next word”
The whole next word thing is interesting isn't it. I like to see it with Dennett's "Competence and comprehension" lens. You can predict the next word competently with shallow understanding. But you could also do it well with understanding or comprehension of the full picture. A mental model that allows you to predict better. Are the AIs stumbling into these mental models? Seems like it. However, because these are such black boxes, we do not know how they are stringing these mental models together. Is it a random pick from 10 models built up inside the weights? Is there any system-wide cohesive understanding, whatever that means? Exploring what a model can articualate using self-reflection would be interesting. Can it point to internal cognitive dissonance because it has been fed both evolution and intelligent design, for example? Or these exist as separate models to invoke depending on the prompt context, because all that matters is being rewarded by the current user?
ChaitanyaSai··on Terence Tao, at 8 years old (1984) [pdf]
Fascinating read! And very interesting in the light of recent advances in AI to think about what makes this ability possible. How far can we go with increasing long-term memory and working memory? Does increasing comprehension follow with competence?

Long-term retention is is hard when encountering new symbols. He seemed quite comfortable at that age absorbing the new stuff and manipulating it. Where does that comfort come from? Is there a way to test that explicitly? Finally, there is the ability to take the new and use it well. What about creating new shorthand? Being able to divine hidden patterns and articulate them?

Ramunujam seems to have had this.

ChaitanyaSai··on Anthropic officially bans using subscription auth for third party use
OK I hope someone from anthropic reads this. Your API billing makes it really hard to work with it in India. We've had to switch to openrouter because anthropic keeps rejecting all the cards we have tried. And these are major Indian banks. This has been going on for MONTHS
← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →